Eddie as a songwriter

Red Mosquito75 · January 2011

I have loved Pearl Jam since the beginning so I guess I am biased when is comes to all things PJ. I have been talking to some of my friends and others about Pearl Jam and the lyrics. They are somewhat fans of the band but not die hard. I said that I believed Eddie was a great song writer and probably going to go down as one of the greatest song writers of all time. I know that is a huge thing to say. I really believe it. They laughed. My friends sad I was full of it and they didn't think he was that good of a song writer. I think a lot of non die hard fans don't look too much at his lyrics. Which is a shame. Still I believe when it is all said and done he will go down as one of the greatest song writers of all time or at the very least my generation. Any thoughts?

rafie · January 2011

I think that at times he is more of a poet. Just look at the lyrics from ITW!

Red Mosquito75 · January 2011

rafie wrote:

I think that at times he is more of a poet. Just look at the lyrics from ITW!

I think so too. I believe Bob Dylan is a poet also...in turn the two are great song writers...Is it that we the die hard fans are the only ones that think that of Ed or do others also?

bignumpty · January 2011

I have had similar conversation's with many people in the UK, many of whom are surprised to hear Pearl Jam are still going!!
However, I am of the opinion that music is very personal medium and different character's have different taste's, not just music, but fashion, TV, sport etc.

Ed should be regarded with the great's, in my ears he already is.

Violin · January 2011

I think that the lyrics of Eddie are strongly related with some experience of his life, who don't know, can't understand the poetry of his words. For me he is poet!!!

Leezestarr313 · January 2011

I also think he is a great poet. He helped me improve my English as well - when I started learning English at school I remember I sat there with the PJ booklets and tried to translate the lyrics because I wanted to know what was behind the music

And I am still amazed by their subtleness, power and poetry.

For me, the music was first (I didn't know English then) - but the lyrics pulled me deeper into the whole thing ...

AELARA · January 2011

Leeze wrote:

I also think he is a great poet. He helped me improve my English as well - when I started learning English at school I remember I sat there with the PJ booklets and tried to translate the lyrics because I wanted to know what was behind the music And I am still amazed by their subtleness, power and poetry.

For me, the music was first (I didn't know English then) - but the lyrics pulled me deeper into the whole thing ...

Me too! I usually want to know what my favourite songs are talking about so I always try to translate them. PJ songs have helped me improve my English. And yes, I think Eddie is a great songwriter and why not, a poet. But I understand that it's a matter of taste after all..

OHtheRitual · January 2011

rafie wrote:

I think that at times he is more of a poet. Just look at the lyrics from ITW!

ITW is a very poetic album..but I believe his is a songwriter first and foremost..put a guitar into that boy's hands, and thats when the poetry comes out..

tremors · February 2011

I think Eddie is one of the strongest songwriters there is, as well as one of the strongest singers - and it is the bond between his words and his voice which makes him so special. A word becomes a reality when he sings it. There are only a few songwriters who I think their words work just to read and not hear - Bob Dylan is probably the best example of this. I think some of Eddie's songs fall into this category, but that is not his forte.

What I have got most from Eddie's songs over the years is that he uses words which are deep conceptually, and concepts which are profound - but he uses them in a natural way - so unless you are paying attention they can just roll right by you. When you do pay attention though, they can seriously expand your mind, your horizons, and help you to get perspective and understanding on some very challenging situations you have to confront in real life. For this reason he is my favourite songwriter, for the words and the songs can always be applied to 'life', and don't just operate in a bubble in the song. Many of the songs carry much more weight when you have experienced situations in the real world. Kurt Cobain's songs I always found were weaker, because although they sound smart and sound real - they are often in my view kind of cartoony, and not based in the real world. For example, as a song to evoke the realities of mental illness - Lithium is more glamorous, romantic, sexy maybe, but Why Go or Off he goes go deeper in drawing from real life experience, rather than the imagination I believe, and I am pretty informed on this subject - and in the words of Hendrix, I have been experienced.

So I think Eddie's songwriting genius lies in his ability to translate traumatic real life experiences into words and sounds which not only communicate an experience, but almost always brings with it the understanding, passion, hope and energy necessary to rise above the experience. This is a rare talent - and whilst there may be better songwriters on paper, I don't believe there is anyone better at writing and singing songs that can lead to breakthrough and catharsis in the listener, and in penetrating difficult subjects with a deep, natural and profound insight and understanding.

dawnella · February 2011

I agree that he is a great songwriter and poet. I've been listening to PJ since they have been out. The funny thing is I had an accident and lost my memory. I got it back playing a PJ cd.How ironic.

Attaway77 · March 2011

It's Eddie fkn Vedder.... He is what science has tried to figure out how does man carry tiger blood...(no offense Charlie Sheen, love Major League).. I don't consider him a poet, I consider him a musician.. I like Jack Kerouac and Hunter S. Thompson and consider them writers. And as it is they are in history as writers. Eddie fkn Vedder will go down as one of the greatest musicians..

ShimmyMommy · March 2011

Eddie is awesome, anyway you see it.

The only reason anyone cannot see that in his songwriting is because they aren't listening to the lyrics and feeling the music. I must say, my husband thought PJ was OK, until I had him read the lyrics as poems first and then have him listen to the songs. It ended up changing him, literally. He can now completely relate to the songs in the same way I do. In fact, Eddie's songwriting/poetry ended up changing our marriage for the better.

The other factor is, do your friends want to hear the underlying messages? Are they ready to hear what the songs will tell them about themselves? It can only touch those who are ready, like my husband, and myself, all those many years ago.

My key is to be aware that when a song evokes a strong emotion for me, it has something to teach me. In all respects, EV's is the only musician that can completely move me like that.

pandora · March 2011

For me, one doesn't realize how gifted he is until they try to write themselves.

He is a master.
I am continually blown away by his thoughts.

He is powerful and very connected to whatever that creative place is ....
that comes from beyond....like revelations.... like genius.

I am thankful daily that he speaks to my very soul because Lord knows I can't put the words together.
Very gratifying and satisfying ...love you Eddie!

ShimmyMommy · March 2011

pandora wrote:

For me, one doesn't realize how gifted he is until they try to write themselves.

He is a master.
I am continually blown away by his thoughts.

He is powerful and very connected to whatever that creative place is ....
that comes from beyond....like revelations.... like genius.

I am thankful daily that he speaks to my very soul because Lord knows I can't put the words together.
Very gratifying and satisfying ...love you Eddie!

YES, AGREE 100% :thumbup:

Staggering Genius · March 2011

pandora wrote:

For me, one doesn't realize how gifted he is until they try to write themselves.

He is a master.
I am continually blown away by his thoughts.

He is powerful and very connected to whatever that creative place is ....
that comes from beyond....like revelations.... like genius.

I am thankful daily that he speaks to my very soul because Lord knows I can't put the words together.
Very gratifying and satisfying ...love you Eddie!

Wonderful post. I completely agree. His words have helped me express emotions I don't think I could have been able to understand or convey even to myself.

Got a hard hard head · March 2011

Read some of Eddie's lyrics.

Then, try to write a song of your own based on your life experiences.

Read Eddie's lyrics again.

The man is a genius and should be held in as high a regard as a songwriter as...well, I won't say who I'm thinking of to spare any arguing...

VedHead2 · March 2011

pandora wrote:

For me, one doesn't realize how gifted he is until they try to write themselves.

He is a master.
I am continually blown away by his thoughts.

He is powerful and very connected to whatever that creative place is ....
that comes from beyond....like revelations.... like genius.

I am thankful daily that he speaks to my very soul because Lord knows I can't put the words together.
Very gratifying and satisfying ...love you Eddie!

completely agree..People don't take the time to listen. I can't help wanting to make everyone listen! And it really ticks me off that most people have no idea what they are missing...

titchinello · March 2011

I agree too, Eddie's lyrics to me seem more poetic, and emotional, and at time very personal. stuff that most of us ordinary day folk can relate to in one way or another.
and i may be speaking out of my ass, and kick it if i'm wrong, but he reminds me of jim morrison, not that i'm too familiar with the doors, but from what i've read and heard, but as i say i might be talking crap on this one.

ShimmyMommy · March 2011

I freakin' love Longing to Belong. I don't care what anyone else thinks. It's right on the mark for me.

and when the time is right, i
hope that you'll respond
like when the wind gets tired
the ocean becomes calm
i may be dreaming but i'm
longing to belong
to you

hockeygrrl · March 2011

Eddie is a poet. A musician. A MAGICIAN. He has long spoken words that I have needed to say. He weaves words into intricate patterns. I am always trying to spout the deepness and the meaning of PJ and Eddie, and it mostly falls on deaf ears. Since I was 12 years old, Eddie has been speaking to me and for me.

keepnfaith44 · March 2011

Not that anyone who has heard Eddie's songs needs backing heres a site that I use often for Music info and history based on this fairly well respected and what i would consider unbiased and pretty fair and open minded site he is in good company!

http://digitaldreamdoor.com/pages/best_lyricists.html

Eddie as a songwriter

Comments

Categories