Alive (with Jack Irons on drums)

suns rival

anyone know a video link of alive with Jack on drums?

just can't find it even in youtube.

help....

12345AGNST1

did this thread have anything to do with my comment on the jack irons thread?

suns rival

12345AGNST1 wrote:

did this thread have anything to do with my comment on the jack irons thread?

nah, i was about to make a poll. and wtf, a can't find any videos of him with the band playing alive.

suns rival

12345AGNST1 wrote:

did this thread have anything to do with my comment on the jack irons thread?

btw, what was your comment about? i haven't read it yet.

12345AGNST1

Yea I looked too. I couldnt find anything either, thats odd.

not for me?

I'm really interested to hear how he plays it. Jack is so good.

Oz Jammer

If you want to hear it then I'm pretty sure that they played it at the recorded Melbourne show in 98

heyjose

Check out Melbourne 95 for the way Jack breaks it down during the solo, then builds it up as Ed does the "Yeah! Yeah!.."

suns rival

heyjose wrote:

Check out Melbourne 95 for the way Jack breaks it down during the solo, then builds it up as Ed does the "Yeah! Yeah!.."

still no melbourne 95 in youtube.:( where can i get a video of jack playing drums in this song? i just want the freakin' video.

12345AGNST1

suns rival wrote:

btw, what was your comment about? i haven't read it yet.

I said that he butchers Alive. He plays a basic rock beat during the solo when there should be improvising. I'm not a fan of Jack.

gndcd402

suns rival wrote:

anyone know a video link of alive with Jack on drums?

just can't find it even in youtube.

help....

is this a request?

suns rival

gndcd402 wrote:

is this a request?

kinda...:D

somebody post a video of this in youtube.

gndcd402

suns rival wrote:

kinda...:D

somebody post a video of this in youtube.

gimme some time, i have a video of black going up right now

suns rival

gndcd402 wrote:

gimme some time, i have a video of black going up right now

hehe!!! pls post alive gndcd402. thanks.

DPrival78

here's jack playing alive, from 97-98

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SrI1pE5S9i4&feature=related

fast forward to 8:05

suns rival

DPrival78 wrote:

here's jack playing alive, from 97-98

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SrI1pE5S9i4&feature=related

fast forward to 8:05

hahaha!!! already saw that. he & stone having some funny moments.

gndcd402

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gy_Z-WYciC8

suns rival

gndcd402 wrote:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gy_Z-WYciC8

thanks a lot man....:D

ruggs1996

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gy_Z-WYciC8

Gnd aka gary uploaded it today

InMyTree4

such a funny drum kit in that video with jack

yosi1

12345AGNST1 wrote:

I said that he butchers Alive. He plays a basic rock beat during the solo when there should be improvising. I'm not a fan of Jack.

Me neither. I just don't think he had the chops, and his live playing is often pretty awful I find.

Spencer

I think Jack's a brilliant drummer, his studio work with the band is impeccable - but I really don't think that's the best video to display his skills.

He was never brilliant on the Ten-era material, it just doesn't suit his style.

If we're comparing who drums In My Tree or Hail Hail better, I can tell you I prefer - and it's not the venerable Mr Cameron!

(I do like Matt's drumming overall, I just think Jack plays the stuff he wrote with the band better than Matt does.)