Song Survival - Gigaton

mcgruff10

I just don’t get the undying love for 7:00.  It s a 5/10 and definitely not the second best song on the album.  

JPPJ84

mcgruff10 said:

I just don’t get the undying love for 7:00.  It s a 5/10 and definitely not the second best song on the album.  

That’s just your opinion though 

mcgruff10

JPPJ84 said:

mcgruff10 said:

I just don’t get the undying love for 7:00.  It s a 5/10 and definitely not the second best song on the album.  

That’s just your opinion though 

But of course. 

D-Rod

RE658041 said:

Ok, so Quick Escape won and Brian Dennehy died.

Very bad deal.

Howard Finkle 

Falling Down

rummy said:

Finals tomorrow (please observe the six-song and 30-minute rule).
Saturday - "Album Survival" (just the 11 of them - no compilations).

That'll probably do it although there have been a few interesting suggestions. However ...
- Unless we can agree upon 15 or so essential covers, it might be too difficult to start that one.
- I feel bad trying to determine the "worst" song.

Just start the whole thing all over Monday. Back with Ten and here we go. 

rummy

Falling Down said:

rummy said:

Finals tomorrow (please observe the six-song and 30-minute rule).
Saturday - "Album Survival" (just the 11 of them - no compilations).

That'll probably do it although there have been a few interesting suggestions. However ...
- Unless we can agree upon 15 or so essential covers, it might be too difficult to start that one.
- I feel bad trying to determine the "worst" song.

Just start the whole thing all over Monday. Back with Ten and here we go. 

I'd be curious to see how things turn out!

Spiritual_Chaos

mcgruff10 said:

I just don’t get the undying love for 7:00.  It s a 5/10 and definitely not the second best song on the album.  

I like the lyrics and Eddies phrasing. In the verses. When it slows down. that's the wrong way to go with the song IMO.

Same with Never Destination. Also sort of whimpers out/drops dead at places in the song when it should kick in. But hey, Of The Earth start/Stops in a weird way all through the songs and people for some reason love that one

cutz

(Very) Guesstimated  Stats 

37 people voted
14 Voted 1 time
10 Voted 5 times or more
2 voted  8 times
2 voted  9 times
110 Total votes to complete the thread

rummy

cutz said:

(Very) Guesstimated  Stats 

37 people voted
14 Voted 1 time
10 Voted 5 times or more
2 voted  8 times
2 voted  9 times
110 Total votes to complete the thread

More stats? Love it!

The Juggler

Buckle Up came in last????

SHAME ON ALL OF YOU.

RiotZact

The Juggler said:

Buckle Up came in last????

SHAME ON ALL OF YOU.

For real.

Jules Winnfield

Maybe we got this wrong.

River Cross ++++

rummy

Jules Winnfield said:

Maybe we got this wrong.

River Cross ++++

Yes. As (almost) always, hearing live performances makes the songs even better.

JPPJ84

rummy said:

Jules Winnfield said:

Maybe we got this wrong.

River Cross ++++

Yes. As (almost) always, hearing live performances makes the songs even better.

Haha, River Cross is literally the one song that had been played live before!!! 

rummy

JPPJ84 said:

rummy said:

Jules Winnfield said:

Maybe we got this wrong.

River Cross ++++

Yes. As (almost) always, hearing live performances makes the songs even better.

Haha, River Cross is literally the one song that had been played live before!!! 

Had it? I didn’t know! When? Where?

Falling Down

rummy said:

JPPJ84 said:

rummy said:

Jules Winnfield said:

Maybe we got this wrong.

River Cross ++++

Yes. As (almost) always, hearing live performances makes the songs even better.

Haha, River Cross is literally the one song that had been played live before!!! 

Had it? I didn’t know! When? Where?

https://youtu.be/13m4IGZ-WUk

Falling Down

Falling Down said:

rummy said:

JPPJ84 said:

rummy said:

Jules Winnfield said:

Maybe we got this wrong.

River Cross ++++

Yes. As (almost) always, hearing live performances makes the songs even better.

Haha, River Cross is literally the one song that had been played live before!!! 

Had it? I didn’t know! When? Where?

https://youtu.be/13m4IGZ-WUk

Part of the Pump Organ EV tour, which included one of my favorite performances, I'm so tired from Fugazi. Seen live in London. 

JPPJ84

I think 2-3 times since 2017. Pilgrimage, Ohana

vito

rummy said:

JPPJ84 said:

rummy said:

Jules Winnfield said:

Maybe we got this wrong.

River Cross ++++

Yes. As (almost) always, hearing live performances makes the songs even better.

Haha, River Cross is literally the one song that had been played live before!!! 

Had it? I didn’t know! When? Where?

C'mon man you are losing cred as our PJ moderator, need to know these little tidbits 😎

PJNB

JPPJ84 said:

I think 2-3 times since 2017. Pilgrimage, Ohana

Firenze 2019 as well. Friend was there. 

PJNB

Had to look it up and he has played 7 times surprisingly counting tonight. Thought it was just 3. 

vito

Love the visuals in BJA performance. Love seeing cool photos of places I've been especially matched with a good song. Lucky to have been to almost every place shown in the montage. Sagrada Familia in Barcelona stunning!

rummy

vito said:

rummy said:

JPPJ84 said:

rummy said:

Jules Winnfield said:

Maybe we got this wrong.

River Cross ++++

Yes. As (almost) always, hearing live performances makes the songs even better.

Haha, River Cross is literally the one song that had been played live before!!! 

Had it? I didn’t know! When? Where?

C'mon man you are losing cred as our PJ moderator, need to know these little tidbits 😎

Ha! I know!
Admittedly, I usually just skim through EV’s set lists. Lots of covers.... and, wait for it, I don’t really listen to a lot of his solo stuff.

JPPJ84

rummy said:

vito said:

rummy said:

JPPJ84 said:

rummy said:

Jules Winnfield said:

Maybe we got this wrong.

River Cross ++++

Yes. As (almost) always, hearing live performances makes the songs even better.

Haha, River Cross is literally the one song that had been played live before!!! 

Had it? I didn’t know! When? Where?

C'mon man you are losing cred as our PJ moderator, need to know these little tidbits 😎

Ha! I know!
Admittedly, I usually just skim through EV’s set lists. Lots of covers.... and, wait for it, I don’t really listen to a lot of his solo stuff.

You’re missing out!

vito

JPPJ84 said:

rummy said:

vito said:

rummy said:

JPPJ84 said:

rummy said:

Jules Winnfield said:

Maybe we got this wrong.

River Cross ++++

Yes. As (almost) always, hearing live performances makes the songs even better.

Haha, River Cross is literally the one song that had been played live before!!! 

Had it? I didn’t know! When? Where?

C'mon man you are losing cred as our PJ moderator, need to know these little tidbits 😎

Ha! I know!
Admittedly, I usually just skim through EV’s set lists. Lots of covers.... and, wait for it, I don’t really listen to a lot of his solo stuff.

You’re missing out!

This is the correct response!

Falling Down

rummy said:

vito said:

rummy said:

JPPJ84 said:

rummy said:

Jules Winnfield said:

Maybe we got this wrong.

River Cross ++++

Yes. As (almost) always, hearing live performances makes the songs even better.

Haha, River Cross is literally the one song that had been played live before!!! 

Had it? I didn’t know! When? Where?

C'mon man you are losing cred as our PJ moderator, need to know these little tidbits 😎

Ha! I know!
Admittedly, I usually just skim through EV’s set lists. Lots of covers.... and, wait for it, I don’t really listen to a lot of his solo stuff.

Never seen him live? Don't tell anyone, but I've actually enjoyed more my last 5 EV solo than last 5 PJ, even though there were a few good ones in there 

rummy

JPPJ84 said:

rummy said:

vito said:

rummy said:

JPPJ84 said:

rummy said:

Jules Winnfield said:

Maybe we got this wrong.

River Cross ++++

Yes. As (almost) always, hearing live performances makes the songs even better.

Haha, River Cross is literally the one song that had been played live before!!! 

Had it? I didn’t know! When? Where?

C'mon man you are losing cred as our PJ moderator, need to know these little tidbits 😎

Ha! I know!
Admittedly, I usually just skim through EV’s set lists. Lots of covers.... and, wait for it, I don’t really listen to a lot of his solo stuff.

You’re missing out!

Probably. Ever since I got heavily into PJ, Eddie hasn’t come my way. Seeing him live would play a major role, I presume. This said, I will listen to Into The Wild soundtrack again this evening.

vito

Eilish is just so damn cool and talented for a kid!!!

tbergs

vito said:

Eilish is just so damn cool and talented for a kid!!!

Sounded really good.

PJNB

Falling Down said:

rummy said:

vito said:

rummy said:

JPPJ84 said:

rummy said:

Jules Winnfield said:

Maybe we got this wrong.

River Cross ++++

Yes. As (almost) always, hearing live performances makes the songs even better.

Haha, River Cross is literally the one song that had been played live before!!! 

Had it? I didn’t know! When? Where?

C'mon man you are losing cred as our PJ moderator, need to know these little tidbits 😎

Ha! I know!
Admittedly, I usually just skim through EV’s set lists. Lots of covers.... and, wait for it, I don’t really listen to a lot of his solo stuff.

Never seen him live? Don't tell anyone, but I've actually enjoyed more my last 5 EV solo than last 5 PJ, even though there were a few good ones in there 

Dude your last shows were London ON 13, Hartford 13, Quebec 16, Fenway 16 and London 18. I would say there were a few good ones.