Home› Words and Music...Communication

Lost Dogs

Fetus Jr.Fetus Jr. Posts: 26
edited May 2007 in Words and Music...Communication
I've been listening to Disc 1 alot lately and I was wondering if they have ever played many of those songs live?

I heard Alone in STL '04 but have they ever played Sad, Undone, Education, Hold On, Black Red Yellow, or In the Moonlight?

I'd love to hear any of those songs live.
I traded magic for fact...then I traded back.
Post edited by Unknown User on

Comments

  • DarkStarDarkStar Posts: 734
    Fetus Jr. wrote:
    I've been listening to Disc 1 alot lately and I was wondering if they have ever played many of those songs live?

    I heard Alone in STL '04 but have they ever played Sad, Undone, Education, Hold On, Black Red Yellow, or In the Moonlight?

    I'd love to hear any of those songs live.

    I've been listening to disc I a lot too...all the way to work...all day at work...all the way home...then at home...been doing this for about two weeks straight. To answer your question…


    All Night
    o Never played live.

    Sad
    o first time played on 10/01/04
    o last time played on 10/03/04

    Down
    o first time played 12/05/02
    o last time played 09/28/04

    In The Moonlight
    o Never played live.

    Hitchhiker
    o Never played live.

    Don't Gimme No Lip
    o Never played live.

    Alone
    o first time played 10/22/90 (as Mookie Blaylock)
    o last time played 10/05/04

    Education
    o Never played live.

    U
    o done on 05/01/98 in soundcheck?; done on 10/11/00
    o last time played on 10/06/04

    Black, Red, Yellow
    o first time played 11/09/96 (in soundcheck)
    o first time played in concert in part (09/26/96 Daughter jam)
    o played in concert in full 11/17/96 and 11/24/96 (soundchecked 07/14/03 Ed solo)

    Leaving Her
    o first time played 06/19/95
    o last time played 07/19/03

    Gremmie Out Of Control
    o Never played live.

    Whale Song
    o Never played live.

    Undone
    o Never played live.

    Hold On
    o Never played live

    Yellow Ledbetter
    o first time played 11/06/93 (riffs heard earlier--i.e., 03/02/92, 05/05/92, and 08/29/92)
    o last time played 10/08/04)

    props go out to http://theskyiscrape.com/setlists/index.php and http://www.pjvault.com/songlists.html

    ds
    And no one sings me lullabyes
    And no one makes me close my eyes
    So I throw the windows wide
    And call to you across the sky....
  • armanHammerarmanHammer Posts: 471
    Yellow Ledbetter closes every show.

    I know Down has been played a few times, once at Benaroya Hall
    Riverside.. LA.. California. EV?
  • my name is corymy name is cory Posts: 1
    armanHammer wrote:
    Yellow Ledbetter closes every show.

    I know Down has been played a few times, once at Benaroya Hall


    Not every show, but many. I have been to five concerts and only heard it once.
    "It is by the goodness of God that in our country we have those three unspeakably precious things: freedom of speech, freedom of conscience, and the prudence never to practice either."

    -Mark Twain
  • a5pja5pj Posts: 3,896
    Sad is such an awesome song, I was lucky enough to see it live in Reading last year. I hope they play it a lot on their next tour.
    Wouldn't it be funny if the world ended in 2010, with lots of fire?



  • kmac5576kmac5576 Posts: 11
    If I can switch the thread to disc 2 for a moment, what is the name and story behind the hidden track played after bee girl? anybody know?
    9/1/1998 - Atlanta
    8/12/2000 - Tampa
    8/14/2000 - New Orleans
    4/19/2003 - Atlanta
    5/13/2006 - Hartford
    5/24/2006 - Boston
    6/30/2008 - Mansfield
    5/15/2010 - Hartford
    5/17/2010 - Boston
  • Angled lightAngled light Posts: 7
    kmac5576 wrote:
    If I can switch the thread to disc 2 for a moment, what is the name and story behind the hidden track played after bee girl? anybody know?

    it was recorded by Ed the day that Layne Stayley's death was discovered. The title is that date

    4/20/02 i believe.
    love is a tower, of strength to me
    i am the shoreline, but you're the sea
  • Angled lightAngled light Posts: 7
    a5pj wrote:
    Sad is such an awesome song, I was lucky enough to see it live in Reading last year. I hope they play it a lot on their next tour.


    yeah i saw it there too, it was awesome... i was very suprised to see Ed not playing the guitar during it though.
    love is a tower, of strength to me
    i am the shoreline, but you're the sea
  • AbuskedtiAbuskedti Posts: 1,917
    DarkStar wrote:
    I've been listening to disc I a lot too...all the way to work...all day at work...all the way home...then at home...been doing this for about two weeks straight. To answer your question…


    All Night
    o Never played live.

    Sad
    o first time played on 10/01/04
    o last time played on 10/03/04

    Down
    o first time played 12/05/02
    o last time played 09/28/04

    In The Moonlight
    o Never played live.

    Hitchhiker
    o Never played live.

    Don't Gimme No Lip
    o Never played live.

    Alone
    o first time played 10/22/90 (as Mookie Blaylock)
    o last time played 10/05/04

    Education
    o Never played live.

    U
    o done on 05/01/98 in soundcheck?; done on 10/11/00
    o last time played on 10/06/04

    Black, Red, Yellow
    o first time played 11/09/96 (in soundcheck)
    o first time played in concert in part (09/26/96 Daughter jam)
    o played in concert in full 11/17/96 and 11/24/96 (soundchecked 07/14/03 Ed solo)

    Leaving Her
    o first time played 06/19/95
    o last time played 07/19/03

    Gremmie Out Of Control
    o Never played live.

    Whale Song
    o Never played live.

    Undone
    o Never played live.

    Hold On
    o Never played live

    Yellow Ledbetter
    o first time played 11/06/93 (riffs heard earlier--i.e., 03/02/92, 05/05/92, and 08/29/92)
    o last time played 10/08/04)

    props go out to http://theskyiscrape.com/setlists/index.php and http://www.pjvault.com/songlists.html

    ds

    Well we have something in common. I have been know to listen to that disk 24 hours a day.
  • Fetus Jr.Fetus Jr. Posts: 26
    Wow...that answers my question fully. thanks.

    I think they should definitely play In the Moonlight, Don't Gimmie No Lip, and Undone on this next tour then. Maybe even some Hold On, beautiful song.
    I traded magic for fact...then I traded back.
  • Fetus Jr.Fetus Jr. Posts: 26
    Oh, and another thing I was wanting to put out there for you guys....

    I'm sure you've all read the booklet on the songs, and I was thinking..how do you think these songs (one's from regular PJ albums) would have change the album.

    In other words, if In the Moonlight and Sad would've made it on Binaural would it have made the cd better, worse? Same goes for Alone and Yellow Ledbetter on Ten....

    Don't get me wrong I love the albums how they are, but any of the Lost Dogs from 1 or 2 could have made it on those albums, and that's incredible in the least.
    I traded magic for fact...then I traded back.
  • armanHammerarmanHammer Posts: 471
    Fetus Jr. wrote:
    Oh, and another thing I was wanting to put out there for you guys....

    I'm sure you've all read the booklet on the songs, and I was thinking..how do you think these songs (one's from regular PJ albums) would have change the album.

    In other words, if In the Moonlight and Sad would've made it on Binaural would it have made the cd better, worse? Same goes for Alone and Yellow Ledbetter on Ten....

    Don't get me wrong I love the albums how they are, but any of the Lost Dogs from 1 or 2 could have made it on those albums, and that's incredible in the least.

    In the Moonlight just doesn't go with Binaural in my opinion. Yellow Ledbetter on the other hand should have been on Ten. It's PJ's best song evar.
    Riverside.. LA.. California. EV?
  • DarkStarDarkStar Posts: 734
    Abuskedti wrote:
    Well we have something in common. I have been know to listen to that disk 24 hours a day.

    haha. we're both human too...so we have that in common as well. :D

    ds
    And no one sings me lullabyes
    And no one makes me close my eyes
    So I throw the windows wide
    And call to you across the sky....
  • Angled lightAngled light Posts: 7
    armanHammer wrote:
    In the Moonlight just doesn't go with Binaural in my opinion. Yellow Ledbetter on the other hand should have been on Ten. It's PJ's best song evar.

    Would you still think it is there best ever if it were on the record??

    I think its place is perfect.

    Lets also remember that as good as YL is, it is a SRV tribute,

    the album had to be more original than that.

    i like it the way they did it.

    respect to all opinions.

    if one were to make an album, i'd say Hard to Imagine or Other Side.
    love is a tower, of strength to me
    i am the shoreline, but you're the sea
  • samsubusamsubu Posts: 1
    yellow ledbetter-SRV tribute! maybe i'm just dumb, but what does SRV stand for?
  • MerkyjammMerkyjamm Posts: 272
    To ruin the thread, I like the boots where they close with Fuckin' Up, just a personal thing!
    Too many cowboys, not enough indians, so just go ape shit!

    I may be boring but at least I'm not Jack fucking Johnson.

    TV is such shit; let's go outside and ride bicycles, right now!

    Madrid 07/09/06 - Little mofo'ing Wing!!!
    Wembley 06/18/07 - Speechless

    www.last.fm/user/StNick_
  • Angled lightAngled light Posts: 7
    samvedder wrote:
    yellow ledbetter-SRV tribute! maybe i'm just dumb, but what does SRV stand for?



    STEVIE RAY VAUGHAN




    also the lyrics, from what they tell me, were Ed improv. Outstanding!
    love is a tower, of strength to me
    i am the shoreline, but you're the sea
  • this is not for youthis is not for you Posts: 240
    DarkStar wrote:

    Sad
    o first time played on 10/01/04
    o last time played on 10/03/04

    [
    ds



    they played sad at reading last year...





    EDIT



    shit, how long ago was this thread started
  • Got Some If You Need ItGot Some If You Need It Posts: 435
    i have heard education played during daughter once during the end when they usually start some other song riff, can't remember off the top of my head when though

    don't gimme no lip has been played i'm sure several times, it was played at Rio de Janiero 12/4/05 and its sung by stone gossard
    PJ: Hartford 6/27/08 Mansfield 6/30/08 Philly 3 Oct. 30 2009
    Philly 4 Oct. 31 2009 Hartford May 2010 Boston May 2010 MSG 1 May 2010
    EV: Albany 1 and 2 June 2009 Providence June 15 2011 Hartford June 18 2011
  • Hitch-HikerHitch-Hiker Posts: 2,873
    The played Education twice last year - Dublin and Zagreb, and I was there for both :D
    I'll Ride The Wave Where It Takes Me
  • BrezBrez Posts: 570
    They played Sad at Boston I last year too.
    And before his first step... He's off again...
  • Unbelievable21Unbelievable21 Posts: 35
    DarkStar wrote:
    haha. we're both human too...so we have that in common as well. :D

    ds

    Heh... You two aren't the only ones!

    Unfortunately, I haven't been lucky enough to have seen Pearl Jam live, but I would LOVE to... but I don't have my license, so I have to wait until they come to a close stadium or something. I would love to hear Sad (my 1st of 2 favorite songs on the album, tied with Yellow Ledbetter), Hard to Imagine, Last Kiss, Strangest Tribe, Down... hell, I'd love to hear this whole album live!

    Hey, Metallica did it with Master Of Puppets, so it could happen. But it probably won't.
  • TizoffthechainTizoffthechain Posts: 116
    I keep listening to no 2, sometimes I wonder if I will ever get tired of them? I loved them at the beginning of the 90s but I was only a teenager, then, after YELD, it kind of stopped for a few years and after having seeing them live 4 the 1st time last summer..it s worst than 15 years ago only I am not a teenager anymore!!!! Really one the greatest bands ever!
    "Come on people now, smile on your brother and everybody get together, try to love one another right now!!!!"
    "You my friend, I will defend and if we change, well I love you anyway"
    "I know I was born and I know that I'll die, the in between is mine, I AM MINE"
  • JordyWordyJordyWordy Posts: 2,261
    Fetus Jr. wrote:
    I'm sure you've all read the booklet on the songs, and I was thinking..how do you think these songs (one's from regular PJ albums) would have change the album.

    In other words, if In the Moonlight and Sad would've made it on Binaural would it have made the cd better, worse? Same goes for Alone and Yellow Ledbetter on Ten....

    All Night was on the draft tracklisting for No Code, and Fatal was meant to be on Binaural but was dropped at last minute - they wouldve been great inclusions i think. theres a website that seems to have the draft tracklists somewhere, ill try find it...

    anybody else think the best thing about Lost Dogs is the incredible guitars on Brother??
Sign In or Register to comment.