I think we're ready for this question

NCfan

If the Dems win the house in November, should they impeach Bush?

know1

NCfan wrote:

If the Dems win the house in November, should they impeach Bush?

No. It's a silly question. He's done nothing worthy of impeachment.

Vedderlution_Baby

Oh man, here we go.

:: puts on helmet and gets under a desk::

this should be good

PaperPlates

thats a moot point, and useless question. The dems couldnt win a bicycle race if they were driving motorcycles.

Milestone

Need a good reason first.

O-ren Ishii

know1 wrote:

No. It's a silly question. He's done nothing worthy of impeachment.

Well, actually, quite a few people think his warrantless wire tapping program broke the law. Were this proven to be the case, yeah, get his ass out of there. Unfortunately, those accusations don't seem to be going anywhere, so it's likely a moot point.

NCfan

I think it would be the worst possible decision ever, even dumber (for those that thought it was dumb to go to Iraq) than going to Iraq.

How vindicated would the terrorist feel? Talk about giving those whacks jobs propaganda material? Shit, talk about creating more terrorist!!!!

Laz

impeach him for what? bad decisions? since when is that an impeachable offense?

NCfan

Laz wrote:

impeach him for what? bad decisions? since when is that an impeachable offense?

Quite a few top Democrats, including Nacy Pelosi and Harry Reid have already called for his impeachment, on multiple occasions.

God only knows what they would do if they win congress.

Commy

I think all mass murderers should be held accountable, W included. Yeah he's a puppet, but ultimately he makes the decision...certain people tell him what to do, but really it does come down to him. He could have said no, I don't want to kill tens of thousands of people in the middle east and turn a stable country into a wasteland, ripe with civil wars and terrorist attacks and very unstable soldiers running around executing people. He could have prevented all of that. Even though he is a puppet.

Laz

NCfan wrote:

Quite a few top Democrats, including Nacy Pelosi and Harry Reid have already called for his impeachment, on multiple occasions.

God only knows what they would do if they win congress.

The question remains, impeachment for what? There has to be a reason to impeach a President, I mean a real reason. Can't impeach him because you don't like his policies (boneheaded or not) and you can't impeach him because he prays, that's for sure...

NCfan

Commy wrote:

I think all mass murderers should be held accountable, W included. Yeah he's a puppet, but ultimately he makes the decision...certain people tell him what to do, but really it does come down to him. He could have said no, I don't want to kill tens of thousands of people in the middle east and turn a stable country into a wasteland, ripe with civil wars and terrorist attacks and very unstable soldiers running around executing people. He could have prevented all of that. Even though he is a puppet.

Iraq, a "stable" country... LOL

NCfan

Laz wrote:

The question remains, impeachment for what? There has to be a reason to impeach a President, I mean a real reason. Can't impeach him because you don't like his policies (boneheaded or not) and you can't impeach him because he prays, that's for sure...

http://article.nationalreview.com/?q=YjVjM2M2N2U3ZjJlNTRiZmYzZjJkYzJiN2RlZGQyYjY=

Laz

NCfan wrote:

Iraq, a "stable" country... LOL

yeah, lol... Iraq hasn't been a stable country since Hammurabi

dayan

Commy wrote:

I think all mass murderers should be held accountable, W included. Yeah he's a puppet, but ultimately he makes the decision...certain people tell him what to do, but really it does come down to him. He could have said no, I don't want to kill tens of thousands of people in the middle east and turn a stable country into a wasteland, ripe with civil wars and terrorist attacks and very unstable soldiers running around executing people. He could have prevented all of that. Even though he is a puppet.

As Tony Blair pointed out very wisely, it is the terrorists in Iraq who have turned Iraq into what it is today, not us. Our actions haven't been perfect, but neither are we responsible for all the terror and killing and sectarian violence that plagues Iraq. That can be laid squarely at the feet of people like Zarqawi and his terrorist buddies.

Milhouse VanHouten

NCfan wrote:

I think it would be the worst possible decision ever, even dumber (for those that thought it was dumb to go to Iraq) than going to Iraq.

How vindicated would the terrorist feel? Talk about giving those whacks jobs propaganda material? Shit, talk about creating more terrorist!!!!

How, exactly, would impeachment create more terrorists??

Ahnimus

Milhouse VanHouten wrote:

How, exactly, would impeachment create more terrorists??

I think it would actually be a sign to the terrorists that steps are being taken to make peace.

Eliot Rosewater

NCfan wrote:

Quite a few top Democrats, including Nacy Pelosi and Harry Reid have already called for his impeachment, on multiple occasions.

God only knows what they would do if they win congress.

I'm pretty sure there will be impeachment hearings if the dems get congress. His NSA debacle is clearly unconstitutional. Are we really discussing this?

Abuskedti

Milhouse VanHouten wrote:

How, exactly, would impeachment create more terrorists??

I believe it does increase the likliness of an attack on America. George W Bush has been by far the greatest success story of terrorism. If the "terrorists" lose Bush, they will lkely try another attack in the hopes the United States may respond as miserable or at least almost - again.

seagoat2

Vedderlution_Baby! wrote:

Oh man, here we go.

:: puts on helmet and gets under a desk::

this should be good

**I agree w/you, vedderlution_baby! Don't EVEN get me started....I'm staying out of this one!!!!! What a fun thread....bump!

Cosmo

NCfan wrote:

If the Dems win the house in November, should they impeach Bush?

...
Impeachment for what? Making one poor decision after another after another after another after another after another after another is not an impeachable offense.
...
And the Democrats won't win... and if they do win... what's the difference? Shit and crap both stink.