Pre-election polls: keep them or ban them?
brianlux
Moving through All Kinds of Terrain. Posts: 42,334
I'm all for taking surveys on line and even matching them against other results. Some are amusing, some mindless, some even a little revealing. But what about election polls? What usefulness do they have and does that usefulness out-weigh the negative?
My own feeling is that pre-election polls are probably easy as pie to manipulate (duh) and because they are statistics they can be made to lie. Besides that, doesn't it seem likely that they all too often serve as either a way to sway votes or make it super easy for people to cast lazy votes? (Hey man, everybody in my stinking town is voting for Smith. Screw that guy, I'm voting for Bartz.). It's bad enough that there is no basic requirement or even simple social pressure to understand anything at all about government or candidates in order to be able to vote. It's like that bit they did on college campuses asking students questions like WHO DEFEATED WHOM IN THE CIVIL WAR, FROM WHICH COUNTRY DID THE UNITE STATES GAIN ITS INDEPENDENCE, WHO IS THE CURRENT VICE PRESIDENT? The most frequent answer was, "Ahhhh, dunno?" Bit when asked to who (or not) Angelina Jolie is married, BOOM, fast answer!
Exit polling needs to go, period.
Several countries (38 to be exact) have banned pre-election polls including Bhutan, Brazil, Canada, Greece, Mexico, Norway, Poland and Venezuela and day before and voting day in France. I would be all for it.
Along with that would I would support added pressure to increase political/ current events related education (use Socratic dialog, don't make it dull!) and, of course, critical thinking.
My own feeling is that pre-election polls are probably easy as pie to manipulate (duh) and because they are statistics they can be made to lie. Besides that, doesn't it seem likely that they all too often serve as either a way to sway votes or make it super easy for people to cast lazy votes? (Hey man, everybody in my stinking town is voting for Smith. Screw that guy, I'm voting for Bartz.). It's bad enough that there is no basic requirement or even simple social pressure to understand anything at all about government or candidates in order to be able to vote. It's like that bit they did on college campuses asking students questions like WHO DEFEATED WHOM IN THE CIVIL WAR, FROM WHICH COUNTRY DID THE UNITE STATES GAIN ITS INDEPENDENCE, WHO IS THE CURRENT VICE PRESIDENT? The most frequent answer was, "Ahhhh, dunno?" Bit when asked to who (or not) Angelina Jolie is married, BOOM, fast answer!
Exit polling needs to go, period.
Several countries (38 to be exact) have banned pre-election polls including Bhutan, Brazil, Canada, Greece, Mexico, Norway, Poland and Venezuela and day before and voting day in France. I would be all for it.
Along with that would I would support added pressure to increase political/ current events related education (use Socratic dialog, don't make it dull!) and, of course, critical thinking.
"Pretty cookies, heart squares all around, yeah!"
-Eddie Vedder, "Smile"
-Eddie Vedder, "Smile"
"Try to not spook the horse."
-Neil Young
0
Comments
-Eddie Vedder, "Smile"
And...exit polling as bad/inconsequential/influential as pre-election one? That confused me a bit.
I don't know. If some polls are considered OK, then why not others. I mean really, ban them? I'd rather put it on people to be responsible enough to figure out whether or not those polls should be given credence.
I was called for presidential and cut them off second question, when asked if I was voting dem or gop. Not one word of the other 2. Shit at a minimum johnson should be included as that ticket is on all 50 states ballots. And because of polling numbers the debate commision will disallow them to participate. We're seeing just how truly skewed things are.
For a start the league of women's voters should take back stewardship oof the pres debates. Each poll released should contain the methodology and questions asked.AND reported on with that info.. then WE can place whatever weight on a particular poll we wish.
Not today Sir, Probably not tomorrow.............................................. bayfront arena st. pete '94
you're finally here and I'm a mess................................................... nationwide arena columbus '10
memories like fingerprints are slowly raising.................................... first niagara center buffalo '13
another man ..... moved by sleight of hand...................................... joe louis arena detroit '14
Regarding "ban"-- good point. "Ban" is to hard-assed a word. It's too much like censorship. Politics is a complicated came, however, and since most of us do not object to game rules, what if we just said, "In major elections, polls are against the rules"?
-Eddie Vedder, "Smile"