Teach myself guitar?

2»

Comments

  • Pearl_Juli wrote:
    I really need to get back to basics, and learn the essentials instead of just reading a tab and learning a song.


    That's typical, Pearl Juli, and hello!


    Everyone's different in how they approach learning. Some people have the knack to learn via ear, some need to see it on paper, or in a book, and some need a live person to show them the ropes.

    Remember if you're self taught, you're learning from someone who doesn't know what they're doing! :D

    I think getting a teacher that you like will put you farther ahead than someone without a teacher, because if you get some of the basics in you, then you build on them, rather than plunk away at stuff from a TAB site THEN get the basics.
    A good teacher should show you how to practice most efficiently. I think the time invested into learning the basics is far less than the time people spend on the computer trying to get the tab for each song. It takes time to learn the basics up front, but then you have them,,, and in most cases you won't need the TAB.

    There ARE some good DVD's out there and that can work, because you can plug that thing in whenever you have time, but you have to have the discipline to do it.

    If you want to help ear training, one thing I used to tell students is to at least:

    1) Learn to barre the E and A formation major chords all the way up the neck. That takes some strength training but it's great to know.


    E formation

    Letter on the left is the string, Number on the right is the fret
    On an open E, the 0 is an open string.
    On a barre chord, the 0's will be your index finger struggling to barre across all the strings. :D

    E -0
    B-0
    G-1 < middle finger
    D-2 <pinky
    A-2 <ring finger
    E-0

    A formation:

    E-0
    B-2 < pinky
    G-2 < ring
    D-2 < middle
    A-0
    E-0

    2) Learn all the notes on the low E string and A string frets.
    The note on the low E string is the root of the chord in the E formation.
    The note on the A string is the root of the chord in A position.

    For instance, when you're playing a barred E position chord at the 7th fret, you are actually playing a B chord.

    3) Now listen to a song you want to learn and find the key by fretting the E string up to what the general sound matches and voila,,, that's the general chord that's being played.
    Use trial and error and soon your ears and your hands will mesh and you will be released from looking up TAB in most cases.

    4) Now learn the Em, E7 , Eminor7th,,,Am, A7 and A minor7th positions and you have just about all rock and roll chords right there.

    Em:

    E-0
    B-0
    G-0
    D-2
    A-2
    E-0

    E7th:

    E-0
    B-0
    G-1
    D-0
    A-2
    E-0

    E minor 7th:

    E-0
    B-0
    G-0
    D-0
    A-1
    E-0

    A Minor:

    E-0
    B-1
    G-2
    D-2
    A-0
    E-x

    A 7th

    E-0
    B-2
    G-0
    D-2
    A-0
    E-x

    A minor 7th

    E-0
    B-1
    G-0
    D-2
    A-0
    E-x

    Those aren't hard to learn to barre after you get the major chords down, but then you'll have some basics.

    If you listen to the sound of an E7, E minor, E minor 7th enough, for instance, you WILL recognize what chord it is sooner than you think, without even playing it.

    There are MANY different ways to play all those chords, but they are basic ways, and that should keep beginners busy for a day or so! :D



    Ok, this post took a long time to type! I missed lunch!
    Be kind, man
    Don't be mankind. ~Captain Beefheart
    __________________________________
  • ^ bob why do you use your pinky to play E and A? :confused:
    Come on pilgrim you know he loves you..

    http://www.wishlistfoundation.org

    Oh my, they dropped the leash.



    Morgan Freeman/Clint Eastwood 08' for President!

    "Make our day"
  • I'm getting by, I dont have school lessons for a while, so I'm using internet lessons. Its going ok. I guess just playing a guitar is practice.
    no matter where you go,
    there you are.

    - brain of c
  • stu gee
    stu gee Posts: 1,174
    I have two accoustic guitars given to me by my dad but i have never got round to even attempting to learn them. Its my 22nd birthday in about 4 weeks and the only thing ive asked for is a few lessons, ive been told that its good to learn by youself but i think i would like just a few lessons at least to point me in the right direction and then take it from there.

    Some of my friends are really good and havent even been playing a year, while others i know have been playing since they were kids and arent good at all. Think it all comes down to dedication and really wanting to play.
    People say im paranoid. Well, they dont say it, but i know that's what they are thinking.
  • ^ bob why do you use your pinky to play E and A? :confused:


    It's not the only way I play them, but it frees up your index finger to barre those chords up the neck.
    It's also good to learn to play the open C , and G chords without your index finger for the same reasons. You can barre them, too.
    It stretches out that pinky and strengthens it up for playing lead, too!
    Be kind, man
    Don't be mankind. ~Captain Beefheart
    __________________________________
  • It's not the only way I play them, but it frees up your index finger to barre those chords up the neck.
    It's also good to learn to play the open C , and G chords without your index finger for the same reasons. You can barre them, too.
    It stretches out that pinky and strengthens it up for playing lead, too!
    oh i see what you're doing.

    I play that formation like that too, but I don't use my pinky when i'm just playing the open E and A.
    Come on pilgrim you know he loves you..

    http://www.wishlistfoundation.org

    Oh my, they dropped the leash.



    Morgan Freeman/Clint Eastwood 08' for President!

    "Make our day"
  • oh i see what you're doing.

    I play that formation like that too, but I don't use my pinky when i'm just playing the open E and A.

    I usually play A by barring my ring finger, or index across three strings, but I don't want everyone to have my bad habits! :mrgreen:

    I usually play the open chords with my index middle and ring, but doing it with the other fingers is good to get you in position if you're barring.




    Haha,,,, I have to sit here an play a guitar to figure out how I'm playing! I can't explain it without looking at my fingers! :D
    Be kind, man
    Don't be mankind. ~Captain Beefheart
    __________________________________
  • I really wish I was better at guitar. Its just finding the time to practice.
    no matter where you go,
    there you are.

    - brain of c
  • I usually play A by barring my ring finger, or index across three strings, but I don't want everyone to have my bad habits! :mrgreen:

    I usually play the open chords with my index middle and ring, but doing it with the other fingers is good to get you in position if you're barring.




    Haha,,,, I have to sit here an play a guitar to figure out how I'm playing! I can't explain it without looking at my fingers! :D
    haha yeah when I read you were using your pinky I went..

    "huh?... do i..?... wait... what?" and ran over to my guitar to see if I do it too. :p
    Come on pilgrim you know he loves you..

    http://www.wishlistfoundation.org

    Oh my, they dropped the leash.



    Morgan Freeman/Clint Eastwood 08' for President!

    "Make our day"
  • haha yeah when I read you were using your pinky I went..

    "huh?... do i..?... wait... what?" and ran over to my guitar to see if I do it too. :p


    I'm like that. I've been playing for so damn long I forget how to play! :)

    I'm actually going to take some lessons coming up.
    The University of the Arts here in Philadelphia has a great jazz guitar program. I can play a lot of jazz, but this is taught by Pat Martino! :cool:
    That dude is smokin'!!!
    He has a whole theory of all chords coming out of the diminished chord formula, and it changes the way you approach chord structure.

    Haha,, back to school at 52 years old! He's older than me, though.
    Be kind, man
    Don't be mankind. ~Captain Beefheart
    __________________________________
  • Never too late! :cool:
    Come on pilgrim you know he loves you..

    http://www.wishlistfoundation.org

    Oh my, they dropped the leash.



    Morgan Freeman/Clint Eastwood 08' for President!

    "Make our day"
  • Never too late! :cool:

    Exactly! Pat Martino is one of the most amazing jazz players out there, and I saw he was teaching a class, so I figured I'd sign up. Might as well play with the best!
    You have to know how to read and know theory and audition to get into his classes, too.
    Be kind, man
    Don't be mankind. ~Captain Beefheart
    __________________________________
  • I really wish I was better at guitar. Its just finding the time to practice.

    That's a common problem. Finding time. Which is exactly why I stress that you have to try to learn to practice properly. A good teacher can help, or the program that ,,,, hell, the name escapes me! It's great, too!
    DOH!!! :(

    Enharmonic will know if he signs in because he's mentioned it, too, or I'll look it up.

    But you have to focus on your practice and not wander around diddling into licks and out of them. Learning in 20 minute chunks of time is good, too. It gives what you've learned time to sink in, and doesn't get as boring if you're running scales, or learning triads. etc.
    Be kind, man
    Don't be mankind. ~Captain Beefheart
    __________________________________
  • i taught myself...i think it's definitely about being able to find the time...i think i would have learned faster if i had lessons since i would have more likely committed the time to practice before i met up with a teacher...so for me it took a couple of years. i didn't have the patience for the basics (which i sometimes regret) and i don’t know how to read notes, so i found it easiest to use tab since it tells you where to put your fingers. i basically found a tab and started trying to play it. the first song i learned was time of your life by green day, for some reason I just really wanted to be able to play it but actually after how long it took me i don’t suggest that as a starter song,…then to learn how to play barre chords i stuck with hail, hail....over and over and over again until i got the hang of it. since i didn't know anyone else who played at the time that i was learning, it wasn't until about a year after that that i discovered that i have the wrong finger placement for barre chords and it's so hard to switch now but it works for me. so yah, i totally suggest teaching yourself, there are lots of sites that can explain the basics and tab to you and it’s the cheapest way…plus i have found that people who know how to play are always willing to give advice about it too...if you like it you'll stick with it…good luck!
    08/22/98; 10/04/00; 10/05/00; 10/07/00; 05/02/03; 06/25/03; 06/28/03; 06/29/03; 09/11/05; 09/12/05; 09/13/05; 09/16/05; 09/19/05; 05/09/06; 05/10/06; 06/15/09; 08/21/09; 09/21/09; 09/25/09...
  • Pearl Juli
    Pearl Juli Posts: 1,213
    That's typical, Pearl Juli, and hello!


    Everyone's different in how they approach learning. Some people have the knack to learn via ear, some need to see it on paper, or in a book, and some need a live person to show them the ropes.

    Remember if you're self taught, you're learning from someone who doesn't know what they're doing! :D

    I think getting a teacher that you like will put you farther ahead than someone without a teacher, because if you get some of the basics in you, then you build on them, rather than plunk away at stuff from a TAB site THEN get the basics.
    A good teacher should show you how to practice most efficiently. I think the time invested into learning the basics is far less than the time people spend on the computer trying to get the tab for each song. It takes time to learn the basics up front, but then you have them,,, and in most cases you won't need the TAB.

    There ARE some good DVD's out there and that can work, because you can plug that thing in whenever you have time, but you have to have the discipline to do it.

    If you want to help ear training, one thing I used to tell students is to at least:

    1) Learn to barre the E and A formation major chords all the way up the neck. That takes some strength training but it's great to know.


    E formation

    Letter on the left is the string, Number on the right is the fret
    On an open E, the 0 is an open string.
    On a barre chord, the 0's will be your index finger struggling to barre across all the strings. :D

    E -0
    B-0
    G-1 < middle finger
    D-2 <pinky
    A-2 <ring finger
    E-0

    A formation:

    E-0
    B-2 < pinky
    G-2 < ring
    D-2 < middle
    A-0
    E-0

    2) Learn all the notes on the low E string and A string frets.
    The note on the low E string is the root of the chord in the E formation.
    The note on the A string is the root of the chord in A position.

    For instance, when you're playing a barred E position chord at the 7th fret, you are actually playing a B chord.

    3) Now listen to a song you want to learn and find the key by fretting the E string up to what the general sound matches and voila,,, that's the general chord that's being played.
    Use trial and error and soon your ears and your hands will mesh and you will be released from looking up TAB in most cases.

    4) Now learn the Em, E7 , Eminor7th,,,Am, A7 and A minor7th positions and you have just about all rock and roll chords right there.

    Em:

    E-0
    B-0
    G-0
    D-2
    A-2
    E-0

    E7th:

    E-0
    B-0
    G-1
    D-0
    A-2
    E-0

    E minor 7th:

    E-0
    B-0
    G-0
    D-0
    A-1
    E-0

    A Minor:

    E-0
    B-1
    G-2
    D-2
    A-0
    E-x

    A 7th

    E-0
    B-2
    G-0
    D-2
    A-0
    E-x

    A minor 7th

    E-0
    B-1
    G-0
    D-2
    A-0
    E-x

    Those aren't hard to learn to barre after you get the major chords down, but then you'll have some basics.

    If you listen to the sound of an E7, E minor, E minor 7th enough, for instance, you WILL recognize what chord it is sooner than you think, without even playing it.

    There are MANY different ways to play all those chords, but they are basic ways, and that should keep beginners busy for a day or so! :D



    Ok, this post took a long time to type! I missed lunch!

    Hello there! :D

    Thank you so much for your reply :) It was very helpful. I saved your post, and I'm gonna get to it as soon as I change strings. I broke the high E...it always seems to be the only one that breaks :o
    MISSION ACCOMPLISHED: 2008-06-11

    ♪ Juli ♪
  • DOSW
    DOSW Posts: 2,014
    That's a common problem. Finding time. Which is exactly why I stress that you have to try to learn to practice properly. A good teacher can help, or the program that ,,,, hell, the name escapes me! It's great, too!
    DOH!!! :(

    Enharmonic will know if he signs in because he's mentioned it, too, or I'll look it up.

    But you have to focus on your practice and not wander around diddling into licks and out of them. Learning in 20 minute chunks of time is good, too. It gives what you've learned time to sink in, and doesn't get as boring if you're running scales, or learning triads. etc.

    Yep. It's not about how much time you have to practice. It's about how you use your practice time.

    Here's an article about effective practicing: http://www.ultimate-guitar.com/columns/general_music/an_analysis_of_suck.html

    I read another one too that was a little better than that, but I can't find it. That one is a good article, though.
    It's a town full of losers and I'm pulling out of here to win