Home› All Encompassing Trip

Which New Star Wars Film is Better?

dmaradona10dmaradona10 Posts: 915
edited December 2016 in All Encompassing Trip
Las Cruces, NM Pan Am Center September 14, 1995
Albuquerque, NM Tingley Coliseum July 7, 1998
New York City, NY MSG May 20, 2010
Eddie Vedder Solo Albuquerque, NM November 9, 2012
Wrigley Field July 19, 2013
LA Nov. 23: 24, 2013
Denver 10-22-14

Which New Star Wars Film is Better? 38 votes

Star Wars Episode VII: The Force Awakens
34%
The JugglerYefaNamiInHiding80ChazzJimmyVpolaris_xdmaradona10BLACK35jeff2040rgambsseanwonEchoesOnMars 13 votes
Rogue One: A Star Wars Story
55%
ledveddermanmcgruff10Poncierrival.MayDay10caifan82PJammer4lifeJason Pon2legschiwhitesoxBIGDaddyWilvduboisePJ1973BentleyspopGM17961HesCalledDyerMerkin BallerthemessengerMedozKRobbyD462 21 votes
Star Wars Episode Shut Up: There Is No Comparison
10%
lolobuggJK_LivineeriepadaveHobbes 4 votes
«1

Comments

  • JimmyVJimmyV Boston's MetroWest Posts: 19,344
    Star Wars Episode VII: The Force Awakens
    I liked Rogue One a lot but I loved Force Awakens.
    ___________________________________________

    "...I changed by not changing at all..."
  • WobbieWobbie Posts: 30,673
    they're all for nerds.
    If I had known then what I know now...

    Vegas 93, Vegas 98, Vegas 00 (10 year show), Vegas 03, Vegas 06
    VIC 07
    EV LA1 08
    Seattle1 09, Seattle2 09, Salt Lake 09, LA4 09
    Columbus 10
    EV LA 11
    Vancouver 11
    Missoula 12
    Portland 13, Spokane 13
    St. Paul 14, Denver 14
    Philly I & II, 16
    Denver 22
  • HesCalledDyerHesCalledDyer Maryland Posts: 16,456
    Rogue One: A Star Wars Story
    Because, let's face it, the story arc of Episode 7 was pretty much an exact copy of 4. And I liked the darkness of Rogue One.
    Star Lake 00 / Pittsburgh 03 / State College 03 / Bristow 03 / Cleveland 06 / Camden II 06 / DC 08 / Pittsburgh 13 / Baltimore 13 / Charlottesville 13 / Cincinnati 14 / St. Paul 14 / Hampton 16 / Wrigley I 16 / Wrigley II 16 / Baltimore 20 / Camden 22 / Baltimore 24
  • MayDay10MayDay10 Posts: 11,787
    edited December 2016
    Rogue One: A Star Wars Story
    I think i need to see them both again

    I voted for rogue one for the same reasons as dyer
  • InHiding80InHiding80 Upland,CA Posts: 7,623
    Star Wars Episode VII: The Force Awakens
    R1 could be better after a rewatch but for now it's TFA.
  • eeriepadaveeeriepadave West Chester, PA Posts: 42,476
    Star Wars Episode Shut Up: There Is No Comparison
    my first reaction was Force awakens, but after seeing rogue one and letting that sink in, it's too close too call for me.
    8/28/98- Camden, NJ
    10/31/09- Philly
    5/21/10- NYC
    9/2/12- Philly, PA
    7/19/13- Wrigley
    10/19/13- Brooklyn, NY
    10/21/13- Philly, PA
    10/22/13- Philly, PA
    10/27/13- Baltimore, MD
    4/28/16- Philly, PA
    4/29/16- Philly, PA
    5/1/16- NYC
    5/2/16- NYC
    9/2/18- Boston, MA
    9/4/18- Boston, MA
    9/14/22- Camden, NJ
    9/7/24- Philly, PA
    9/9/24- Philly, PA
    Tres Mts.- 3/23/11- Philly. PA
    Eddie Vedder- 6/25/11- Philly, PA
    RNDM- 3/9/16- Philly, PA
  • EchoesOnMarsEchoesOnMars Reading, Pennsylvania Posts: 422
    Star Wars Episode VII: The Force Awakens
    Wobbie said:

    they're all for nerds.

    dont be like that
    Philadelphia 2013 (Night 1)
    Philadelphia 2016 (Night 2)
    Upper Darby 2016 (Night 2) (Temple of the Dog)

  • RobbyD462RobbyD462 Victoria BC Posts: 4,812
    Rogue One: A Star Wars Story
    Rogue One kicked ass on Force awakens
    -Seattle,Wash-Key Arena-9/21/9 -Vancouver,B.C-Rogers Arena-12/4/13 -Vancouver,BC-Rogers Arena-5/6/24
    -Seattle,Wash-Key Arena-9/22/9 -Pemberton,B.C-7/17/16
    -Vancouver,B.C-GM Place -9/25/9 -Seattle,Wash-Safeco Field-8/8/18
    -Vancouver,B.C-Pacific Coliseum-9/25/11 -Seattle,Wash-Safeco Field-8/10/18
    -Misoula,MT-Adams Field House-9/30/12 -Vancouver,BC-Rogers Arena-5/4/24

  • RygarRygar Posts: 8,690
    I consider FA to be 'not very good'...is it worth seeing Rogue One?
  • eddieceddiec Posts: 3,946
    Rygar said:

    I consider FA to be 'not very good'...is it worth seeing Rogue One?

    Yes
  • JimmyVJimmyV Boston's MetroWest Posts: 19,344
    Star Wars Episode VII: The Force Awakens
    Rygar said:

    I consider FA to be 'not very good'...is it worth seeing Rogue One?

    Do you consider other Star Wars movies to be good? If so then yes this is worth seeing. If not it might be a skip.
    ___________________________________________

    "...I changed by not changing at all..."
  • F Me In The BrainF Me In The Brain this knows everybody from other commets Posts: 31,603
    Rogue One: A Star Wars Story
    The more I reflect on R1, the more I like it. Think I am going to see it again with my brother.
    I liked FA very much -- but I find when it is on cable I only watch snippets of it. For super fans I can understand why FA would be embraced more, but by most any other measurement I find R1 to be a better film.

    Wob -- we embrace our nerd-dom. Go post about your 50 favorite NCAA teams! ;)
    The love he receives is the love that is saved
  • lolobugglolobugg BLUE RDGE MTNS Posts: 8,195
    Star Wars Episode Shut Up: There Is No Comparison
    Wob One: A DanActive Story

    livefootsteps.org/user/?usr=446

    1995- New Orleans, LA  : New Orleans, LA

    1996- Charleston, SC

    1998- Atlanta, GA: Birmingham, AL: Greenville, SC: Knoxville, TN

    2000- Atlanta, GA: New Orleans, LA: Memphis, TN: Nashville, TN

    2003- Raleigh, NC: Charlotte, NC: Atlanta, GA

    2004- Asheville, NC (hometown show)

    2006- Cincinnati, OH

    2008- Columbia, SC

    2009- Chicago, IL x 2 / Ed Vedder- Atlanta, GA x 2

    2010- Bristow, VA

    2011- Alpine Valley, WI (PJ20) x 2 / Ed Vedder- Chicago, IL

    2012- Atlanta, GA

    2013- Charlotte, NC

    2014- Cincinnati, OH

    2015- New York, NY

    2016- Greenville, SC: Hampton, VA:: Columbia, SC: Raleigh, NC : Lexington, KY: Philly, PA 2: (Wrigley) Chicago, IL x 2 (holy shit): Temple of the Dog- Philly, PA

    2017- ED VED- Louisville, KY

    2018- Chicago, IL x2, Boston, MA x2

    2020- Nashville, TN 

    2022- Smashville 

    2023- Austin, TX x2

    2024- Baltimore

  • polaris_xpolaris_x Posts: 13,559
    Star Wars Episode VII: The Force Awakens
    because the element that is unique to the star wars stories is The Force ... it is remarkably absent as a character unto itself in Rogue One ...

    although the single best sequence of the entire star wars movies for me is the transfer of the plans to leia and vader boarding the ships in Rogue One ...
  • RygarRygar Posts: 8,690
    JimmyV said:

    Rygar said:

    I consider FA to be 'not very good'...is it worth seeing Rogue One?

    Do you consider other Star Wars movies to be good? If so then yes this is worth seeing. If not it might be a skip.
    Big fan of the original trilogy.
  • rgambsrgambs Posts: 13,576
    Star Wars Episode VII: The Force Awakens
    I don't see how R1 could be considered better.
    The character development is incredibly slow for a group of characters that will never be seen again.
    Forrest Whitaker was a huge letdown. Corny character with corny lines that does nothing.
    The acting performances were not up to snuff with FA, but the action was pretty good.
    The Vader scene was badass, a perfect blend of speed and immobility for him, light years ahead of the fighting from the originals.
    There should have been a few more scenes with Vader, they were the highlights of the film.
    Monkey Driven, Call this Living?
  • JK_LivinJK_Livin South Jersey Posts: 7,365
    Star Wars Episode Shut Up: There Is No Comparison
    I like both of them.
    Alright, alright, alright!
    Tom O.
    "I never had any friends later on like the ones I had when I was twelve. Jesus, does anyone?"
    -The Writer
  • HobbesHobbes Pacific Northwest Posts: 6,433
    Star Wars Episode Shut Up: There Is No Comparison
    I saw R1 on Monday. My first reaction was that FA is better. Mind you I think R1 is fantastic and the longer I sit with it, the better it gets. I plan on re-watching FA on Thursday. Maybe then I'll be able to vote. Until then...

    I am one with the force, the force is with me.
  • JimmyVJimmyV Boston's MetroWest Posts: 19,344
    Star Wars Episode VII: The Force Awakens
    Rygar said:

    JimmyV said:

    Rygar said:

    I consider FA to be 'not very good'...is it worth seeing Rogue One?

    Do you consider other Star Wars movies to be good? If so then yes this is worth seeing. If not it might be a skip.
    Big fan of the original trilogy.
    Then definitely see it. This is set right before Episode IV and is heavy with original trilogy references.
    ___________________________________________

    "...I changed by not changing at all..."
  • mcgruff10mcgruff10 New Jersey Posts: 28,757
    Rogue One: A Star Wars Story
    Rouge one was freaking awesome!!!!
    I'll ride the wave where it takes me......
  • Spiritual_ChaosSpiritual_Chaos Posts: 30,947
    Hard one. Hmm.

    No one was "freaking awesome" though.
    "Mostly I think that people react sensitively because they know you’ve got a point"
  • mcgruff10mcgruff10 New Jersey Posts: 28,757
    Rogue One: A Star Wars Story
    Spiritual_Chaos said:

    Hard one. Hmm.

    No one was "freaking awesome" though.

    Rogue one was better than Jedi
    I'll ride the wave where it takes me......
  • BIGDaddyWilBIGDaddyWil Michigan Posts: 3,070
    Rogue One: A Star Wars Story
    Just saw Rogue One......loved it!
    Pine Knob Music Theatre - Jul 31, 1992 Crisler Arena - Mar 20, 1994
    Summerfest - Jul 09, 1995*Savage Hall - Sep 22, 1996The Palace of Auburn Hills-Aug 23, 1998 Breslin Center- Aug 18, 1998,The Palace of Auburn Hills-Oct 07, 2000 DTE Energy Theatre-Jun5,2003,DTE Energy Music Theatre - Jun 26, 2003Sports Arena - Oct 02, 2004 Van Andel Arena - May 19, 2006Palace of Auburn Hills-May 22, 2006 Quicken Loans Arena-May 09, 2010
    10-16-2014 Detroit
  • mickeyratmickeyrat Posts: 42,229
    rogue was very well done and I think served the overall story nicely in filling in some details.
    _____________________________________SIGNATURE________________________________________________

    Not today Sir, Probably not tomorrow.............................................. bayfront arena st. pete '94
    you're finally here and I'm a mess................................................... nationwide arena columbus '10
    memories like fingerprints are slowly raising.................................... first niagara center buffalo '13
    another man ..... moved by sleight of hand...................................... joe louis arena detroit '14
  • InHiding80InHiding80 Upland,CA Posts: 7,623
    Star Wars Episode VII: The Force Awakens
    FUCK YOU 2016! FUCK YOU TO HELL!

    http://people.com/movies/carrie-fisher-dies/
  • PJ_SoulPJ_Soul Vancouver, BC Posts: 50,154
    edited December 2016
    I felt equally neutral about both of them. I feel like the Star Wars story was pretty thin to begin with, and it's just getting thinner as it goes along. Rouge One was barely about anything IMO, but it was no worse than the Force Awakens because that is when they killed the only character in the franchise who actually made it worth watching.

    My apologies to fans for my rant, lol. Just being honest. ;)
    With all its sham, drudgery, and broken dreams, it is still a beautiful world. Be careful. Strive to be happy. ~ Desiderata
  • rgambsrgambs Posts: 13,576
    Star Wars Episode VII: The Force Awakens
    PJ_Soul said:

    I felt equally neutral about both of them. I feel like the Star Wars story was pretty thin to begin with, and it's just getting thinner as it goes along. Rouge One was barely about anything IMO, but it was no worse than the Force Awakens because that is when they killed the only character in the franchise who actually made it worth watching.

    My apologies to fans for my rant, lol. Just being honest. ;)

    Haha I totally agree, it was a very weak story to base a 2+hr movie on. They did really well with what little they had though, I guess.

    Han was the best character, but Rey is badass and will fill his shoes.
    Monkey Driven, Call this Living?
  • PJ_SoulPJ_Soul Vancouver, BC Posts: 50,154
    rgambs said:

    PJ_Soul said:

    I felt equally neutral about both of them. I feel like the Star Wars story was pretty thin to begin with, and it's just getting thinner as it goes along. Rouge One was barely about anything IMO, but it was no worse than the Force Awakens because that is when they killed the only character in the franchise who actually made it worth watching.

    My apologies to fans for my rant, lol. Just being honest. ;)

    Haha I totally agree, it was a very weak story to base a 2+hr movie on. They did really well with what little they had though, I guess.

    Han was the best character, but Rey is badass and will fill his shoes.
    Lol, that is true they did a lot with almost nothing I guess. I do admit that Rogue One killed with the whole retro/original look and feel of the original movies. The Force Awakens did pretty well with that too, but this newest one really kicked some ass as far as that goes. All the machines, movie sets, and especially the costumes, were so true to the "real" Star Wars without looking hokey, so I did enjoy that part at least.
    With all its sham, drudgery, and broken dreams, it is still a beautiful world. Be careful. Strive to be happy. ~ Desiderata
  • RygarRygar Posts: 8,690
    JimmyV said:

    Rygar said:

    JimmyV said:

    Rygar said:

    I consider FA to be 'not very good'...is it worth seeing Rogue One?

    Do you consider other Star Wars movies to be good? If so then yes this is worth seeing. If not it might be a skip.
    Big fan of the original trilogy.
    Then definitely see it. This is set right before Episode IV and is heavy with original trilogy references.
    I was aware of the general story of Rogue One. Thanks for the advice all the same, I saw it and enjoyed it quite a bit more than FA.

    My main gripe...where were all the Bothans that died to bring us these plans? I didn't see any in the entire movie.
  • mcgruff10mcgruff10 New Jersey Posts: 28,757
    Rogue One: A Star Wars Story
    Rygar said:

    JimmyV said:

    Rygar said:

    JimmyV said:

    Rygar said:

    I consider FA to be 'not very good'...is it worth seeing Rogue One?

    Do you consider other Star Wars movies to be good? If so then yes this is worth seeing. If not it might be a skip.
    Big fan of the original trilogy.
    Then definitely see it. This is set right before Episode IV and is heavy with original trilogy references.
    I was aware of the general story of Rogue One. Thanks for the advice all the same, I saw it and enjoyed it quite a bit more than FA.

    My main gripe...where were all the Bothans that died to bring us these plans? I didn't see any in the entire movie.
    bothans captured the plans for the second death star (return of the jedi).
    I'll ride the wave where it takes me......
Sign In or Register to comment.