quick The Pink Floyd question

StoneG82

"Wish You Were Here" - who sang the vocals on this song - Gilmour or Waters?

my friends and i have been having arguments about this. I personally think its Waters, but everyone says it's Gilmour.

Someone help me out. Please.

wavin_goodbye

Gilmour.......

jumpin cat rival

Both

david begins

roger continues with the
Did they get yu to trade .........


then both sing in the chorus

StoneG82

jumpin cat rival wrote:

Both

david begins

roger continues with the
Did they get yu to trade .........


then both sing in the chorus

interesting........thanks for the info!

jumpin cat rival

jumpin cat rival wrote:

Both

david begins

roger continues with the
Did they get yu to trade .........


then both sing in the chorus

hey my 700th post.........now finally i can say WHOOPIDY DOO

http://forums.pearljam.com/showthread.php?t=161811&page=2

jumpin cat rival

StoneG82 wrote:

interesting........thanks for the info!

You are welcome

El_Kabong

this site supposedly lists who sang what

http://www.allfloyd.com/lyrics/Who.sang.what.html

btw, i read that cough at the beginning of the song is what made dave quit smoking