Home› A Moving Train

Is this true about Jehova (aka God)?

qtegirlqtegirl Posts: 321
edited January 2007 in A Moving Train
"Between 500 and 150 BC, the priestly aristocracy ordered its scribes to re-write Palestinian history, pretending that they didn't reinvent Jehovah, to make believe that God the almighty had always existed as a monotheistic entity. The scribes inserted the presence of Jehovah into every past natural disaster, wars, famines, into the life of every past king and queen in Palestine and beyond. The creative collective works of the Jerusalem scribes became known in Europe as the 'Old Testament.' "

This is the first time I've ever heard of this. Has anyone been taught this before? Are there any sources available to confirm this?
Post edited by Unknown User on

Comments

  • gobrowns19gobrowns19 Posts: 1,447
    I've never been taught this or learned this, or in fact ever even heard of it. But then again, you don't know my credibility anymore than you do where you heard that.
    Happiness is only real when shared
  • qtegirlqtegirl Posts: 321
    It's part of a counterpunch article:

    http://www.counterpunch.com/cohen12292006.html

    But there aren't any references or sources listed.
  • CorporateWhoreCorporateWhore Posts: 1,890
    Jehova is an incorrect spelling of "Yahweh," for starters. The Jews did not use vowels I think and that's why there was a misunderstanding.

    I have never heard of that or been taught that. I would be interested in seeing the source.
    All I know is that to see, and not to speak, would be the great betrayal.
    -Enoch Powell
  • miller8966miller8966 Posts: 1,450
    Yes sources are always nice
    America...the greatest Country in the world.
  • qtegirlqtegirl Posts: 321
    Well, I sent the author an e-mail and hopefully he'll get back to me.

    I'm glad I wasn't the only one who was puzzled about that bit of information.
  • AhnimusAhnimus Posts: 10,560
    Well, it's the most realistic explanation of God, I've ever heard :)
    I necessarily have the passion for writing this, and you have the passion for condemning me; both of us are equally fools, equally the toys of destiny. Your nature is to do harm, mine is to love truth, and to make it public in spite of you. - Voltaire
  • qtegirlqtegirl Posts: 321
    Ahnimus wrote:
    Well, it's the most realistic explanation of God, I've ever heard :)
    You know.... I had a feeling you were going to say something like that.
  • kenny olavkenny olav Posts: 3,319
    qtegirl wrote:
    Well, I sent the author an e-mail and hopefully he'll get back to me.

    I'm glad I wasn't the only one who was puzzled about that bit of information.


    fascinating article... could you please post whatever Uri Cohen may reply back to you with?
  • qtegirlqtegirl Posts: 321
    I got the following reply from the author of the article:


    Happy New Year and all the best for 2007! Thank you for reading my article.

    I would recommend the following books regarding the ‘Old Testament’ and archeology as well as questions regarding the historicity of the Bible.


    The Israelites in History and Tradition (Library of Ancient Israel) (Hardcover)
    by Niels Peter Lemche "Recent developments in the study of ancient Israel have caused of a lot of concern..." (more)
    Key Phrases: Late Bronze Age, Near East, Niels Peter Lemche (more...)


    In Search of Ancient Israel (Journal for the Study of the Old Testament Supplement Ser Vol 148) (Paperback)
    by Philip R. Davies


    The Origins of the Ancient Israelite States
    Author:
    Volkmar Fritz (Editor), Philip R. Davies (Editor)
    Format:Hardcover
    Published: October 1998
    ISBN: 1850756295
    List Price: $85.00

    ·Scribes and Schools : The Canonization of the Hebrew Scriptures
    Author: Philip R. Davies
    Format: Paperback
    Published: July 1998
    ISBN: 0664227287
    List Price: $29.95

    ·The Mythic Past: Biblical Archaeology and the Myth of Israel (Paperback)
    by Thomas L. Thompson "Saul's election and rise to power over Israel: his fall from grace; mad king Saul whose depressions are soothed by David the inspired musician of..." (more)
    Key Phrases: population transference, elohe shamayim

    ·The Historicity of the Patriarchal Narratives: The Quest for the Historical Abraham (Paperback)
    by Thomas L. Thompson
    Thomas L. Thompson (University of Copenhagen)
    Niels Peter Lemche (University of Copenhagen)
    á Giovanni Garbini (University of Rome)
    ************************

    HAPPY READING!!!
  • harmless_little_f***harmless_little_f*** Posts: 8,005
    This is kind of what I expected. He's obviously not knowledgable enough to give you a little off the top of his head. He could've told you his opinion on some things at least briefly based on what he knows, but he offered you nothing except for a few books which, for all intents and purposes, he probably just Googled. He's passing the buck to other scholars because he knows he isn't one.

    qtegirl wrote:
    I got the following reply from the author of the article:


    Happy New Year and all the best for 2007! Thank you for reading my article.

    I would recommend the following books regarding the ‘Old Testament’ and archeology as well as questions regarding the historicity of the Bible.


    The Israelites in History and Tradition (Library of Ancient Israel) (Hardcover)
    by Niels Peter Lemche "Recent developments in the study of ancient Israel have caused of a lot of concern..." (more)
    Key Phrases: Late Bronze Age, Near East, Niels Peter Lemche (more...)


    In Search of Ancient Israel (Journal for the Study of the Old Testament Supplement Ser Vol 148) (Paperback)
    by Philip R. Davies


    The Origins of the Ancient Israelite States
    Author:
    Volkmar Fritz (Editor), Philip R. Davies (Editor)
    Format:Hardcover
    Published: October 1998
    ISBN: 1850756295
    List Price: $85.00

    ·Scribes and Schools : The Canonization of the Hebrew Scriptures
    Author: Philip R. Davies
    Format: Paperback
    Published: July 1998
    ISBN: 0664227287
    List Price: $29.95

    ·The Mythic Past: Biblical Archaeology and the Myth of Israel (Paperback)
    by Thomas L. Thompson "Saul's election and rise to power over Israel: his fall from grace; mad king Saul whose depressions are soothed by David the inspired musician of..." (more)
    Key Phrases: population transference, elohe shamayim

    ·The Historicity of the Patriarchal Narratives: The Quest for the Historical Abraham (Paperback)
    by Thomas L. Thompson
    Thomas L. Thompson (University of Copenhagen)
    Niels Peter Lemche (University of Copenhagen)
    á Giovanni Garbini (University of Rome)
    ************************

    HAPPY READING!!!
    'We're learning songs for baby Jesus' birthday. His mum and dad were Merry and Joseph. He had a bed made of clay and the three kings bought him Gold, Frankenstein and Merv as presents.'

    - the great Sir Leo Harrison
  • CollinCollin Posts: 4,931
    harmless_little_f*** wrote:
    This is kind of what I expected. He's obviously not knowledgable enough to give you a little off the top of his head. He could've told you his opinion on some things at least briefly based on what he knows, but he offered you nothing except for a few books which, for all intents and purposes, he probably just Googled. He's passing the buck to other scholars because he knows he isn't one.

    You are assuming a lot.
    THANK YOU, LOSTDAWG!


    naděje umírá poslední
  • harmless_little_f***harmless_little_f*** Posts: 8,005
    Collin wrote:
    You are assuming a lot.

    Yes, I am. Just as much as others are assuming by believing this guy is right.
    'We're learning songs for baby Jesus' birthday. His mum and dad were Merry and Joseph. He had a bed made of clay and the three kings bought him Gold, Frankenstein and Merv as presents.'

    - the great Sir Leo Harrison
  • CollinCollin Posts: 4,931
    harmless_little_f*** wrote:
    Yes, I am.

    Well as long as you know it, it's ok.
    THANK YOU, LOSTDAWG!


    naděje umírá poslední
  • harmless_little_f***harmless_little_f*** Posts: 8,005
    Collin wrote:
    Well as long as you know it, it's ok.

    It's just weird for this guy to offer a long list of books and then say 'Happy reading!' without even a hint of a morsel of an opinion on what he's obviously knowledgable about. I myself could've compiled such a list. It implies that in researching this article, this was the first and only time he'll ever have read these books - and then he probably only skim-read them in order to pick out bits which affirm his anti-religious prejudices.
    'We're learning songs for baby Jesus' birthday. His mum and dad were Merry and Joseph. He had a bed made of clay and the three kings bought him Gold, Frankenstein and Merv as presents.'

    - the great Sir Leo Harrison
  • CollinCollin Posts: 4,931
    harmless_little_f*** wrote:
    It's just weird for this guy to offer a long list of books and then say 'Happy reading!' without even a hint of a morsel of an opinion on what he's obviously knowledgable about. I myself could've compiled such a list. It implies that in researching this article, this was the first and only time he'll ever have read these books - and then he probably only skim-read them in order to pick out bits which affirm his anti-religious prejudices.

    qtegirl said this in the initial post:

    This is the first time I've ever heard of this. Has anyone been taught this before? Are there any sources available to confirm this?

    He gave a list of sources. Doesn't really imply anything if you ask me, maybe just a 'figure it out yourself.'
    THANK YOU, LOSTDAWG!


    naděje umírá poslední
  • harmless_little_f***harmless_little_f*** Posts: 8,005
    Collin wrote:
    qtegirl said this in the initial post:

    This is the first time I've ever heard of this. Has anyone been taught this before? Are there any sources available to confirm this?

    He gave a list of sources. Doesn't really imply anything if you ask me, maybe just a 'figure it out yourself.'

    Yeah maybe, fair enough. :)
    'We're learning songs for baby Jesus' birthday. His mum and dad were Merry and Joseph. He had a bed made of clay and the three kings bought him Gold, Frankenstein and Merv as presents.'

    - the great Sir Leo Harrison
  • brainofPJbrainofPJ Posts: 2,361
    read about the dead sea scrolls


    Esther's here and she's sick?

    hi Esther, now we are all going to be sick, thanks
Sign In or Register to comment.