Islam is so peaceful...
jsand
Posts: 646
Another wonderful "honor" killing - this time a 6-year old is killed:
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/main.jhtml?xml=/news/2006/09/20/nhonour20.xml
Two men murdered a six-year-old girl by setting fire to her house to warn her brother off a relationship he was having, a court heard yesterday.
Proceed with the typical apologist nonsense.
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/main.jhtml?xml=/news/2006/09/20/nhonour20.xml
Two men murdered a six-year-old girl by setting fire to her house to warn her brother off a relationship he was having, a court heard yesterday.
Proceed with the typical apologist nonsense.
Post edited by Unknown User on
0
Comments
http://news.yahoo.com/s/wtae/20060920/lo_wtae/9896050;_ylt=AgY8UO74U.y07lDJ8md9G8jp5hsC;_ylu=X3oDMTA5aHJvMDdwBHNlYwN5bmNhdA--
my point: senseless violence happens...it happens with reason and without...but , sadly, it happens...no excuse makes it ok...be it religion, drugs, mental illness, or just plain evil...
question: do you think all those who follow Islam are violent murderers....? please note the word "all"...
(edit) as for islam being peaceful, I guess that would depend on the circumstances. Sitting in a quiet room reading the holy book sounds and looks peaceful to me.
Peace
Dan
"Every judgment teeters on the brink of error. To claim absolute knowledge is to become monstrous. Knowledge is an unending adventure at the edge of uncertainty." - Frank Herbert, Dune, 1965
How does the incident you posted have any comparison? "Honor killings" are committed in the name of Islam. The incident I cite is not isolated -there's a pattern here.
To answer your question, I do not think that all those who follow Islam are violent. I do think that all those who stringently adhere to the Quaran - fundamentalists - have a very high likelihood to become radicalized and commit violent acts.
But boy, you dont say that very often. Or your definition of fundamentalist islam goes far beyond what I would say. I will agree that fundamentalism is dangerous.
Peace
Dan
"Every judgment teeters on the brink of error. To claim absolute knowledge is to become monstrous. Knowledge is an unending adventure at the edge of uncertainty." - Frank Herbert, Dune, 1965
This specific killing and the article you quoted doesnt even mention Islam... how can you say this was done in the name of Islam... you dont know the background well enough!!
If you agree with me on that, then why view this reprehensible incident as a mere "criminal" act? It goes beyond that. Violent reactions to relationships, violent reactions to the Pope's words, violent reactions to cartoons...There's a pattern. Viewing it as merely criminal, or as just a few crazy people, doesn't get to the heart of the matter. Do you realize that the protests against the Pope and the cartoons began on Fridays? That's when Mosque lets out. This hatred is being ingrained - it's taught by clerics.
Honor killing is based on Islam - although it is not exclusive to it. Look at the guys' names and do the math.
um, I was looking at the larger picture of senseless violence, here is what I said for reference:
I'm unsure how else to say it....
I agree with you for once....what do you suggest...? how should it be addressed...? should the religion of islam be banned..? we can sit here all day and point out senseless act of violence based on every reason under the sun, including religion....but at the end of the day, it's still happening....I happen to think until open dialog begins on all sides, this sort of thing will continue...refusing to speak to each other adds to the problem, rather that helping....
from wikipedia "... In Europe, honor killings have mostly been reported within some Muslim and Sikh communities"
how do you know these people werent Sikh's???
and the holocaust was based opon ideas by Nazis... doesnt mean every German person was ecstatic about it does it!
While I would prefer dialogue, I don't see that happening. This fundamentalist ideology does not permit compromise.
nice edit there
ok..i'l check the names.... oh wait... why should I? just because they sound 'foreign' then they must be Muslims... how do you know they are not Sikhs, or Hindus? Honor killing happens in these religions also?
Hussain Ahmed, a 26-year-old dentist, and Daryll Tuzzio,
ok Hussain Ahmed sounds Pakistani or whatever.. so he could be a follower of many religions with that name and background.... and wow oh wow Clueso... the other guy is called Daryll Tuzzio ... a half English half Italian name!!! hardly conclusive proof is it?
By the way, talking of "honour killings" I recently read some interesting articles concerning how you can compare "honour killings" with "family tragedies" (typically, the husband killing his family, and then himself) and asked why this wasn't spoken of in the same way. That is also violence towards women, most often, even given the difference that th eperpetrator also offs himself. How widespread is this phenomenon? Apart from shock articles, and some tragic incidences the last decade it seems to be very much limited. We have murders all the time. Why must we look at islam when a muslim does the killing? That is my question. That these particular people have a pretty messed up version of the world, and what must be done in regards to "offenses", sure. Is it islam's fault? No. Is there some cultural backdrop to this? Maybe. But even so, they ARE extreme even for that.
And interestingly, noone in the article talks of islam. That's because the honour thing is not of islam, but prevalent in countries who also happen to be muslim. And, they may occur in our own societies, although we dont label them as such.
You are way too quick to go at the throat of islam or muslims every chance you get. And if, in a case, something somewhere is/is related to muslims/islam, you never fail to highlight it ahead of anything else that might be of importance.
So, to sum up:
Honour killings is not of Islam
Honour killing as phenomenon is very overrated
Honour killings are connected to culture first and foremost. Just like circumcitions.
Honour killings occurs in our societies too. Only labelled jealousy or "family tragedy" instead.
Tragic case. Lock them up good for arson and murder. And schedule them a psychiatrist while you're at it.
In conlusion, yes fundamentalism is dangerous, and I will oppose it at any turn. At the same time, it is important to see and think clearly what is and is not about or of fundamentalism, and avoid gross mis-labelling that affects other non-fundamentalists. And these days hate for muslims sits way too loose and with little or no justification apart from a big sensationalist headline. Rabid anti-fundamentalism can be a fundamentalism in itself.
Peace
Dan
"Every judgment teeters on the brink of error. To claim absolute knowledge is to become monstrous. Knowledge is an unending adventure at the edge of uncertainty." - Frank Herbert, Dune, 1965
"I don't see that happening" and then you go on to blame "fundanmentalist ideology"....you see, that's the problem....I'd be willing to bet that those on the other side are saying the same thing....
I think there is no harm in reaching out to the other side...but until that happens, nothing will change...
I asked: what do you suggest...? how should it be addressed...? should the religion of islam be banned..?
I'm curious as to your thoughts....
Peace
Dan
"Every judgment teeters on the brink of error. To claim absolute knowledge is to become monstrous. Knowledge is an unending adventure at the edge of uncertainty." - Frank Herbert, Dune, 1965
I disagree with your opinion that there is no harm in reaching out to the other side. In my opinion, reaching out to fundamentalists, who believe that those who do not adhere to Islam are "infidels," emboldens them further. They perceive this as weakness. It is a slippery slope.
I do not think the religion of Islam should be banned. However, I don't think these radicals should be coddled, either. To be honest, I don't know what the solution is, other than moderates making a real concerted effort to control what is going on. Groups like CAIR (the counsel on american islamic relations) claim to be moderate, but do not condemn the actions of those who commit violence in the name of Islam. Instead, CAIR and other such groups reverse the scenario and claim that the west is "Islamophobic." HNow about addressing the cause of that phobia by speaking out against terrorism, without any hedging? That would be a start.
Oh, please. My "race-hate and bigotry"?
NO. All it says is that there are nuts out there that use religion as an excuse for their insanity. All it proves is that there are nuts out there.
Hail, Hail!!!
If there were thousands of Andrea Yeats-like incidents happening around the world, would you think differently? People on this board love to counter the argument that there is a problem in Islam by posting about an isolated incident, such as this one. If you show me that thousands of Christians are doing the same thing, then you have a point.
That is not my point. My point is that these people are insane and neither one of them has anything to do with religion.
You are the one that is saying that since these men did this... and since they are Muslim... then, all of Islam is like this.
If you follow YOUR logic... then the same would apply to Andrea Yeates.
...
My point is that neither is true and you are incorrect in your assessment.
Hail, Hail!!!
http://www.myspace.com/thelastreel http://www.facebook.com/group.php?gid=19604327965
According to the wikipedia-thingy I referenced, there are perhaps 5000 a year that can be based in honour-killing (That is conjecture and worst-case, not fact). And, a lot of it occurs elsewhere than in islamic countries. India, as has been mentioned have a dark history on such things including also widow-burning and so on. Also, how many of the husbands who murder their wives in "western" societies can be accused and suspected of the same?
You have failed to provide evidence of the muslim nature of this, hence your starting accusation (headline) is without merit. If you wanna attack middle-eastern/indian macho culture and an age-old patriarchy, then go ahead. But the issue isn't about islam. It's about honour which is culturally based and stands strong in some parts of the world still.
You often seem to equate muslims/arabs/middle eastern culture when they are seperate entities and dont always coincide. And dont be surprised if you are accused of race-hate, as your posts are invariably about one thing and one thing only. You know what I mean. If you really have a balanced view, you fail consistently to show it. As here, where islam is nowhere at the forefront of the issue, but you parade it as the main reason behind anyway.
And even if you think there's a difference of numbers, you dont answer the question whether people killing their kids for god is worthy of a look on christianity, which would be consistent with your accusation against islam here.
Peace
Dan
"Every judgment teeters on the brink of error. To claim absolute knowledge is to become monstrous. Knowledge is an unending adventure at the edge of uncertainty." - Frank Herbert, Dune, 1965
Shall we post the crimes in the Unites States to show what kind of person you are?
KIDNAP GIRL KEPT IN BUNKER FOR 10 DAYS
Racism isn't the right word... but it's the first that comes to mind.
naděje umírá poslední
as it was me he directed the "look at the names and do the math" comment at... i'm slightly annoyed he hasnt responded to it... surely debating means you are able to put your hands up and say "you know what.. i got it wrong"
One of the guys names was of Asian origin but the other guys name was English/Italian... and so i have done the maths and come to the conclusion that the guys were fucking nutters... their religion didnt enter the equation
Christianity is so peaceful...
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Andrea_Yates
I feel really sorry for you.