is, "Stairway to Heaven," overrated?

2

Comments

  • DCGARDEN
    DCGARDEN Posts: 515
    If you put it into the proper context, that song was so far ahead of it's time it's scary - overplayed yes - over-rated - no fucking chance

    Beautiful melodies , sick solos, Bonham's drumming on it, in my opinion, is rock at it's finest
    I'll keep taking punches
    Untill their will grows tired
  • swede
    swede Posts: 558
    iAmNoKiller wrote:
    Don't fly off the hook about this! Some of my friends and I were sitting around listening to Zep, and the song came on, and two of us actually agreed that it's a little overrated. If you take into context the other great songs they have that aren't actually acknowledged. You can stop anyone off the street who doesn't know shit about Zeppelin, but they'll tell tou S.t.H. is the greatest song ever. What does everyone think.


    i think its overrated... as is led zep IV
  • swede
    swede Posts: 558
    Ledbetterman10 wrote:
    I won't even give the original post a read. All I know is that Stairway to Heaven is NOT overrated in the least. It borders on biblical if anything

    the bible is overrated... so if thats the case then it may help explain stairway being overrated
  • FinsburyParkCarrots
    FinsburyParkCarrots Seattle, WA Posts: 12,223
    DCGARDEN wrote:
    If you put it into the proper context, that song was so far ahead of it's time it's scary - overplayed yes - over-rated - no fucking chance

    Beautiful melodies , sick solos, Bonham's drumming on it, in my opinion, is rock at it's finest

    I think it was ahead of most conventional rock, in its time, but there were some British folk-rock artists at the time, who were producing comparable music. It's no coincidence that Sandy Denny sings on Battle of Evermore, for example: Zep were acknowledging a debt to the pioneers of the movement that they managed to bring to the mainstream.

    I don't think Stairway to Heaven is overrated, but I do think that there's music by Sandy Denny, Roy Harper, et al, which was around in the same period and which is criminally underrated to this day.
  • yosi1
    yosi1 Posts: 3,272
    Virgil Caine wrote:
    Your friend is mistaken.

    She is probably confusing it with No Quarter which would sometimes stretch to 1/2 hour.

    Or more likely Dazed and Confused which also reached lengths of 45 minutes.
    you couldn't swing if you were hangin' from a palm tree in a hurricane.
  • cjc9
    cjc9 Posts: 5
    Well, it's got an awesome guitar solo. It is not my favorite song though, too tough to pick a fave. Their 4th album is not my fave either, I love Physical Graffiti and Presence. The guitar on Achilles Last Stand is astounding. I love The Song Remains the Same- again awesome guitar work by Page.
    Caroline Caton
  • EBowie
    EBowie Posts: 533
    chiefojibwa wrote:
    totally overrated. zep has much better songs. and the lyrics...cheese to the nth degree.

    but it's a damn fine song.

    WOW!!!! See, I consider cheesy lyrics to be those that sound like anyone could have written them. Who the fuck else is gonna come up with opening lines like..."There's a lady who's sure all that glitters is gold"...come on the lyrics are fucking good...nothing is cheesy about them. The song is definitely overplayed people...and in that sense it can get boring. But I'll never say that it's overrated. And the lyrics are certainly not cheesy.
  • DCGARDEN
    DCGARDEN Posts: 515
    cj-vegan wrote:
    Well, it's got an awesome guitar solo. It is not my favorite song though, too tough to pick a fave. Their 4th album is not my fave either, I love Physical Graffiti and Presence. The guitar on Achilles Last Stand is astounding. I love The Song Remains the Same- again awesome guitar work by Page.


    You just hit my sore spot!

    Presence a great album???? Hardly. It has 2 great songs, one of which (Achilles ) may be the greatest rock song ever made, but that hardly makes up for the rest of the album being average.

    Graffiti is definitely a great album, as a matter of fact, I'd say it's one of the greatest.
    I'll keep taking punches
    Untill their will grows tired
  • hendrix78
    hendrix78 Posts: 507
    Is Stairway over-rated? HELL NO!

    I concede that it's played so often that it is easy to lose focus on how original and ahead of it's time it is. The structure of this song is incredible. The way it starts soft and slow and builds to one of the most orgasmic climaxes in the history of rock music is incredible. It is a true peice of art. Whoever called it "commercial tat" doesn't know his ass from a hole in the ground. Stairway is 8 minutes long and doesn't even have a chorus. There's nothing commercial about it.

    That said, it's not my favorite Zeppelin tune.
  • JaneNY
    JaneNY Posts: 4,438
    Virgil Caine wrote:
    Your friend is mistaken.

    She is probably confusing it with No Quarter which would sometimes stretch to 1/2 hour.

    Who knows - she was arguing with her boyfriend at the time! In any case its a long ago friend; I have no idea where she even is now.
    R.i.p. Rigoberto Alpizar.
    R.i.p. My Dad - May 28, 2007
    R.i.p. Black Tail (cat) - Sept. 20, 2008
  • mwachsman
    mwachsman Posts: 474
    Overrated, no. The problem is that all other Zeppelin songs are underrated. They should be on the same level as Stairway. Even Hot Dog.
    "So, you must really love Led Zeppelin. That’s the oldest shirt I’ve ever seen on someone who wasn’t a bum."
    "Hey, if God didn’t want me to wear it so much, he wouldn’t have made them rock so hard."
  • Clau_yellowled
    Clau_yellowled Posts: 382
    NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO WAY!!!

    one of the greatest song ever!! that song will never be overrated!!! never!!
    Pearl Jam Mexico 2005, The greatest year ever!
    December 9, 10 - ESTA BIEN, ESTA BIEEEEEN!

    www.myspace.com/clau_yellowled
  • yosi1
    yosi1 Posts: 3,272
    DCGARDEN wrote:
    You just hit my sore spot!

    Presence a great album???? Hardly. It has 2 great songs, one of which (Achilles ) may be the greatest rock song ever made, but that hardly makes up for the rest of the album being average.

    Graffiti is definitely a great album, as a matter of fact, I'd say it's one of the greatest.

    You just listen to the Greatest Hits too much to appreciate the other songs.
    you couldn't swing if you were hangin' from a palm tree in a hurricane.
  • FreshTendrils
    FreshTendrils Posts: 267
    yosi wrote:
    You just listen to the Greatest Hits too much to appreciate the other songs.

    But he's right. Presence is not a great album.
    I share a cigarette with negativity.
  • yosi1
    yosi1 Posts: 3,272
    FreshTendrils wrote:
    But he's right. Presence is not a great album.

    I don't know, Achilles Last Stand, Nobody's Fault But Mine, Tea for One, For Your Life. Those are all great songs.
    you couldn't swing if you were hangin' from a palm tree in a hurricane.
  • decides2dream
    decides2dream Posts: 14,977
    it is an amazing song, sure...but if i never hear it played ever again, it'll be too soon. sorry, i LOVE led zep, to the deeps of my soul...but that song got RUINED for me during my teen years, completely obliterated, over-played beyond belief. so yea....i appreciate it's mastery...but i just don't want to hear it ever again. :)
    Stay with me...
    Let's just breathe...


    I am myself like you somehow


  • Inkdaub
    Inkdaub Posts: 235
    Stairway is one of the greatest songs ever written. I never get tired of it and never feel like changing it or skipping it when it comes on. I don't see it as overrated. I DO see the absurdity of naming it the greatest rock song ever because there can't be a single greatest rock song ever. But Stairway would make the list of possibles for sure.
  • brain of c
    brain of c Posts: 5,213
    the sign in the guitar store says it all.

    no stairway.
    d'oh!!!!!!

    http://www.myspace.com/brain_of_c
  • solace23
    solace23 Posts: 704
    never over rated- it is one the greatest songs of all time!!
  • Ledbetterman10
    Ledbetterman10 Posts: 16,995
    mwachsman wrote:
    Overrated, no. The problem is that all other Zeppelin songs are underrated. They should be on the same level as Stairway. Even Hot Dog.


    Hot Dog is good fun but I don't think it's quite on the level of anything on Zeppelin IV.

    now Carouselambra on the other hand.......
    2000: Camden 1, 2003: Philly, State College, Camden 1, MSG 2, Hershey, 2004: Reading, 2005: Philly, 2006: Camden 1, 2, East Rutherford 1, 2007: Lollapalooza, 2008: Camden 1, Washington D.C., MSG 1, 2, 2009: Philly 1, 2, 3, 4, 2010: Bristol, MSG 2, 2011: PJ20 1, 2, 2012: Made In America, 2013: Brooklyn 2, Philly 2, 2014: Denver, 2015: Global Citizen Festival, 2016: Philly 2, Fenway 1, 2018: Fenway 1, 2, 2021: Sea. Hear. Now. 2022: Camden, 2024: Philly 2, 2025: Pittsburgh 1

    Pearl Jam bootlegs:
    http://wegotshit.blogspot.com

Categories