Song Survival - Ten

CPR7

2 Alive -
2 Porch -
15 Release +

Let's go! Vs. Next right?

rummy

It's coming... it’d be nice if Alive and Porch are not eliminated simultaneously (according to rule #4).

vito

3 people posted at the same time, lol

PJNB

CPR7 said:

1 Alive -
1 Porch -
16 Release +

Let's go! Vs. Next right?

corrected 

0 Porch  -
0 Alive   -
 
17 Release +

rummy

PJNB said:

0 Porch  -
0 Alive   -
 
17 Release +

Rule 4? Can you choose?

PJNB

rummy said:

PJNB said:

0 Porch  -
0 Alive   -
 
17 Release +

Rule 4? Can you choose?

Porch #3 So is Alive still alive lol? 

rummy

Maybe we should end it. Release destroyed this!!!

1. Release
2. Alive
3. Porch
4. Black
5. Once
6. Garden
7. Why Go 
8. Even Flow
9. Oceans
10. Deep
11. Jeremy 

PJNB

Thanks for starting this rummy! New thread for VS or this one you thinking with a new title?

mcgruff10

Lost dogs should be fun! Nice work Matt!!!

rummy

I’m away from my lap top right now but I will post Vs asap.

Reflections? Any reason why Alive and Black (and Porch) seem to do better than these sorts of things than Even Glow and Jeremy?

I love Release but like it waaay better on the bootlegs. Did that influence any of your choices?

rummy

PJNB said:

Thanks for starting this rummy! New thread for VS or this one you thinking with a new title?

I’ll create a new thread shortly.
(I guess this is our Friday nights these days).

rummy

mcgruff10 said:

Lost dogs should be fun! Nice work Matt!!!

Ugh. I can I least include Leatherman and Angel in there? WHY WEREN’T THESE SONGS INCLUDED????

vito

My only surprise was that Jeremy was first out and not Even Flow.

Sobelberg8

rummy said:

mcgruff10 said:

Lost dogs should be fun! Nice work Matt!!!

Ugh. I can I least include Leatherman and Angel in there? WHY WEREN’T THESE SONGS INCLUDED????

Do an extras category with those two, Breath, SOLAT, Of The Earth, Cant Deny Me, Olympic Platinum, Falling Down, Happy When I’m Crying so on and so forth

JPPJ84

Geez,  wake up and nothing’s left to vote for. Poor Porch, my number 2

cool idea, Rummy!
Problem with lost dogs is that it’s so many songs. There’ll be 5 people voting at once because it takes so long 

rummy

JPPJ84 said:

Geez,  wake up and nothing’s left to vote for. Poor Porch, my number 2

cool idea, Rummy!
Problem with lost dogs is that it’s so many songs. There’ll be 5 people voting at once because it takes so long 

It got a little intense this afternoon.- but there's the Vs. poll going on now!
We'd have to break Lost Dogs up into its respective discs and then do at least one other list with all the other tracks like Breath, State, I Got Id, Long Road, Leatherman, etc.
Another option is to simply divide the non-album tracks up into their eras (e.g, 1992-1994, 1995-1998, etc).

JPPJ84

rummy said:

JPPJ84 said:

Geez,  wake up and nothing’s left to vote for. Poor Porch, my number 2

cool idea, Rummy!
Problem with lost dogs is that it’s so many songs. There’ll be 5 people voting at once because it takes so long 

It got a little intense this afternoon.- but there's the Vs. poll going on now!
We'd have to break Lost Dogs up into its respective discs and then do at least one other list with all the other tracks like Breath, State, I Got Id, Long Road, Leatherman, etc.
Another option is to simply divide the non-album tracks up into their eras (e.g, 1992-1994, 1995-1998, etc).

Oh I like the eras idea!

cutz

My VERY Guesstimated Stats

32 People Voted
92 Total Votes
14 Voted Once
6 Voted 5 times or more
2 Voted 7 Times
1 Voted 8 Times
1 Voted 11 Times (You will remain nameless>LOL> unlike   

 https://youtu.be/QaTbErVDQ40 )