Home› Other Music

Bands that never hit the crapper

Tim SimmonsTim Simmons Posts: 8,079
edited November 2013 in Other Music
Caveats:

Must have 3+ albums (live albums don't count)
Albums need to be consistently good to great. Not some mediocre debut and then they hit a stride with a sophomore release
Can still be recording or broken up/retired (though if they are still making music, you run the risk of them hitting said crapper)
Take into account critical, commercial, and peer opinions, not just personal
Post edited by Unknown User on
«1

Comments

  • Tim SimmonsTim Simmons Posts: 8,079
    The Smiths
    Nirvana
    LCD Soundsystem
  • EarlWelshEarlWelsh Posts: 1,118
    Tim Simmons wrote:
    The Smiths
    Nirvana
    LCD Soundsystem

    Nice little list there. I can't think of many right now.

    Mogwai
    Yo La Tengo
  • JTHJTH Posts: 3,238
    Tim Simmons wrote:
    Nirvana
    Man, I love everything else they did, but I find almost every song on Bleach to be nearly unlistenable.

    There are others but I'll go with Arcade Fire (although who knows? I've only heard the one new song so far so I might think differently tomorrow.)
  • bluesuedeitzradbluesuedeitzrad Posts: 430
    This is tough, because so many bands had that one bad album. REM is amazing, but Around the Sun was a tough listen. Even greats like the Ramones, The Who and Neil Young had their low points.

    The first one that comes to mind:
    The Jimi Hendrix Experience
    Three studio albums that were amazing.

    Others that fit:
    Cream
    Beck (not a band but all of his albums are great)
    Foo Fighters
    The Beatles (too obvious?)
  • DewieCoxDewieCox Posts: 11,429
    edited October 2013
    Zeppelin
    Floyd
    Beatles
    Black Crowes
    Hendrix
    White Stripes
    TOOL
    Wilco
    Post edited by DewieCox on
  • bluesuedeitzradbluesuedeitzrad Posts: 430
    I think the easy way out is to think of bands that were only together for 5-10 years.
  • SJHalpSJHalp Posts: 37
    edited October 2013
    Wilco
    Alice in Chains
    Post edited by SJHalp on
  • JTHJTH Posts: 3,238
    bluesuedeitzrad wrote:
    I think the easy way out is to think of bands that were only together for 5-10 years.
    OK, I'll change my answer then.

    Clutch.
  • SJHalpSJHalp Posts: 37
    Candlebox
    Collective Soul
    Stone Temple Pilots
    Silverchair
    Bush
    Days of the New
    Sponge
    Seven Mary Three
  • foodboyfoodboy Posts: 988
    u2,pink floyd,the band, crosby stills nash, cold play, supertramp, whit stripes, the who, the stones, bob marley,
  • SVRDhand13SVRDhand13 Posts: 26,169
    In honor of tomorrow's release-

    Arcade Fire
    severed hand thirteen
    2006: Gorge 7/23 2008: Hartford 6/27 Beacon 7/1 2009: Spectrum 10/30-31
    2010: Newark 5/18 MSG 5/20-21 2011: PJ20 9/3-4 2012: Made In America 9/2
    2013: Brooklyn 10/18-19 Philly 10/21-22 Hartford 10/25 2014: ACL10/12
    2015: NYC 9/23 2016: Tampa 4/11 Philly 4/28-29 MSG 5/1-2 Fenway 8/5+8/7
    2017: RRHoF 4/7   2018: Fenway 9/2+9/4   2021: Sea Hear Now 9/18 
    2022: MSG 9/11  2024: MSG 9/3-4 Philly 9/7+9/9 Fenway 9/15+9/17
  • JTHJTH Posts: 3,238
    JTH wrote:
    bluesuedeitzrad wrote:
    I think the easy way out is to think of bands that were only together for 5-10 years.
    OK, I'll change my answer then.

    Clutch.
    Wait. No. Arcade Fire's been a band since 2001 (holy shit am I old) so I'm sticking with them.
  • EquallyWorthlessEquallyWorthless Posts: 3,993
    The Beatles
    Nick Cave & The Bad Seeds
    Radiohead
    {if (work != 0) {
    work = work + 1;
    sleep = sleep - work * 10;}
    else if (work >= 0) {
    reality.equals(false);
    work = work +1;
    }system("pause");
    return 0;}
  • EraserheadEraserhead Posts: 2,937
    Swans
    Isis
    Godspeed You Black Emperor
    Manchester 04.06.00, Leeds 25.08.06, Wembley 18.06.07, Dusseldorf 21.06.07, Shepherds Bush 11.08.09, Manchester 17.08.09, Adelaide 17.11.09, Melbourne 20.11.09, Sydney 22.11.09, Brisbane 25.11.09, MSG1 20.05.10, MSG2 21.05.10, Dublin 22.06.10, Belfast 23.06.10, London 25.06.10, Long Beach 06.07.11 (EV), Los Angeles 08.07.11 (EV), Toronto 11.09.11, Toronto 12.09.11, Ottawa 14.09.11, Hamilton 14.09.11, Manchester 20.06.12, Manchester 21.06.12, Amsterdam 26.06.2012, Amsterdam 27.06.2012, Berlin 04.07.12, Berlin 05.07.12, Stockholm 07.07.12, Oslo 09.07.12, Copenhagen 10.07.12, Manchester 28.07.12 (EV), Brooklyn 18.10.13, Brooklyn 19.10.13, Philly 21.10.13, Philly 22.10.13, San Diego 21.11.13, LA 23.11.13, LA 24.11.13, Oakland 26.11.13, Portland 29.11.13, Spokane 30.11.13, Calgary 02.12.13, Vancouver 04.12.13, Seattle 06.12.13, Trieste 22.06.14, Vienna 25.06.14, Berlin 26.06.14, Stockholm 28.06.14, Leeds 08.07.14, Philly 28.04.16, Philly 28.04.16, MSG1 01.05.16, MSG2 02.05.16
  • Tim SimmonsTim Simmons Posts: 8,079
    SJHalp wrote:
    Candlebox
    Collective Soul
    Stone Temple Pilots
    Silverchair
    Bush
    Days of the New
    Sponge
    Seven Mary Three

    I feel like most of these bands are the definition of diminishing returns/crapper. I don't know what most of them are doing or have done in the past 15 years.
  • JTHJTH Posts: 3,238
    Tim Simmons wrote:
    SJHalp wrote:
    Candlebox
    Collective Soul
    Stone Temple Pilots
    Silverchair
    Bush
    Days of the New
    Sponge
    Seven Mary Three

    I feel like most of these bands are the definition of diminishing returns/crapper. I don't know what most of them are doing or have done in the past 15 years.
    I've never been a fan but a friend of mine saw Candlebox not too long ago and he said they were great.

    Of course, as a child, he lived under power lines and ate paint chips with great regularity.
  • Tim SimmonsTim Simmons Posts: 8,079
    It's just funny to me that a band like Candlebox has supposedly never hit the crapper, but bands like REM, or the Rolling Stones have.
  • SatansFutonSatansFuton Posts: 5,399
    Tim Simmons wrote:
    It's just funny to me that a band like Candlebox has supposedly never hit the crapper, but bands like REM, or the Rolling Stones have.

    Well, when you're around for 50 years they can't all be winners...

    1994_-_Dirty_Work.jpg

    I didn't keep up with Candlebox after the 90's so I can't really judge. I don't like much R.E.M. after New Adventures In Hi Fi (which might be my favorite album of theirs), after that they never seemed the same to me. Not shitty, just not interesting to me.

    Has anybody mentioned Zeppelin? I know In Through The Out Door was very different and not well liked by all, but I still like it and consider all their studio albums great in their own way.
    "See a broad to get dat booty yak 'em, leg 'er down, a smack 'em yak 'em!"
  • ekwiptekwipt Posts: 562
    JTH wrote:
    Tim Simmons wrote:
    Nirvana
    Man, I love everything else they did, but I find almost every song on Bleach to be nearly unlistenable.

    :o
    "School" is by far my favourite Nirvana song. The lyrics are genius albeit brief.
  • South of SeattleSouth of Seattle Posts: 10,724
    Raconteurs
    White Stripes
    Led Zep
    Tool
    The Clash
    Jimi Hendrix Experience
    Nirvana
    NWA
    The Fugees
    QOTSA
    RATM
    NERDS!
  • JTHJTH Posts: 3,238
    ekwipt wrote:

    :o
    "School" is by far my favourite Nirvana song. The lyrics are genius albeit brief.
    That one is listenable.
  • JTHJTH Posts: 3,238
    Tim Simmons wrote:
    It's just funny to me that a band like Candlebox has supposedly never hit the crapper...
    They never hit the crapper because the crapper hit them first.
  • DewieCoxDewieCox Posts: 11,429
    SatansFuton wrote:
    Has anybody mentioned Zeppelin? I know In Through The Out Door was very different and not well liked by all, but I still like it and consider all their studio albums great in their own way.

    I did. With stuff like Carouselambra and In the Evening as the epics, Hot Dog and Fool In the Rain as kinda quirky numbers that Zep had on the later albums.....All My Love is a little cheesy, it's really well crafted. I think it's good and really great for a low point.

    The Stones hit the crapper, trying to keep up with trends, but they had some good songs on everything and they've bounced back pretty well.

    Some of the bands, while solid, I don't think they were ever good enough to hit the crapper. You gotta take a pretty hard fall from grace, to me. Stuff like Candlebox and Live lived their life on the toilet rim.
  • Hugh Freaking DillonHugh Freaking Dillon Posts: 14,010
    SJHalp wrote:
    Candlebox
    Collective Soul
    Stone Temple Pilots
    Silverchair
    Bush
    Days of the New
    Sponge
    Seven Mary Three

    I think this list was meant for the other thread.
    Gimli 1993
    Fargo 2003
    Winnipeg 2005
    Winnipeg 2011
    St. Paul 2014
  • EarlWelshEarlWelsh Posts: 1,118
    Hugh Freaking Dillon wrote:
    SJHalp wrote:
    Candlebox
    Collective Soul
    Stone Temple Pilots
    Silverchair
    Bush
    Days of the New
    Sponge
    Seven Mary Three

    I think this list was meant for the other thread.

    :lol:
  • Hugh Freaking DillonHugh Freaking Dillon Posts: 14,010
    The Headstones
    Queens of the Stone Age
    Black Mountain
    Soundgarden
    White Stripes
    Nirvana
    Gimli 1993
    Fargo 2003
    Winnipeg 2005
    Winnipeg 2011
    St. Paul 2014
  • YefaYefa Posts: 1,133
    Drive-By Truckers
    Lynyrd Skynyrd (pre-plane crash)
    Immolation
    Sonic Youth
    Richard Thompson
    Husker Du
    You see me empty, Sir, do not pause and inquire, simply assume and refill.
    - Al Swearengen

    http://www.cantstoptheserenity.com
  • smarcheesmarchee Posts: 14,539
    Wilco
    1998 ~ Barrie
    2003 ~ Toronto
    2005 ~ London, Toronto
    2006 ~ Toronto
    2008 ~ Hartford, Mansfied I,
    2009 ~ Toronto, Chicago I, Chicago II
    2010 ~ Cleveland, Buffalo
    2011 ~ Toronto I, Toronto II, Ottawa, Hamilton
    2013 - London, Pittsburgh, Buffalo
    2014 - Detroit
    2019 - Chicago X 2
  • nickburrows14nickburrows14 Posts: 858
    Some bands sure dipped towards the end or lately but not hit the crapper. Can't think of many though.

    PJ
    SOUNDGARDEN
    REM
    NIRVANA
    SPRINGSTEEN
    U2 (been a bit up and down and I really don't like No Line On The Horizon)
    REPLACEMENTS

    As for Neil Young........discuss
    Happy up here in my tree
  • SpartanacusSpartanacus Posts: 830
    AC/DC: It all sounds the same, but it's all good!
    Alice In Chains: LOVE the new stuff too.
    Beastie Boys: They will be missed. Hope they can piece together a 'Hot Sauce Committee Part One.'
    Nirvana: Bleach was no Nevermind or In Utero, but you can't dismiss the raw energy.
    Queens of The Stone Age: My most treasured 'discovery' in this post grunge age.
    19 Pearl Jam shows and still searching for Deep!
    1998 (2) - East Lansing & Auburn Hills; 2000 (2) - Tampa & Noblesville; 2003 (2) - Lexington & Noblesville; 2006 (1) - Cincinnati; 2007 (1) - Chicago (Lollapalooza); 2008 (Ed in Milwaukee); 2009 (1) - Chicago; 2010 (1) - Noblesville; 2013 (3) - San Diego & Los Angeles I & II; 2016 (Temple of the Dog in Los Angeles); 2017 (Ed at Ohana in Dana Point);
    2021 (3) - Dana Point I, II & III; 2022 (3) - San Diego & Los Angeles I & II; 2025 - Southern U.S. Tour Please!
Sign In or Register to comment.