Song Survival - Vs

JPPJ84

2 go 
-
4 rvm -
7 indifference +

Eliminated (with ranking)

4. Animal
5. Blood
6. Rats
7. Daughter
8. W.M.A
9. Elderly Woman Behind the Counter in a Small Town
10. Dissident
11. Leash
12. Glorified G

stuckinline

3 rvm -
8 indifference +

Eliminated (with ranking)

4. Animal
5. Blood
6. Rats
7. Daughter
8. W.M.A
9. Elderly Woman Behind the Counter in a Small Town
10. Dissident
11. Leash
12. Glorified G

JPPJ84

Where’s your Go?!

PJNB

It should be after Stuckinline I think 

1 Go -
3 RVM -
8 Indifference + 

rummy

Go still has one left.
Just an update (not a vote)...
1 Go
3 RVM
8 Indifference

rummy

I'm going to give us a few hours break before we start Vitalogy. This is pretty intense! 

JPPJ84

It’s midnight here, the fate of Indifference is out of my hands  
Until tomorrow, Vitalogy

vito

0 go -
2 rvm -
9 indifference +

Eliminated (with ranking)

4. Animal
5. Blood
6. Rats
7. Daughter
8. W.M.A
9. Elderly Woman Behind the Counter in a Small Town
10. Dissident
11. Leash
12. Glorified G

PJNB

JPPJ84 said:

It’s midnight here, the fate of Indifference is out of my hands  
Until tomorrow, Vitalogy

  

Sobelberg8

3 rvm +
8 indifference -

Eliminated (with ranking)
3. Go

4. Animal
5. Blood
6. Rats
7. Daughter
8. W.M.A
9. Elderly Woman Behind the Counter in a Small Town
10. Dissident
11. Leash
12. Glorified G

PB11041

2 rvm -
9 indifference +

Eliminated (with ranking)
3. Go

4. Animal
5. Blood
6. Rats
7. Daughter
8. W.M.A
9. Elderly Woman Behind the Counter in a Small Town
10. Dissident
11. Leash
12. Glorified G

PJNB

It should be just take aways with rule 5 on the final 2.  We should have 

1 RVM
8 Indifference 

tbergs

Let's end this! Someone finish RVM off!

1 RVM -
10 indifference +

Eliminated (with ranking)
3. Go

4. Animal
5. Blood
6. Rats
7. Daughter
8. W.M.A
9. Elderly Woman Behind the Counter in a Small Town
10. Dissident
11. Leash
12. Glorified G

tbergs

Wait, what? Isn't my vote right?

PJNB

@rummy I believe this one is done? Final 2 rules?

tbergs

Aah, I see. No adding after only 2 left.

PB11041

admittedly, I have been drinking and typing.

mcgruff10

Two slow songs in a row.  Very surprising.

vito

mcgruff10 said:

Two slow songs in a row.  Very surprising.

Will not be surprised it will be 3 in a row when Immortality wins from Vitalogy. They may not be hard rockers but, for me they are the 3 best songs from the first 3 albums.

rummy

mcgruff10 said:

Two slow songs in a row.  Very surprising.

We’re all getting old!

PJNB

vito said:

mcgruff10 said:

Two slow songs in a row.  Very surprising.

Will not be surprised it will be 3 in a row when Immortality wins from Vitalogy. They may not be hard rockers but, for me they are the 3 best songs from the first 3 albums.

Thinking Corduroy for Vitalogy but both of those are amazing songs and in my top 5 with ease. 

tbergs

Immortality to continue the trend! I agree, Release, Indifference and Immortality cut to the soul (especially after some vino - no ice though).

I love Around the Bend, but it lacks the depth of the first 3 closers. 

Glorified KC

Wow I thought RVM was going to have this one decisively.  

vito

tbergs said:

Immortality to continue the trend! I agree, Release, Indifference and Immortality cut to the soul (especially after some vino - no ice though).

I love Around the Bend, but it lacks the depth of the first 3 closers. 

 Present Tense isn't an all out rocker although it does jam out at one point like Immortality but, to me qualifies much in the same vein as Release, Indifference and Immortality in that it builds slowly and deeply crushes your emotions.

rummy

I’ll put Vitalogy up before I crash tonight (in BC). That way our European members will get a chance to play a round or two!

rummy

Now this is SONG survival. I guess I still have to include Stupid Mop et al?!

rummy

Wait! This hasn’t officially ended yet!
Edit. My bad. It has.

rummy

vito said:

tbergs said:

Immortality to continue the trend! I agree, Release, Indifference and Immortality cut to the soul (especially after some vino - no ice though).

I love Around the Bend, but it lacks the depth of the first 3 closers. 

 Present Tense isn't an all out rocker although it does jam out at one point like Immortality but, to me qualifies much in the same vein as Release, Indifference and Immortality in that it builds slowly and deeply crushes your emotions.

Hot take: No Code would have benefited if it had ended after Present Tense.
(last three tracks are the weakest...prove me wrong two polls from now!!!)

rummy

Summary
1. Indifference
2. Rearviewmirror

3. Go
4. Animal
5. Blood
6. Rats
7. Daughter
8. W.M.A
9. Elderly Woman Behind the Counter in a Small Town
10. Dissident
11. Leash
12. Glorified G

vito

rummy said:

vito said:

tbergs said:

Immortality to continue the trend! I agree, Release, Indifference and Immortality cut to the soul (especially after some vino - no ice though).

I love Around the Bend, but it lacks the depth of the first 3 closers. 

 Present Tense isn't an all out rocker although it does jam out at one point like Immortality but, to me qualifies much in the same vein as Release, Indifference and Immortality in that it builds slowly and deeply crushes your emotions.

Hot take: No Code would have benefited if it had ended after Present Tense.
(last three tracks are the weakest...prove me wrong two polls from now!!!)

I will definitely give you Mankind and I'm Open but, I do like Around The Bend just not as the last song. I too would've closed the album with Present Tense.