At what price would you sell your Benaroya LP?

MisterE

When I see a price above $700, it certainly makes me stop and think. If I could ever get over $1,000 for it, I think I would have to give that some serious consideration. Is that wrong?

LukinFan

MisterE wrote:

When I see a price above $700, it certainly makes me stop and think. If I could ever get over $1,000 for it, I think I would have to give that some serious consideration. Is that wrong?

yes, very wrong. What's the difference between selling vinyl for 1000 times the cost price to doing that with posters, which people all the time on here are completely against?

Edit: but then again, there are dumbasses out there that will pay this crazy amount, so go for it

2-feign-reluctance

i'd buy it for $50 and fucking play the shit out of it. 180 gram vinyl?! what the fuck people!? play that shit, don't let it sit around collecting dust.

3inputchick

I would trade it for front row center

LukinFan

2-feign-reluctance wrote:

i'd buy it for $50 and fucking play the shit out of it. 180 gram vinyl?! what the fuck people!? play that shit, don't let it sit around collecting dust.

awwww.... dust... (foams at the mouth)

Brain Of E

yea i'd say sell it for what it's worth, not what you paid for it. It's just like having the first issue of batman, would you sell it for the 50 cent face value?

2-feign-reluctance

LukinFan wrote:

awwww.... dust... (foams at the mouth)

ha! i love dust collecting collectible type stuff, but only if it can't be used! like baseball cards. if i paid $700 for something, i'd better go get my $700 worth of listens out of it!

MayDay10

My wrapping has been torn a little on the back side of it. Do you think that busts the value?

Im close to just opening the damn thing anyways.

whgarrett

I think seriously about selling my copy about twice a year, but I can't seem to do it. Money is tight but when it's gone....baby it's gone.

Lizard

3inputchick wrote:

I would trade it for front row center

damn. That sounds really, really tempting!!!

PearlJamaholic

ill trade it for a shelby cobra.

G Force

2-feign-reluctance wrote:

i'd buy it for $50 and fucking play the shit out of it. 180 gram vinyl?! what the fuck people!? play that shit, don't let it sit around collecting dust.

This record is a gem. Its a piece of art and one of the best live recordings of all time. I love that show. And I love my Benny vinyl. Play it, display it, and save it.

tkepearljamn

Not that I would think of doing it. But... what would you pay for a 1057 the point Soldier Field Vinyl. It was unopened when I purchased it this year. I opened it to listen to it. It is the most expensive record or album I have ever purchased.

How much would that be worth to somebody?

Julien

at this stage, since I don't need money, I would never sell it.
Unless someone gives me $100,000 for it
Even if I am once in need of cash, I don't think I'll be able to sell it. I mean, even if I have $700 for it, it would just help paying one or two bills. One week after, the money will be spent and the vinyls would be in somebody else's hands.

Qball

I would sell mine for $700 and it is unopened. I would never list it on ebay though. I'm sure I could get more for this but I really wont ever play this. I actually bought it to hang on my wall. I never had any intention of playing it.

elvistheking44

tkepearljamn wrote:

Not that I would think of doing it. But... what would you pay for a 1057 the point Soldier Field Vinyl. It was unopened when I purchased it this year. I opened it to listen to it. It is the most expensive record or album I have ever purchased.

How much would that be worth to somebody?

Im very torn about this record.....I realize from a collection standpoint its a "Gem" but the tracklisting on that vinyl is incomplete and out of order.....I wouldn't pay more than $30.00 for an unsealed copy now.

PJStatTracker

elvistheking44 wrote:

Im very torn about this record.....I realize from a collection standpoint its a "Gem" but the tracklisting on that vinyl is incomplete and out of order.....I wouldn't pay more than $30.00 for an unsealed copy now.

I don't buy that for a second. If someone offered to sell you their copy for $75, you're telling me you wouldn't take it? Forget how you feel about the tracklisting, you're making an investment...

btw, if someone is looking to unload their's for $75, I WILL buy it from you.

over bends

I think people here are over anal about selling market value, but with that said, I wouldn't even think about selling Benny for any value (realistic value, no one is going to pay $10,000 or such value for it)... that being if I had one... :(

I mean what's the point? You're going to spend the grand on paying bills to some suit. I could see that vinyl getting me through a lot of rough nights. That's not worth any cash value.

elvistheking44

jblagg wrote:

I don't buy that for a second. If someone offered to sell you their copy for $75, you're telling me you wouldn't take it? Forget how you feel about the tracklisting, you're making an investment...

btw, if someone is looking to unload their's for $75, I WILL buy it from you.

An investment.......shit.....thats about as good an investment as buying a car.

smile05

would like a copy and a record player, just so i could have this dilema

cd rules~~ha ha

petrocs

jblagg wrote:

I don't buy that for a second. If someone offered to sell you their copy for $75, you're telling me you wouldn't take it? Forget how you feel about the tracklisting, you're making an investment...

btw, if someone is looking to unload their's for $75, I WILL buy it from you.

I'll take one for $75 too

PJStatTracker

elvistheking44 wrote:

An investment.......shit.....thats about as good an investment as buying a car.

so you're saying that the value of the Benaroya vinyl has gone down since people originally purchased it?

elvistheking44

jblagg wrote:

so you're saying that the value of the Benaroya vinyl has gone down since people originally purchased it?

No...I was talking about the Soldier Field Vinyl......The original poster said it was the most expensive record they ever bought....Im sure it wont bring much more value to them on the second sale

PJStatTracker

elvistheking44 wrote:

No...I was talking about the Soldier Field Vinyl......The original poster said it was the most expensive record they ever bought....Im sure it wont bring much more value to them on the second sale

I see. that makes much more sense.

danny

MisterE wrote:

When I see a price above $700, it certainly makes me stop and think. If I could ever get over $1,000 for it, I think I would have to give that some serious consideration. Is that wrong?

i couldnt saved to long to own it!!!!!!

tkepearljamn

i got my soldier field vinyl from someone that didnt like music, pj, or vinyls for $125 bucks. That same week I saw it going for 500 on ebay. The vinyl doesn't sound that great. It is marble vinyl and their is a bitchin' poster included. I have wanted that vinyl since 1998 when I was in junior high.