*The "NEW" In My Tree appreciation thread*

VEDHEAD27

I love it! Sorry but this post had to me made. All I hear is bad stuff about it and it's about damn time this song got some lovin. Despite it's extreme differences to the original, this song still kicks some major ass. Yes it may not have those awesome drums and it's missing a few OG lyrics...but so what?!?! The boys rebirthed this song. Everything I thought I would dislike about it (from all the stuff I heard) is actually everything I love about it. I finally got to hear it for the very first time at MSG 1 (the night of all nights) and I was in absolute heaven!! Now there are 2 versions of this song to love. Awesome!!

Anyways PJ, thanks for the "new" In My Tree. Thanks for mixing things up. I appreciate the hell outta it.

VEDHEAD27

Awww I am so not surprised. The "new" In My Tree gets no love.
:(

*hugs "new" In My Tree*

I love you.

pears

i was listening to a boot today on the treadmill.. and this song came on. i loved it!

{[Pearl_Jam}]

NEW IN MY TREE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

i loved... In My Tree old version was the best song... but now new In My Tree is the best

MeddleDeal

HEY you know I was going to give LOVE to the NEW In My Tree:D

I WAS there! I was BLOWN away by it, no drums, but hey, that was great though and brought new life into that song. I think everyone at MSG I was shocked to hear that song. I remember that we were all standing around, and then we realize what song it was, and everyone was screaming w/excitement.

Good times and I am NEVER sick and tired of hearing this boot and verison. KICK ASS!!!

VEDHEAD27

RIGHT ON guys!

Glad to see others givin it some love as well.

gogol

I do love the new version, anyone have a link to the MSG song because I only have the Camden version. Even though it's great, Ed does come in too early at the end and I'd really like a perfect version of it. It was always my favorite song before and I really love the new version. Thanks

MeddleDeal

I need to import the song on my itunes some day and I'll send it your way:D

PhillyPJ

old version is better. but not a big deal. either way works

thebetterman

this version kinda surprised me, i heard it in camden, and at first i didnt know what it was, but it just is a very powerful song, i love it both ways, but the new version is chilling

MeddleDeal

Originally posted by thebetterman
this version kinda surprised me, i heard it in camden, and at first i didnt know what it was, but it just is a very powerful song, i love it both ways, but the new version is chilling

i agree Kevin. It sent chills down my spine hearing that in MSG 1...it was quite a shocker!

{[Pearl_Jam}]

i loved since the first time i heard at the Detroit 2 boot... it surprised me as well

brainofPJ

Originally posted by {[Pearl_Jam}]
i loved since the first time i heard at the Detroit 2 boot... it surprised me as well

Woohoo!!!! DEtroit 2!!!! woohoo woohoo!!!

love the song, don't love Boom on the song though.

{[Pearl_Jam}]

i really enjoy the participation of Boom in In My Tree

by the way.. Detroit 2 is one of the shows shows of the tour very underrated show

VEDHEAD27

Originally posted by {[Pearl_Jam}]
i really enjoy the participation of Boom in In My Tree

Me too! Yes, it is very different...but that's what I like.

{[Pearl_Jam}]

yeah...

it means add something in your music... make something different ... experiment something... and it fited perfectly....

Kaddikat

im still getting used to this version... but the uh no code version gets me everytime.. heheheeheh...

*waves to all my friends*

Kaddikat

ok..
im listening to msg right now..

im diggin this version today..

inner sense

is there any way i can get a listen to it without buying the whole bootleg

MeddleDeal

i love the new version, pretty awesome that they added the keyboard part!!

VEDHEAD27

Yeah, once you accept this version, you can see all of the good things about it (and there are many). Glad others can appreciate.:D

inner sense, do you have aol instant messenger? I can send it to you.

Kaddikat

im still getting used to it.. but i totally zoned today at work and listened to msg (*waves to nadia*) wowwwwwwwwwwwwww..

you guys i cannot believe we were THERE.. :eek:

{[Pearl_Jam}]

i think i'll listen MSG1 next weekend
IN MY TREE

MeddleDeal

Originally posted by Kaddikat
im still getting used to it.. but i totally zoned today at work and listened to msg (*waves to nadia*) wowwwwwwwwwwwwww..

you guys i cannot believe we were THERE.. :eek:

**Waves back at Kaddi!!**

Oh i know, i STILL can't believe that we were there, it feels too good to be true ya know. :eek:

When they started playing that part, I was like, "what the hell is this song?" look on my face. Then I think, I don't remember if this was on this song, but Joe, the guy behind us, asked us, what they are playing, and Lyd said "in my tree" wasn't it Lyd? haha. I don't remember much about the convo. haha. Lyd, please correct me. haha

time2escape

i feel neglected,
the old one is good to,,,,,,,,,,,


and gotta a glempse of my innocense that was my innocense,,,,,,blahh

Kaddikat

just listened to it.. ok i can say i can dig it man! its actually nifty... yeah it just had to CLICK with me i guess

VEDHEAD27

YES!! The "new" In My Tree conquers another!!

WOOHOO!

Yeah it's true, it may take some time but when it clicks it CLICKS.

I dig it too. The more to love.

MeddleDeal

girl, I listened to BOTH verisons of that song one night...truly awesome!!! MSG I verison had no drums, but DAMN, that guitar part was rockin' though:D

now what are Stone and Jeff singing in the middle part of the song?

VEDHEAD27

Originally posted by MeddleDeal
now what are Stone and Jeff singing in the middle part of the song?

Hmmmm, interesting. It's suppose to be....

"Oh, the blue sky it's his hooooome..."


But it sounds like (in the MSG version anyway) that they are sayin someting along the lines of...

"All, the stars....fall."


Hmmmm. I really don't know though.

MeddleDeal

you see, I was trying to listen what the heck they were saying on BOTH verisons...hmmm, thanks Lyd though:D which makes sense as well:)

eddies grrl

This song cracks me up. It's only one of my favorites on No Code, but I can't help it- when I hear it I giggle- and dance around like an idiot. i cannot stay still when I hear it. I can hear it now, in my head, and my ass is wiggling!!!!!!