Robert Plant named 23rd worst lyricist of All Time by Blender

thecrackedjack
thecrackedjack Posts: 148
edited October 2007 in Other Music
...in their 40 worst lyricists of all time. Another terrible list.

http://www.blender.com/guide/articles.aspx?ID=2882

1) Sting (solo, The Police)
2) Neil Peart (Rush)
3) Scott Stapp (Creed)
4) Noel Gallagher (Oasis)
5) Dan Fogelberg
6) Tom Marshall (Phish friend [ not member ])
7) Paul Stanley (KISS)
8) Diane Warren ("I Don't Want to Miss a Thing", "How Can We Be Lovers?", "Have You Ever?")
9) Donovan
10) Jim Morrison (The Doors)

11) Larry Henley and Jeff Silbar ("Wind Beneath My Wings")
12) David Crosby (sometimes of Crosby, Stills & Nash [ & Young ])
13) Pete Gabriel, Mike Rutherford, Tony Banks, Steve Hackett and Phil Collins (aka Genesis, but also including their respective solo projects)
14) will.i.am (Black Eyed Peas)
15) Bernie Taupin (lyricist for Elton John and... "We Built This City")
16) Ben Gibbard (Death Cab for Cutie)
17) Jon Anderson (Yes)
18) Ian Anderson (Jethro Tull)
19) Queensrÿche
20) Ryan Ross (Panic! At the Disco)

21) Alanis Morissette
22) Jon Bon Jovi
23) Robert Plant (Led Zeppelin)
24) Fred Durst (Limp Bizkit)
25) KRS-One
26) Simon Le Bon (Duran Duran)
27) Will Jennings (lyricist, "My Heart Will Go On", "Up Where We Belong", "Tears in Heaven", etc.)
28) Greg Graffin (Bad Religion)
29) Timbaland
30) Kevin Federline (aka K-Fed)

31) Carly Simon
32) Matisyahu
33) Diddy (aka P. Diddy aka Puffy aka Puff Daddy)
34) Henry Rollins (Black Flag, Rollins Band)
35) Dashboard Confessional
36) Common
37) Bryan Adams
38) Paul McCartney (The Beatles, solo)
39) Billy Corgan (Smashing Pumpkins, Zwan, solo)
40) Anthony Kiedis (Red Hot Chili Peppers)
Post edited by Unknown User on
«13

Comments

  • FinsburyParkCarrots
    FinsburyParkCarrots Seattle, WA Posts: 12,223
    That's daft. He's no Dylan or Kevin Coyne, but he's better than most of the people on that "list".

    Why wasn't Pete Doherty listed?
  • Them-Bones
    Them-Bones Posts: 518
    Yea these were the same people who said Blind Melon and The Doors were two of the worst bands of all time, the homeless guy who lives by my house has more crediblity.

    and I guess according to Blender, K-Fed writes better lyrics than Jim Morrison
    yea thats smart.
    "If my thoughts, dreams, could be seen, they'd probably put my head, in a guillotine, but it's alright ma, it's life and life only."
  • catefrances
    catefrances Posts: 29,003
    robert plant worse than fred durst? i don't think so.


    though i have to admit to thinking stairway to heaven is a big pile of... :D

    oh oh henry rollins at #34. what the...? that's just wrong. :(
    hear my name
    take a good look
    this could be the day
    hold my hand
    lie beside me
    i just need to say
  • DOSW
    DOSW Posts: 2,014
    Robert Plant is a terrible lyricist guys. Great frontman, awful lyricist.
    It's a town full of losers and I'm pulling out of here to win
  • throwingcopper
    throwingcopper Posts: 96
    greg graffin of bad religion? haha. have they even heard any of their lyrics. that really is the dumbest and least thought out list i've ever read. the only one i agree with is anthony keidis... a lot of his lyrics don't make too much sense and are just words jumbled up to fit the music... but, at least if you're not basing a song on lyrics and saying "what the hell is that?"... the songs are alright.
    music. love. life.

    the stickman's ghost: www.myspace.com/yield1914
  • Metal Bryan
    Metal Bryan Posts: 12
    NEIL PEART AT #2?!!!!!!!!!!

    RIIIIIIIIIIIIIIGGGGGHHHHHTTTT.

    ^sarcasm
  • jammerfall
    jammerfall Posts: 908
    Consider the source; Blender is a crap publication.
    "Hello Oregonians. Hello Washingtonians. Hello Portland..where the fuck are we? We're in Ridgefield!"
  • Oh, Jimmy
    Oh, Jimmy Posts: 957
    Blender is a pretty entertaining mag, prolly the best US has to offer.

    Some of their lists have been pretty shitty. Prince beat out Led Zeppelin in their rock star wars. There are a few bands that have enough clout to be put above the Zep, and I think we can all agree that Prince aint one of em.

    They have also had some really cool lists.
  • Oh, Jimmy
    Oh, Jimmy Posts: 957
    DOSW wrote:
    Robert Plant is a terrible lyricist guys. Great frontman, awful lyricist.

    Lyrics may be Zeppelin's weakness, but I wouldn't say he's awful. He wrote in a different time. Writin about folklore and the like can sound dated, but you cant deny Plant has some killer lyrics.

    Kashmir
    Ten Years Gone
    Ramble On
    Over the Hills............
    The Song Remains the Same
    Rain Song
    Going to California
    Thank You
    Fool In The Rain
    Achilles Last Stand
  • g under p
    g under p Surfing The far side of THE Sombrero Galaxy Posts: 18,253
    Neil Peart #2, R Plant wasn't the greatest lyricist but LZ's and J Page's riff's saved them I think. Who the hell is Blender?

    Peace
    *We CAN bomb the World to pieces, but we CAN'T bomb it into PEACE*...Michael Franti

    *MUSIC IS the expression of EMOTION.....and that POLITICS IS merely the DECOY of PERCEPTION*
    .....song_Music & Politics....Michael Franti

    *The scientists of today think deeply instead of clearly. One must be sane to think clearly, but one can think deeply and be quite INSANE*....Nikola Tesla(a man who shaped our world of electricity with his futuristic inventions)


  • pjtaper
    pjtaper Posts: 3,020
    this list is SHITE!
    It makes me sick to see Paul McCartney's name on there... It was nice to see Phil Collins get some recognition for how HORRIBLE he is!
    Please Phil, rip out your vocal chord!
  • allforcarrie
    allforcarrie Posts: 60
    38) Paul McCartney (The Beatles, solo)

    WTF
    model, role model, roll some models in blood
  • Prioronfire22
    Prioronfire22 Posts: 393
    I know that is such a shit list. McCartney/Lennon are two of the greatest lyricists ever imo. Nowhere near the worst.
  • pjoasisrule
    pjoasisrule Posts: 3,412
    thecrackedjack wrote:
    ...in their 40 worst lyricists of all time. Another terrible list.

    http://www.blender.com/guide/articles.aspx?ID=2882

    1) Sting (solo, The Police)
    2) Neil Peart (Rush)
    3) Scott Stapp (Creed)
    4) Noel Gallagher (Oasis)
    5) Dan Fogelberg
    6) Tom Marshall (Phish friend [ not member ])
    7) Paul Stanley (KISS)
    8) Diane Warren ("I Don't Want to Miss a Thing", "How Can We Be Lovers?", "Have You Ever?")
    9) Donovan
    10) Jim Morrison (The Doors)

    11) Larry Henley and Jeff Silbar ("Wind Beneath My Wings")
    12) David Crosby (sometimes of Crosby, Stills & Nash [ & Young ])
    13) Pete Gabriel, Mike Rutherford, Tony Banks, Steve Hackett and Phil Collins (aka Genesis, but also including their respective solo projects)
    14) will.i.am (Black Eyed Peas)
    15) Bernie Taupin (lyricist for Elton John and... "We Built This City")
    16) Ben Gibbard (Death Cab for Cutie)
    17) Jon Anderson (Yes)
    18) Ian Anderson (Jethro Tull)
    19) Queensrÿche
    20) Ryan Ross (Panic! At the Disco)

    21) Alanis Morissette
    22) Jon Bon Jovi
    23) Robert Plant (Led Zeppelin)
    24) Fred Durst (Limp Bizkit)
    25) KRS-One
    26) Simon Le Bon (Duran Duran)
    27) Will Jennings (lyricist, "My Heart Will Go On", "Up Where We Belong", "Tears in Heaven", etc.)
    28) Greg Graffin (Bad Religion)
    29) Timbaland
    30) Kevin Federline (aka K-Fed)

    31) Carly Simon
    32) Matisyahu
    33) Diddy (aka P. Diddy aka Puffy aka Puff Daddy)
    34) Henry Rollins (Black Flag, Rollins Band)
    35) Dashboard Confessional
    36) Common
    37) Bryan Adams
    38) Paul McCartney (The Beatles, solo)
    39) Billy Corgan (Smashing Pumpkins, Zwan, solo)
    40) Anthony Kiedis (Red Hot Chili Peppers)

    Jim Morrison, Noel Gallagher, Billy Corgan, Paul McCartney, David Crosby..........seriously this list is complete bullshit and they have absolutely no credibility whatsoever.
    Alpine Valley 2000
    Summerfest 2006

    "Why would they come to our concert just to boo us?" -Lisa Simpson
  • stateoflove79
    stateoflove79 Posts: 2,845
    The fact that Billy Corgan is on that list makes it a pile of shit to me.

    Billy is better than most, case closed.
    Is it so wrong to think that love can keep us safe?
  • SomethingCreative
    SomethingCreative Kazoo, MI Posts: 3,422
    oh my god you've got to be shitting me that list is rediculous
    "Well, I think this band is incapable of sucking."
    -my dad after hearing Not for You for the first time on SNL .
  • stickfig13
    stickfig13 Posts: 1,532
    Greg Graffin?? Not a great lyricist?


    Have they ever listened to Bad Religion?
    Sacramento 10-30-00, Bridge School 10-20 and 10-21-01, Bridge School 10-25 and 10-26-01, Irvine 06-02-03, Irvine 06-03-03, San Diego 06-05-03, San Diego 07-07-06, Los Angeles 07-09-06, Santa Barbara 07-13-06, London UK 06-18-07, San Diego 10-9-09, San Diego 2013, LA 1 2013
  • lucylespian
    lucylespian Posts: 2,403
    I think having Bernie Taupin on the list says it all about cred. K-Fed fails by not having a career to assess, so has no place there. You might as well put my name there.

    This list is just to create controversy.

    Most pop lyrics look weak when taken out of the context of the song.
    Simple Minds belonged there though. Most of their songs were just one phrase repeated endlessly.
    Music is not a competetion.
  • SoonForgotten2
    SoonForgotten2 Posts: 2,245
    I don't know... I think the worst thing about the list is the order and not as much as who is on it. Anthony Kiedis should be top 10, no doubt. Billy Corgan should be higher as he has written some godawful lyrics. Pete Doherty doesn't make the list because no one outside the UK gives a fuck about him.

    Morrison is a tough one. I can see how someone who doesn't get JM could cringe at a LOT of his lyrics. That being said, anyone in music journalism should know enough about Jim Morrison to realise that his lyrics were nothing if not deliberate, which is brilliance in and of itself.

    ANd with all due respect to The Beatles, Paul McCartney deserves to make the list. He has contributed some proper lyrical clangers, no matter how catchy they may have been. He can't touch Lennon.
    <a href="http://www.flickr.com/photos/jmgphotos/sets/72157600802942672/">My Pearl Jam Photos</a>

    <a href="http://www.flickr.com/photos/jmgphotos/4731512142/&quot; title="PJ Banner2 by Mister J Photography, on Flickr"><img src="http://farm2.static.flickr.com/1135/4731512142_258f2d6ab4_b.jpg&quot; width="630" height="112" alt="PJ Banner2" /></a>
  • PHATJ
    PHATJ Posts: 348
    Gaiye
    "I'll Ride the wave where it takes me. I'll Hold the pain. RELEASE ME!"

Categories