Pearl Jam Vs. Pink Floyd

2»

Comments

  • IWillLiveForeve
    IWillLiveForeve Posts: 427
    I BrisK I wrote:
    please lets not ruin this thread with stupid notions.

    I second that notion. Corgan still blows.
  • Brisk.
    Brisk. Posts: 11,578
    IWillLiveForeve wrote:
    I second that notion. Corgan still blows.

    He does not blow, he is a brilliant muscian.

    /End.
  • IWillLiveForeve
    IWillLiveForeve Posts: 427
    I BrisK I wrote:
    He does not blow, he is a brilliant muscian.

    /End.

    Go sell crazy some place else. He is a hack.
  • Brisk.
    Brisk. Posts: 11,578
    IWillLiveForeve wrote:
    Go sell crazy some place else. He is a hack.

    porque?
  • IWillLiveForeve
    IWillLiveForeve Posts: 427
    I BrisK I wrote:
    porque?

    because whining, screaming, and acting disenfranchised has been done. That music has no soul. If you can't tell that he doesn't create from the heart, then I have a kick ass piece of ocean front property in Nebraska I'd like to sell you.
  • Brisk.
    Brisk. Posts: 11,578
    IWillLiveForeve wrote:
    because whining, screaming, and acting disenfranchised has been done. That music has no soul. If you can't tell that he doesn't create from the heart, then I have a kick ass piece of ocean front property in Nebraska I'd like to sell you.

    Have you seen the vieuphoria dvd, have you seen any pumpkins shows (specifically from the actual pumpkins era) and have you even seen any interviews or the stuff he writes on the website and especially the old BC website.

    He may not have the greatest voice ever, but neither does ozzy and black sabbath fucking pwn. I actually quite like Billy's voice, it can sound quite soft and nice e.g. Luna etc and very angry when the song is needed e.g. fuck you.

    "Destroy the mind, destroy the body, but you cannot destroy the heart" .

    EDIT - if you listen to all the albums, there is such a diverse style of music, its not just this screaming hard psychedelic rock - e.g. in the arms of sleep, disarm, farewell and goodnight, we only come out at night, 33, galopagas, cupid de locke, by starlight, tonight tonight to an extent.

    Also i own over 400 shows and the amount of times a song like today has been reworked shows an extrememe amount of passion for the music as they arn't constantly playing the hit songs, even on the reunion tour they reworked it and added a solo on the end. And you talk about soul, if you want to see it in the sartorial discourse then just look at the stage attire, its quite a humurous range and original.

    EDIT EDIT -

    Oh yeh, "no soul" is playing 3 hour shows with no support.
  • IWillLiveForeve
    IWillLiveForeve Posts: 427
    I BrisK I wrote:
    Have you seen the vieuphoria dvd, have you seen any pumpkins shows (specifically from the actual pumpkins era) and have you even seen any interviews or the stuff he writes on the website and especially the old BC website.

    He may not have the greatest voice ever, but neither does ozzy and black sabbath fucking pwn. I actually quite like Billy's voice, it can sound quite soft and nice e.g. Luna etc and very angry when the song is needed e.g. fuck you.

    "Destroy the mind, destroy the body, but you cannot destroy the heart" .

    Actually I have seen several shows. That band defines 'going through the motions'. There is a reason they have faded. Thank god. They had the heart of a tit mouse.
  • McCready00
    McCready00 Posts: 371
    Found it on Youtube. Interesting. They did it in their own way and kept the feeling of the original song. I liked it man !
    -"it's times like these you have to ask yourself, "what would mike mccready do"
  • Brisk.
    Brisk. Posts: 11,578
    if anyone wants it i'll pm them the link, rather than craptube ;p
  • IWillLiveForeve
    IWillLiveForeve Posts: 427
    McCready00 wrote:
    Found it on Youtube. Interesting. They did it in their own way and kept the feeling of the original song. I liked it man !
    wow
  • pjamaholic
    pjamaholic Posts: 1,225
    jeffbr wrote:
    This is a pearl jam board, I would expect them to win. But they really have nothing to do with one another. Different eras, different impact and influence, different music, different musicianship. If I had to pick I'd go with the Floyd, but why would I want to have to pick? I probably listen to more PJ than Floyd right now, but if I could only take one band's music with me to a desert island, I'd take Pink Floyd.


    I've seen both bands live, Floyd in '92 and PJ in '03 and '06. Floyd were the most incredible band both on their albums and to see live and I still love their music today. They are one of my all time most favourite bands. However if I had the choice of seeing Pink Floyd live again, or Pearl Jam, I'd pick Pearl Jam every time.
  • Anon
    Anon Posts: 11,175
    pjamaholic wrote:
    However if I had the choice of seeing Pink Floyd live again, or Pearl Jam, I'd pick Pearl Jam every time.

    Yes...I saw Floyd (sans Waters) twice in the '80s...they were great...and both bands are hugely important to me personally, but that's the way I'd put it too.

    Of course, it doesn't seem like we'll be getting the choice to see Floyd ever again.

    However, I saw the Australian Pink Floyd Experience once, and they were quite good.
  • TheDecline13
    TheDecline13 Posts: 990
    PJ 1st round KO!
    Tour with fucking NOFX

Categories