@PJRadio's All-Time LIVE25 The best live Pearl Jam cuts SiriusXM Pearl Jam Radio

demetrios

Today @ 12pm EST

Spiritual_Chaos

NHiding said:

Spiritual_Chaos said:

I think my problem with Robs shows is the (constant) hyperbole.

Have a problem with the "sucking the dick of the thing you 'love'" mentality.

Would have loved Pj Radio to be more critical/balanced. Instead of Fox viwe on fair and balanced.

Now onto an amazing version of Immortality.

The job of the station is to promote the band and the best they have to offer. You really want to hear me say, Oh, and here's a version where they just f'd it up to the max? And who needs a radio channel to be critical when there's this forum! As for the list and the entire concept, I'm the first one to tell you it's the most subjective thing and almost impossible to be definitive by any stretch of the imagination, hence why I insisted on a Volume 1 so we can just keep doing it and I'm more than happy to take all of eveyone's suggestions and find more great versions of things. I honestly wasn't paying any attention to geographical locales of the songs, but perhaps those can be future countdowns...The Best of Oz, The Best of SA, The Best of Canada etc.

Yeah, I understand that and what your job is and what the station is. Sorry if you interpreted what I said as dickish. Just a general thought and preference.

I loved your'e explenation on the inclusion of Benaroya Black etc. Don't have a problem with the subjectivity.

And a "25 worst live fuck ups" would be a cool show though.

Spiritual_Chaos

Finding a good Hail Hail version must be all about looking for that great bass-tail Jeff does.

Porch was great.

Benaroya-Black might be the best version out there. Milan 2006 is my go to though.

Spiritual_Chaos

NHiding said:

Spiritual_Chaos said:

I think my problem with Robs shows is the (constant) hyperbole.

Have a problem with the "sucking the dick of the thing you 'love'" mentality.

Would have loved Pj Radio to be more critical/balanced. Instead of Fox viwe on fair and balanced.

Now onto an amazing version of Immortality.

The job of the station is to promote the band and the best they have to offer. You really want to hear me say, Oh, and here's a version where they just f'd it up to the max? And who needs a radio channel to be critical when there's this forum! As for the list and the entire concept, I'm the first one to tell you it's the most subjective thing and almost impossible to be definitive by any stretch of the imagination, hence why I insisted on a Volume 1 so we can just keep doing it and I'm more than happy to take all of eveyone's suggestions and find more great versions of things. I honestly wasn't paying any attention to geographical locales of the songs, but perhaps those can be future countdowns...The Best of Oz, The Best of SA, The Best of Canada etc.

And how big are the chances on getting Dave A on as a guest?

Spiritual_Chaos

Obviously a panteon Breath.

My dream would be to get a soundboard version of the 2007 Copenhagen version. If I remember that night correctly it was a spontaneous inclusion by Eddie, and (together with Hard top imagine) made my night.

Copenhagen 2007 was tiiiiight.

rummy

Spiritual_Chaos said:

Finding a good Hail Hail version must be all about looking for that great bass-tail Jeff does.

Porch was great.

Benaroya-Black might be the best version out there. Milan 2006 is my go to though.

Milan 2006 is one of my favourites, too. Cleveland 2006 is also great as are (a little Canadian bias) Toronto 2011 and Vancouver 2013).

Wait a second, isn't there a "Best live version of Black" of thread somewhere on this forum?

jksimpkins

demetrios said:

Spiritual_Chaos said:

Would love a link.

Is every song discussed?

PM sent. Hear for yourself.

Can I get a link too?

demetrios

jksimpkins said:

demetrios said:

Spiritual_Chaos said:

Would love a link.

Is every song discussed?

PM sent. Hear for yourself.

Can I get a link too?

You got it.

Jed

Can I please request the link too? I missed the beginning.

davidos

Could someone please PM me the link!
Thx!

pjhawks

NHiding said:

Spiritual_Chaos said:

I think my problem with Robs shows is the (constant) hyperbole.

Have a problem with the "sucking the dick of the thing you 'love'" mentality.

Would have loved Pj Radio to be more critical/balanced. Instead of Fox viwe on fair and balanced.

Now onto an amazing version of Immortality.

The job of the station is to promote the band and the best they have to offer. You really want to hear me say, Oh, and here's a version where they just f'd it up to the max? And who needs a radio channel to be critical when there's this forum! As for the list and the entire concept, I'm the first one to tell you it's the most subjective thing and almost impossible to be definitive by any stretch of the imagination, hence why I insisted on a Volume 1 so we can just keep doing it and I'm more than happy to take all of eveyone's suggestions and find more great versions of things. I honestly wasn't paying any attention to geographical locales of the songs, but perhaps those can be future countdowns...The Best of Oz, The Best of SA, The Best of Canada etc.

I think some of the f-ups are great though. I still enjoy Last Kiss from 2003 Las Vegas show, where not only does Ed fuck it up but the crowd does to. Just great stuff. Nothing wrong with having some fun.

I did a version on my Ipod a few years ago of the best version of every song from PJ. Most were live versions but some were studio. I had about 20 bootlegs to go with it. Was fun putting the list together.

I'd love to hear a Best of Philly. i could definitely put together a nice list for that i should put a list together...

NHiding

Spiritual_Chaos said:

NHiding said:

Spiritual_Chaos said:

I think my problem with Robs shows is the (constant) hyperbole.

Have a problem with the "sucking the dick of the thing you 'love'" mentality.

Would have loved Pj Radio to be more critical/balanced. Instead of Fox viwe on fair and balanced.

Now onto an amazing version of Immortality.

The job of the station is to promote the band and the best they have to offer. You really want to hear me say, Oh, and here's a version where they just f'd it up to the max? And who needs a radio channel to be critical when there's this forum! As for the list and the entire concept, I'm the first one to tell you it's the most subjective thing and almost impossible to be definitive by any stretch of the imagination, hence why I insisted on a Volume 1 so we can just keep doing it and I'm more than happy to take all of eveyone's suggestions and find more great versions of things. I honestly wasn't paying any attention to geographical locales of the songs, but perhaps those can be future countdowns...The Best of Oz, The Best of SA, The Best of Canada etc.

Yeah, I understand that and what your job is and what the station is. Sorry if you interpreted what I said as dickish. Just a general thought and preference.

I loved your'e explenation on the inclusion of Benaroya Black etc. Don't have a problem with the subjectivity.

And a "25 worst live fuck ups" would be a cool show though.

got ya. glad you enjoyed.

Dr.Teeth and the Electric Mayh

NHiding said:

Spiritual_Chaos said:

I think my problem with Robs shows is the (constant) hyperbole.

Have a problem with the "sucking the dick of the thing you 'love'" mentality.

Would have loved Pj Radio to be more critical/balanced. Instead of Fox viwe on fair and balanced.

Now onto an amazing version of Immortality.

The job of the station is to promote the band and the best they have to offer. You really want to hear me say, Oh, and here's a version where they just f'd it up to the max? And who needs a radio channel to be critical when there's this forum! As for the list and the entire concept, I'm the first one to tell you it's the most subjective thing and almost impossible to be definitive by any stretch of the imagination, hence why I insisted on a Volume 1 so we can just keep doing it and I'm more than happy to take all of eveyone's suggestions and find more great versions of things. I honestly wasn't paying any attention to geographical locales of the songs, but perhaps those can be future countdowns...The Best of Oz, The Best of SA, The Best of Canada etc.

I/2 Full from July 11 2003 needs to be on the next one.

demetrios

This morning @ 8am EST.

PORCH8

Please would somebody be kind enough to PM me a link?
I have just created a new account on here mainly to request this!!!

rgambs

The LBC from St. Paul on 10/19/14 was said to be the debut of the badass JJF jam, but it wasn't, the debut was the first night of the tour on 10/1/14 in Cincinnati. I was there, woot!
I think it was a better version as well, but I'd have to listen back to back to be sure.

SVRDhand13

rgambs said:

The LBC from St. Paul on 10/19/14 was said to be the debut of the badass JJF jam, but it wasn't, the debut was the first night of the tour on 10/1/14 in Cincinnati. I was there, woot!
I think it was a better version as well, but I'd have to listen back to back to be sure.

I noticed that mistake. They did it at ACL too and maybe more. Finally got that version in Tampa last year.

BK221359

Haven't heard the entire Live25 show as of yet, but one of the iconic performances should include the opening track of the Pensacola, FL show in '94. It was a rock for choice show exactly one year after Dr. David Gunn was shot and killed at his clinic. Ed opened the night with I Won't Back Down...I believe this is the first time it was covered live by the band. Very powerful show and tune.

pjtour

rgambs said:

The LBC from St. Paul on 10/19/14 was said to be the debut of the badass JJF jam, but it wasn't, the debut was the first night of the tour on 10/1/14 in Cincinnati. I was there, woot!
I think it was a better version as well, but I'd have to listen back to back to be sure.

Cinci was the debut of the Jumping Jack Flash intro/tag onto LBC but I have to say the St. Paul version is superior.

tbergs

pjtour said:

rgambs said:

The LBC from St. Paul on 10/19/14 was said to be the debut of the badass JJF jam, but it wasn't, the debut was the first night of the tour on 10/1/14 in Cincinnati. I was there, woot!
I think it was a better version as well, but I'd have to listen back to back to be sure.

Cinci was the debut of the Jumping Jack Flash intro/tag onto LBC but I have to say the St. Paul version is superior.

Having been at that show, I would agree