Supernova

Where's everyone's reviews and opinions from tonite's show???

so who went home?

jezebeloria wrote:

Storm...about time imo

i definitely agree.

I am with Toby, he really interacts with the crowd. But I think that Magni really fits the image that they are looking for.

aBoxOfFear wrote:

headspin is the worst song of this year. lucas - you make my ears bleed. and if you don't get voted off tonight, i'm going to throw my tv off the balcony.

Was that the loud crash I heard around 8:55PM?

Head Spin isn't too bad a song. Plus remember they can't vote off the guy who already has the job.

Damn I knew Brooke was preggers, said it to my wife weeks ago when her clothes became a little baggier.

i liked storm's "wish you wre here" and the dedication to her mom. i have a feeling the band had already made their decision before the performances...seemed like newkid was emotional while she was doing the tune and after. he may have an emotional attachment to the song, though...who knows...i'm sure many of us do.

dilana finally seemed to be having fun again. i thought she did a great job on the cheap trick tune. the crowd seemed to dig it and so did navarro and the band. good on her.

i went to take a dump while lukas was doing his original again.

civ_eng_girl wrote:

poor Jason... looked like he was crying... i just wanted to give him big ol' hug!

i was actually kinda sad to see Storm go... she really won me over with What The F*** Is Ladylike... that was a pretty kick ass tune, and I would have rather had that as an encore than Uh Oh Uh Oh oh oh.....

I like Toby, but i don't think it's fair that they always pick on everyone else for not 'changing up' their performance, when Toby makes the same rounds around the crowd... to the contestants stage, to the back, to Supernova's stage, and back again.... every night!

i agree, ceg...well except giving jason a hug...oh what the hell, i'd give the newkid a hug

mookie blaylock 10 wrote:

i liked storm's "wish you wre here" and the dedication to her mom. i have a feeling the band had already made their decision before the performances...seemed like newkid was emotional while she was doing the tune and after. he may have an emotional attachment to the song, though...who knows...i'm sure many of us do.

dilana finally seemed to be having fun again. i thought she did a great job on the cheap trick tune. the crowd seemed to dig it and so did navarro and the band. good on her.

i went to take a dump while lukas was doing his original again.

I said the same thing about Dilana... after a few weeks of seeing her going at about 50% mentally, she looked like she just dropped all the baggage and had fun again. Too bad she has to hop through every song lol... but hey, she is final 4 and based on how she often carried the show at times she SHOULD be, although she won't win.

Toby might be making SN think they need a high energy, girl magnet guy like Toby... Its nice that his song is catchy, but that kind of a song gets skipped on my mix CD's after a couple weeks of hearing it (if it gets on it as track #18 ). Something too "shallow" about his performance and style, but considering what product is out there today, he is pretty good. Also, SN's sound seems to fit him. But Lukas gives SN an entirely different, dirtier sound which they may like more.

Lukas did his original again... meh. Not a bad song, but we just heard it. I was hoping Storm would get the encore, was surprised Toby did after getting it recently for a carbon copy performance.

It was Storm's time to go. I really like the charisma she brought, as did SN or her cabaret style would have been gone a long time ago. Made a Metallica guy CRY on National TV! That should be on her concert posters

Final 4:

Magni: great voice, personality... but overall delivers a plain, repetetive performance. I predict 4th (if they break it down like that)

Dilana: Like they said, she was running away with it... but she crumbled under pressure after some ill-advised comments to the press. They havent said anything bad about her performances really, and genuinely love the creativity she brought to the stage. 3rd

Toby: Figured he was a top 5 guy from the beginning, but didnt do much for me voice-wise. His performances have been among the best the past 4 weeks or so, and I can actually see him singing with SN. High energy, good guy. 2nd by a hair

Lukas: Love him or hate him... has great presence and a unique delivery. Seems musically creative and lyrically as well. He takes the 70's rock sound of SN and makes it dirtier, which I think is what they want. I dont like his hyper-growling at times and I think his voice may not hold up for a 2 hour concert, but a studio album would probably sound pretty cool. I like when bands have a unique sound, something Magni or Toby wouldnt give them. Lukas, from day 1 really, seems like the best fit... even though their songs are hardly heavy rock. WINNER.

I liked Storm's Pink Floyd song, she did a good job...had the feeling she was going to be the one to go though, I just can't see a female fronting that band for some reason

Like Toby and Dilona, lots of energy, she showed some gutts going out there even in pain, she reminds me of Janis Joplin though and just don't know if she will appeal to the younger crowd for very long; Toby gets the crowd going

Still don't like Lukas, just can't see him fronting this band

Magni is great, not as dramatic and energetic as alot of them but his vocals are good, I just like him overall

because they already decided she would go home this week no matter what. I think she should have at least won the car.

moemoe6434 wrote:

they said storm's original song performance was the best so far this year or any year..... so why did she go home? that did not add up.