Who You Are... The lost song

gettingright

would love to hear this in OKC!!!

HesCalledDyer

JonnyPistachio wrote:

JB183385 wrote:

Jack Irons.

Exactly.

I recall I didnt get into this song until much later...I had my headphones on and I was running along the ocean and it hit me like a ton of bricks.

Jack was the man! I mean, we're blessed to have Matt Cameron for the past 15 years, but I often wonder how PJ would have evolved if Jack were still around. (Or even moreso, had he been around since the beginning.)

JonnyPistachio

HesCalledDyer wrote:

JonnyPistachio wrote:

JB183385 wrote:

Jack Irons.

Exactly.

I recall I didnt get into this song until much later...I had my headphones on and I was running along the ocean and it hit me like a ton of bricks.

Jack was the man! I mean, we're blessed to have Matt Cameron for the past 15 years, but I often wonder how PJ would have evolved if Jack were still around. (Or even moreso, had he been around since the beginning.)

I think the same things buddy... And I was surprised to hear Pendulum for the first time and think to myself, "hmm I think maybe Matt was listening to some No Code recently."

DriftingByTheStorm

smanchac1 wrote:

Listening to both versions next to one another.

Only difference I'm hearing is, there is a slight fade in on RVM, but vocals sound the same...

Care to point out differences?

Thanks

uh.okay. as bill cosby said, "CHALLENGE!"

best copy of rearviewmirror i could find(sure pearl jam is thrilled, lol)

actual song from no code

The line that stuck out at me immediately, which i remembered from my first listen, and you can almost hear it is "punched in" or otherwise an over emphasized vocal take is ...

original version, just after the line
"take me for a ride, before we leave" is:
"circumstance, clapping hands"

Very clearly, the original, he says "circumstance".

Now go listen to the RVM version.
I don't know what the fuck he is saying, sounds like "avalanche" mixed with "ambulance"
"avalanche, falling fast" ? i don't really know. it ain't the original vocal take for that line though.
right? or am i cracking up here?

And, having just finished the comparison myself now, apparently (to my ears anyway) that is the *only* change. ?tried slowly going through playing a piece of each together. That was all i came up with. The one edit. Why would Eddie feel the need to change that?
?

smanchac1

DriftingByTheStorm wrote:

smanchac1 wrote:

Listening to both versions next to one another.

Only difference I'm hearing is, there is a slight fade in on RVM, but vocals sound the same...

Care to point out differences?

Thanks

uh.okay. as bill cosby said, "CHALLENGE!"

best copy of rearviewmirror i could find(sure pearl jam is thrilled, lol)

actual song from no code

The line that stuck out at me immediately, which i remembered from my first listen, and you can almost hear it is "punched in" or otherwise an over emphasized vocal take is ...

original version, just after the line
"take me for a ride, before we leave" is:
"circumstance, clapping hands"

Very clearly, the original, he says "circumstance".

Now go listen to the RVM version.
I don't know what the fuck he is saying, sounds like "avalanche" mixed with "ambulance"
"avalanche, falling fast" ? i don't really know. it ain't the original vocal take for that line though.
right? or am i cracking up here?

And, having just finished the comparison myself now, apparently (to my ears anyway) that is the *only* change. ?tried slowly going through playing a piece of each together. That was all i came up with. The one edit. Why would Eddie feel the need to change that?
?

Thanks.

I am usually the first one to notice these things.. Will give it another go.

Do you have an approximate time of these lines?

surforia

DriftingByTheStorm wrote:

smanchac1 wrote:

Listening to both versions next to one another.

Only difference I'm hearing is, there is a slight fade in on RVM, but vocals sound the same...

Care to point out differences?

Thanks

uh.okay. as bill cosby said, "CHALLENGE!"

best copy of rearviewmirror i could find(sure pearl jam is thrilled, lol)

actual song from no code

The line that stuck out at me immediately, which i remembered from my first listen, and you can almost hear it is "punched in" or otherwise an over emphasized vocal take is ...

original version, just after the line
"take me for a ride, before we leave" is:
"circumstance, clapping hands"

Very clearly, the original, he says "circumstance".

Now go listen to the RVM version.
I don't know what the fuck he is saying, sounds like "avalanche" mixed with "ambulance"
"avalanche, falling fast" ? i don't really know. it ain't the original vocal take for that line though.
right? or am i cracking up here?

And, having just finished the comparison myself now, apparently (to my ears anyway) that is the *only* change. ?tried slowly going through playing a piece of each together. That was all i came up with. The one edit. Why would Eddie feel the need to change that?
?

So weird that he changed that... thanks for the analysis. I'm going to listen with headphones and see if I can pick out any other differences...

jimbojones1138

i was absolutely blown away when they blew the dust off of this one back in 2008. i think i shit a brick when they played it in camden. two great shows if you ask me, i think only what, 6 repeats over the two nights. what a great run!

tempo_n_groove

One of the greats. Would love to hear this in Seattle...

Comatose Pilate

Hope they bust it out at one of the LA shows

vaggar99

No Code is a beautiful album. i'd love to see them play every song off that record one show.

october22

DriftingByTheStorm wrote:

october22 wrote:

Damn. I've seen it six times. Didn't even realize. They should absolutely bring it back.

son of a bitch.
got a string of them in 08
or you were somehow able to catch them repeatedly in 96 (wow, if so) ?

Who You Are MSG '08
kind've pissed life forbade me from a PJ show in '08, now.

THIS SONG WOULD MAKE AN EPIC OPENER.

Yeah, man. All 08. Crazy they don't play it more often

SwBkRn44

jerometurner wrote:

Please, please get this song back into the rotation for this 2nd Leg.

Only played 10 times since 96'

Wow, I had no idea it was so rare as I've seen 4 of those 10 performances.

Bring it back!

MG79478

SVRDhand13 wrote:

Sat 3 Sep, 2011 Alpine Valley Music Theatre East Troy, Wisconsin
Tue 1 Jul, 2008 Beacon Theatre, New York, New York
Mon 30 Jun, 2008 Tweeter Center Mansfield, Massachusetts
Wed 25 Jun, 2008 Madison Square Garden New York, New York
Tue 24 Jun, 2008 Madison Square Garden New York, New York
Sun 22 Jun, 2008 Verizon Center Washington, D.C.
Thu 19 Jun, 2008 Susquehanna Bank Center Camden, New Jersey
Sat 14 Jun, 2008 Bonnaroo Manchester, Tennessee
Wed 11 Jun, 2008 Cruzan Amphitheatre West Palm Beach, Florida

Fixed

I was lucky to catch the last two performances of this song.

My first thought was "that song has been played a ton recently". Then I realized I was just at 6 of the above shows.

TheLuckyOnes

lol, only once in the last 5 years (Alpine), tho a bunch in '08, which is cool.

The MSG '08 clip sounds pretty good. This was a song i always wrote off after Jack left. It's a Jack song (and i love Jack's playing, so that's a compliment), and Jack songs else get rearranged significantly (GTF) or fall off and disappear for the most part (Who you are, In my Tree). But i could definitely see them playing this now. From what i can tell, not having seen this tour but judging by clips and everyone's response, they have really been super tight this tour. So i could see them pulling the arrangement together just a bit more and maybe squeezing this one in late 1st set, or leading out of the more acoustic encore.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Bs2JrRD1bqE

cheers

Mad Mohab

Take me for a ride, before we leave...