Home› Words and Music...Communication

Live or Album

given2fly5given2fly5 Posts: 8
edited December 2003 in Words and Music...Communication
What Songs do you like live exponentially better than on the Album? And what songs get you on the album more so than live?

Nothing compares to a live Smile, 1/2 full and wishlist.

But there is something to be said for the studio versions of courdury.
Post edited by Unknown User on

Comments

  • MrBrianMrBrian Posts: 2,672
    Originally posted by given2fly5
    What Songs do you like live exponentially better than on the Album? And what songs get you on the album more so than live?

    Nothing compares to a live Smile, 1/2 full and wishlist.

    But there is something to be said for the studio versions of courdury.

    Crazy mary is amazing live, corduroy is better studio

    I think they play even flow 2 quickly lol so I like the studio better,
  • {[No_Code}]{[No_Code}] Posts: 4,059
    IN My Tree live... is better...

    NAIS
    Almost all the songs...

    but i prefer... Tremor Christ and Satan's Bed and Oceans from studio
    So that is how I learned the lesson that everyone is alone. And your eyes must do some raining if you are ever going to grow. But when crying don't help and you can't compose yourself. It is best to compose a poem, an honest longing or simple song of hope.
    That is why I'm singing
  • PJ17MKDPJ17MKD Posts: 136
    It is a unique love for every song and every version of the song , doesn't matter live or studio , if you like the song you like the song ... of course at one time you'd like to hear some version of that song many times more than the other version of it but after awhile you'll get back to the version you put to rest sooo ...
  • magnusmagnus Posts: 26
    hey,

    i feel that the songs they have written most recently are the songs that they perform with the most passion at any one point in time.....

    take live at the garden....... love boat captain and particularly save you COMPLETELY blew me away, as did crop duster (i thought matt cameron was gonna burst a major blood vessel)

    although i was also impressed with how much care and passion black was performed, considering the hundreds/thousands of times they have done it live......
    mag
  • time to dreamtime to dream Posts: 26
    It all depends on the day, but "I got shit" is one that really sticks out that I like live allot. And the jam session on RVM kicks a littl tail too.
    we can dream, and we can make dreams come true for others
  • Alive AgainAlive Again Posts: 71
    Correct me if I'm wrong, but I haven't heard a really good live performance of Breath. I love the studio version. I think Do The Evolution is more energetic live.
    ". . . as each breath goes by I only own my mind."
  • oldermanolderman Posts: 1,765
    1/2 Full live is awesome.. I also like Long Road live, any version
    Down the street you can hear her scream youre a disgrace
    As she slams the door in his drunken face
    And now he stands outside
    And all the neighbours start to gossip and drool
    He cries oh, girl you must be mad,
    What happened to the sweet love you and me had?
    Against the door he leans and starts a scene,
    And his tears fall and burn the garden green
  • dissident7dissident7 Posts: 4
    I do think that most of their songs sound better live. It just feels like that's the way the music is meant to be heard.
    Some of the best sounding live songs to me:

    Not for You, Long Road, Alive, Betterman, Save You

    I particularly like any song live that you can really hear the crowd singing along. To me there's nothing better than singing Pearl Jam songs with a few thousand Pearl Jam fanatics.
    I'll ride the wave where it takes me

    I'll hold the pain, RELEASE ME!
  • brain of cbrain of c Posts: 5,213
    live music is better......

    bumper stickers should be issued........:)
    d'oh!!!!!!

    http://www.myspace.com/brain_of_c
  • eddies grrleddies grrl Posts: 509
    Black, on East Troy 10.8.2000

    Even Flow on Seattle 11.6.2000

    Hail Hail on Seattle 11.6.2000 ("I don't wanna fuck, I wanna feeeel")

    Long Road, Mansfield (Boston) 7.11.2003

    Betterman on Vitalogy, because it has that beautiful, quiet buildup without any background noise and his voice is AMAYYYYZING

    Indifference on Vs. just because he breaks my heart when I hear it
    Life is the riddle
    Of which we're caught in the middle.
    A couple of lucky ones
    Tangled up in too much love
    ~cowboy junkies
  • eddies grrleddies grrl Posts: 509
    Originally posted by dissident7
    I do think that most of their songs sound better live. It just feels like that's the way the music is meant to be heard.
    Some of the best sounding live songs to me:

    Not for You, Long Road, Alive, Betterman, Save You


    I actually like Not For You in ANY form. That song would kick ass even if he recorded it in the shower.
    Life is the riddle
    Of which we're caught in the middle.
    A couple of lucky ones
    Tangled up in too much love
    ~cowboy junkies
  • theskyiscrapetheskyiscrape Posts: 69
    corduroy live sounds so much better...
    em ot sselecirp si y c a v i r p
  • unlincedunlinced Posts: 21
    Originally posted by eddie's grrl
    I actually like Not For You in ANY form. That song would kick ass even if he recorded it in the shower.

    i feel a new dvd coming on...
    ...well i guess there's nothing wong with what you say...
  • clallsevenclallseven Posts: 6
    Originally posted by {[No_Code}]
    IN My Tree live... is better...

    NAIS
    Almost all the songs...

    but i prefer... Tremor Christ and Satan's Bed and Oceans from studio

    Amen to In My Tree...this was a song I never gave much of a chance until I heard it live. Totally changed my perspective. now it's one of my all time favorites.

    State of Love & Trust is waaaaaaaaaay better outta the studio.
    9/5/00, 4/26/03, 5/3/03, 7/1/03
  • clallsevenclallseven Posts: 6
    I read what I wrote and it didn't sound right. The studio version of SOLAT is better - that's what I literally meant.
    9/5/00, 4/26/03, 5/3/03, 7/1/03
  • brother123brother123 Posts: 792
    I think Crazy Mary, corduroy, Black is better in the studio. Although if the band is truley on top of their game that night any song would truley kick ass
    <a href="http://smg.photobucket.com/albums/v44/brother123/?action=view&current=thewh0.png&quot; target="_blank"><img src="http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v44/brother123/thewh0.png&quot; border="0" alt="Photobucket"></a>
  • take my handtake my hand Posts: 11
    I think most definitely Even flow is way better live than on album..actually thinking about it, the more enegetic songs tend to sound that much better than on record...most probably the atmosphere of the concert that does it
  • lazygun_99lazygun_99 Posts: 73
    I have never heard a live version of Long Road which isnt amazing.
Sign In or Register to comment.