Fantasy Baseball Pearl Jam Poster League

ed243421

Poster selection process poll coming soon

Ninetytworules

ed243421 said:

Let’s start getting this figured out

poster payout:

I guess in the past the payouts included both regular season winners and the playoff winners



do you want to see regular season winners get the same amount of posters as playoff winners or give one of the two more?






Also:


which option would you choose?

Option A:

2 First Half winners: best win % for weeks 1-11

2 Second Half winners: best win % for weeks 12-21

2 Regular season winners: best win % at end of season

3 Playoff winners: 1st, 2nd, & 3rd




Option B:

3 regular season winners: best win %

3 playoff winners: 1st, 2nd, & 3rd

Baseball is about the full season. I don’t think we should be awarding anything for being in first in June.

Santos L. Halper

My poster will be a mystery. I'm good for it...

ewok pants

Ninetytworules said:

ed243421 said:

Let’s start getting this figured out

poster payout:

I guess in the past the payouts included both regular season winners and the playoff winners



do you want to see regular season winners get the same amount of posters as playoff winners or give one of the two more?






Also:


which option would you choose?

Option A:

2 First Half winners: best win % for weeks 1-11

2 Second Half winners: best win % for weeks 12-21

2 Regular season winners: best win % at end of season

3 Playoff winners: 1st, 2nd, & 3rd




Option B:

3 regular season winners: best win %

3 playoff winners: 1st, 2nd, & 3rd

Baseball is about the full season. I don’t think we should be awarding anything for being in first in June.

i agree with this. Option B is the better of the 2.

ed243421

Keep the votes coming

my thinking is that option A keeps teams that are not so good in the first half of the season, more involved in the second half

but whatever is voted on is ok with me

IamTom

ed243421 said:

Keep the votes coming

my thinking is that option A keeps teams that are not so good in the first half of the season, more involved in the second half

but whatever is voted on is ok with me

I think a wooden spoon option is a great idea  

Other than that I'm easy. 

lukinsfridge05

definitely not option A.... dont think you should get anything for leading in the 1st half.
how would you allocate posters for option b?


what do you guys think about this? 
best record in reg season gets 2 posters.  The other division leader gets 1 poster.
That leaves 13 for final standings after playoffs
Champion 7      
2nd place  3           
3rd place   2          
4th place   1             

ed243421

Shouldn’t use division winners

2nd place in 1 division could have a better win % than the other division winner

Ninetytworules

ed243421 said:

Shouldn’t use division winners

2nd place in 1 division could have a better win % than the other division winner

I don’t agree. If I remember correctly you set up the divisions so it would be similar to mlb. It doesn’t matter what the win % is because we are playing an uneven schedule. One division may be easier than the other. 

ed243421

I’m ok with voting on it

Whatever is agreed on

TA243471

lukinsfridge05 said:

definitely not option A.... dont think you should get anything for leading in the 1st half.
how would you allocate posters for option b?


what do you guys think about this? 
best record in reg season gets 2 posters.  The other division leader gets 1 poster.
That leaves 13 for final standings after playoffs
Champion 7      
2nd place  3           
3rd place   2          
4th place   1             

I vote for this payout.  And I think that the Champion should get to at least pick 3 off the top, then allocate the rest.

Slettelleir

I’m on board with option b, or a version thereof...

ed243421

Did we ever decide on a payout?

Slettelleir

What about:
Regular Season:

• 1st Place- 3 Posters 
• 2nd Place- 2 Posters 
• 3rd Place- 1 Poster

Playoffs:

• 1st Place- 6 Posters
• 2nd Place- 3 Posters
• 3rd Place- 1 Poster

just shooting from the hip here, but I'm open for whatever.

ed243421

Dr. Teeth????

Dr.Teeth and the Electric Mayh

I didn’t run it this year. Last year I believe playoff champ and regular season champ had first dibs. 

ed243421

Ok

how would you suggest we do the poster selection process?

ed243421

Slettelleir said:

What about:
Regular Season:

• 1st Place- 3 Posters 
• 2nd Place- 2 Posters 
• 3rd Place- 1 Poster

Playoffs:

• 1st Place- 6 Posters
• 2nd Place- 3 Posters
• 3rd Place- 1 Poster

just shooting from the hip here, but I'm open for whatever.

This looks good to me

?????

Dr.Teeth and the Electric Mayh

ed243421 said:

Slettelleir said:

What about:
Regular Season:

• 1st Place- 3 Posters 
• 2nd Place- 2 Posters 
• 3rd Place- 1 Poster

Playoffs:

• 1st Place- 6 Posters
• 2nd Place- 3 Posters
• 3rd Place- 1 Poster

just shooting from the hip here, but I'm open for whatever.

This looks good to me

?????

Yeah and just alternate like playoffs then regular season then playoffs

ed243421

So which one should we use?