Your White Whale Song?

1343537394044

Comments

  • KswheelerKswheeler Philadelphia Posts: 75
    I’d love to see falling down 
  • Closing in on 30 shows, and Once has escaped me everytime.
  • Saltzy23Saltzy23 Posts: 1,350
    I saw 7 shows last year and heard Crazy Mary once.  Heartbreaking.

    That song needs to be played twice every show IMO.
    'I know I was born and I know that I'll die, the in between is mine.'
  • moleculemolecule Posts: 623
    Strangest Tribe. Believe it was on the setlist for Chicago 13 but got cut due the weather delays. Right behind it was Fatal, but caught it at Missoula 18.
    🤙
  • CrewCrew Posts: 299
    I wish they'd open with, "You Are."  In Baltimore, if I'm already dreaming!

    They never have, to my knowledge. 

    Would be SUCH a killer slow starter; kinda like Pendulum.
  • Saltzy23Saltzy23 Posts: 1,350
    edited January 2020
    Crew said:
    I wish they'd open with, "You Are."  In Baltimore, if I'm already dreaming!

    They never have, to my knowledge. 

    Would be SUCH a killer slow starter; kinda like Pendulum.
    They have played You Are a total of 6 times since Nov 2015.

    I wouldn't hold my breath.


    'I know I was born and I know that I'll die, the in between is mine.'
  • HughFreakingDillonHughFreakingDillon Winnipeg Posts: 37,350
    rummy said:
    JT167846 said:
    Reckon white whales are generally more album tracks as others are b-sides and rarities (obviously a few exceptions here with State, Ledbetter etc).

    A few for me: Oceans, Deep, Glorified, Leash, Whipping, NAIS of the first six. I've only seen then nine times but am getting to the point of averaging three songs I haven't heard a night. Pity I could only make Fenway 2 in 2018 as I think there were some goodies on there, and the make up London gig would have been awesome were I still living in Europe.

    The grass is always greener though. Reading some of these posts reminds me that even out of those nine I've seen some songs people would kill to see (hell both Merkinball tracks twice, Love Reign, HTI) so I'll try not to be a greedy bastard and appreciate what I have seen, and hope for instead of demand my white whales. I could bloody send Ed a full set of them.
    I like this post. I've only been to eight shows and have witnessed "Let Me Sleep" twice - the same number of times as I've seen the band  perform "Jeremy!"
    Of the albums tracks, my top 5 are:
    In My Tree (mentioned earlier)
    Hail Hail (admittedly, I've seen it but not since 1998)
    Dissident
    Glorified G
    Deep
    ...Save You, Wash, Tremor Christ, Red Mosquito, and MFC (also saw that in 1998) would be awesome as well.
    Crazy, I’ve seen Let Me Sleep 3 times in 7 shows...
    that's insane. go get a lottery ticket! I've seen them 5 times, and no ledbetter. but every ten track except oceans. 
    "Oh Canada...you're beautiful when you're drunk"
    -EV  8/14/93




  • HughFreakingDillonHughFreakingDillon Winnipeg Posts: 37,350
    Crew said:
    I wish they'd open with, "You Are."  In Baltimore, if I'm already dreaming!

    They never have, to my knowledge. 

    Would be SUCH a killer slow starter; kinda like Pendulum.
    this is a fantastic idea. I love it. ed could even pull that rockstar move of the rest of the band coming on and him coming on just a bit later when the lyrics start. 
    "Oh Canada...you're beautiful when you're drunk"
    -EV  8/14/93




  • 1ThoughtKnown1ThoughtKnown Posts: 6,155
    edited January 2020
    Crew said:
    I wish they'd open with, "You Are."  In Baltimore, if I'm already dreaming!

    They never have, to my knowledge. 

    Would be SUCH a killer slow starter; kinda like Pendulum.
    this is a fantastic idea. I love it. ed could even pull that rockstar move of the rest of the band coming on and him coming on just a bit later when the lyrics start. 
    That immediately made me think of Layne walking out on Unplugged and sitting down to hit the first line of Nutshell. That blows me away every time I see it. It sounded like the studio version. Man that guy was amazing.. such talent. 

    Would be fun to see Ed do something like that 
  • HughFreakingDillonHughFreakingDillon Winnipeg Posts: 37,350
    Crew said:
    I wish they'd open with, "You Are."  In Baltimore, if I'm already dreaming!

    They never have, to my knowledge. 

    Would be SUCH a killer slow starter; kinda like Pendulum.
    this is a fantastic idea. I love it. ed could even pull that rockstar move of the rest of the band coming on and him coming on just a bit later when the lyrics start. 
    That immediately made me think of Layne walking out on Unplugged and sitting down to hit the first line of Nutshell. That blows me away every time I see it. It sounded like the studio version. Man that guy was amazing.. such talent. 

    Would be fun to see Ed do something like that 
    that show sounded so mind-blowingly amazing, I often wonder if there was any post-production studio trickery done for the release. it just sounds SO good. 
    "Oh Canada...you're beautiful when you're drunk"
    -EV  8/14/93




  • DiscopijDiscopij Posts: 479
    Still my favorite thread ... first time, i posted Immortality and heard it that year ... then i posted about Tremor Christ, Leash and Breakerfall in 2018 and i got all 3 of them!  Running out of dragons to chase but at this point it's Green Disease and Sleight of Hand
  • chiwhitesoxchiwhitesox Chicago Posts: 696
    All or None
    - Chicago G

    chicago98-chicago00-chicago03-east troy03-chicago06-chicago09-east troy11_2-chicago13-moline14-milwaukee14-lexington16-chicago16_1-chicago16_2-chicago18_1-chicago18_2
  • RR258111RR258111 São Paulo, Brazil Posts: 60
    edited January 2020
    Oceans, Red Mosquito and in Hiding .

    Post edited by RR258111 on

    PJ - Irvine,CA (06,03,03) SP, Brazil (12,02,05), SP, Brazil (12,03,05) ,SP, Brazil (11,03,11),  SP, Brazil (11,04,11), SP, Brazil (03,31,13), SP, Brazil (11,14,15), Ft Lauderdale, FL (04,08,16), Miami, FL (04,09,16), SP,Brazil(03,24,18)Chicago, IL(08,18,18), Chicago, IL(08,20,18), San Diego, CA (05,03,22), Los Angeles, CA (05/06/22), Los Angeles, CA (05/07/22) , Oakland, CA(05/12/22), Los Angeles,CA (05/21/24), Los Angeles,CA(05/22/24) - EV - SP, Brazil 2015/2018, 


  • BizzzyBozzzyBizzzyBozzzy San Diego Posts: 388
    Whale Song
  • no codeno code Posts: 109
    Around The Bend
    No matter how cold the winter, there's a springtime ahead...
  • CrewCrew Posts: 299
    Crew said:
    I wish they'd open with, "You Are."  In Baltimore, if I'm already dreaming!

    They never have, to my knowledge. 

    Would be SUCH a killer slow starter; kinda like Pendulum.
    this is a fantastic idea. I love it. ed could even pull that rockstar move of the rest of the band coming on and him coming on just a bit later when the lyrics start. 
    YES!  Now you're getting my hopes up.. but that would be amazing.

    Could you imagine, lights going down, people still getting situated, and you hear that guitar start?  Place would go nuts, I bet.
  • Crew said:
    Crew said:
    I wish they'd open with, "You Are."  In Baltimore, if I'm already dreaming!

    They never have, to my knowledge. 

    Would be SUCH a killer slow starter; kinda like Pendulum.
    this is a fantastic idea. I love it. ed could even pull that rockstar move of the rest of the band coming on and him coming on just a bit later when the lyrics start. 
    YES!  Now you're getting my hopes up.. but that would be amazing.

    Could you imagine, lights going down, people still getting situated, and you hear that guitar start?  Place would go nuts, I bet.
    My favourite opener is Of the Girl,  but this would be phenomenal. I’ve played it out in my head a dozen times at work today. I saw You Are live in Krakow... it’s awesome live. 
    Maybe we need to start a “You Are - Killer Opener?” Thread lol
  • jdizzle8291jdizzle8291 Erie, PA Posts: 456
    Crew said:
    Crew said:
    I wish they'd open with, "You Are."  In Baltimore, if I'm already dreaming!

    They never have, to my knowledge. 

    Would be SUCH a killer slow starter; kinda like Pendulum.
    this is a fantastic idea. I love it. ed could even pull that rockstar move of the rest of the band coming on and him coming on just a bit later when the lyrics start. 
    YES!  Now you're getting my hopes up.. but that would be amazing.

    Could you imagine, lights going down, people still getting situated, and you hear that guitar start?  Place would go nuts, I bet.
    My favourite opener is Of the Girl,  but this would be phenomenal. I’ve played it out in my head a dozen times at work today. I saw You Are live in Krakow... it’s awesome live. 
    Maybe we need to start a “You Are - Killer Opener?” Thread lol
    I don't care if they play it first, last, or in the middle, I just hope to hear this song one of these days. It's one of my favorites, super unique.

    2016: Toronto I, Chicago I + II
    2018: Seattle I + II, Chicago I + II
    2020: Toronto, Ottawa, Quebec, Hamilton, Nashville, St. Louis, Krakow, Budapest, Zurich
  • Tiz10Tiz10 South Florida Posts: 270
    13 shows and I still haven't heard them play these songs live:
    1.) Garden
    2.) Rats
    3.) Satan's Bed
    4.) In My Tree
    5.) I Got Shit

    Would love to hear any one of those, Trying for the NY/MSG show this year thinking it would be a good chance to catch one or two of these.
    August 17th 1998 Indianapolis, IN
    August 18th 2000 Indianapolis, IN
    June 22nd 2003 Indianapolis, IN
    June 11th 2008 West Palm Beach, FL
    June 12th 2008 Tampa, FL
    October 15th 2013 Worcester, MA
    October 16th 2013 Worcester, MA
    October 3rd 2014 St.Louis, MO
    April 8th 2016 Ft. Lauderdale, FL
    April 9th 2016 Miami, FL
    April 11th 2016 Tampa, FL
    August 5th 2016 Boston, MA (Fenway 1)
    August 7th 2016 Boston, MA (Fenway 2)
    April 7th 2017 Hall of Fame Induction Ceremony
  • fgdanzifgdanzi Posts: 139
    Prior to Seattle/Chicago 2018 it was Long Road and Wash ✔️✔️... For 2020 I’m going with Love Boat Captain and Other Side. 
  • CarryTheZeroCarryTheZero Posts: 2,979
    I missed full WMA and Inside Job at Columbia, 2008 as I had to turn around in the car for a family emergency (everything good though).

    Got both in 2016 in Greenville and Chicago!

    Now, Dirty Frank after experiencing that 2018 tease at Fenway! 

    Come on guys! Nashville or St. Louis!
  • HughFreakingDillonHughFreakingDillon Winnipeg Posts: 37,350
    after the last time ed teased dirty frank, i can't see them ever busting it out in full ever again. but who knows. this band likes to surprise. 
    "Oh Canada...you're beautiful when you're drunk"
    -EV  8/14/93




  • CrewCrew Posts: 299
    Crew said:
    Crew said:
    I wish they'd open with, "You Are."  In Baltimore, if I'm already dreaming!

    They never have, to my knowledge. 

    Would be SUCH a killer slow starter; kinda like Pendulum.
    this is a fantastic idea. I love it. ed could even pull that rockstar move of the rest of the band coming on and him coming on just a bit later when the lyrics start. 
    YES!  Now you're getting my hopes up.. but that would be amazing.

    Could you imagine, lights going down, people still getting situated, and you hear that guitar start?  Place would go nuts, I bet.
    My favourite opener is Of the Girl,  but this would be phenomenal. I’ve played it out in my head a dozen times at work today. I saw You Are live in Krakow... it’s awesome live. 
    Maybe we need to start a “You Are - Killer Opener?” Thread lol
    Done!  Haha

    https://community.pearljam.com/discussion/283167/open-w-you-are-in-baltimore-a-killer-slow-starter-and-never-been-an-opener/p1?new=1
  • robis726robis726 Posts: 132
    Kswheeler said:
    I’d love to see falling down 


    Yes! Great song. 
    Oh, if I knew where it was I would take you there...

    Austin, Texas 09-16-1995
    Columbia, Maryland 09-04-2000
    San Antonio, Texas 04-05-2003
    Santa Barbara, California 07-13-2006
    Universal City, California 10-01-2009
    Austin, Texas 10-04-2009
    Dallas, Texas 11-15-2013
    Mexico City, Mexico 11-28-2015
    Ft. Lauderdale, Florida 04-08-2016
    Miami, Florida 04-09-2016
    Chicago, Illinois I 08-20-2016
    Chicago, Illinois II 08-22-2016
    Seattle, Washington I 08-08-2018
    Seattle, Washington II 08-10-2018
    Boston, Massachusets I 09-02-2018
    Austin, Texas 09-18-2023
  • rjwhite19rjwhite19 Posts: 574
    edited January 2020
    Force of Nature



    Montreal 2003. Halifax 2005. EV Montreal 2008. Toronto 2009
    Toronto 2011 1 & 2 London 2013. Quebec City 2016. Ottawa 2016
    Fenway 2016 1 & 2
  • I break this into 3 categories. 

    1) the not likely--Strangest Tribe (my all time white whale song)
    2) the I've just missed it multiple times--All Those Yesterdays (often played the show before I see them, which means I'm not getting it)
    3) the song I most want to see another time--Oceans (saw it my second show ever, STL 1998.  50 shows more after that, zero)
    Lolla St. Louis 92, StL 98, Kansas City 98, Knoxville 98, StL 00, Kansas City 00, Oklahoma City 03, StL 03, Cleveland 03, Pittsburgh 03, Kansas City 03, Philly x 2 03, MSG x 2 03, StL 04, GR 06, Cleveland 06, Detroit 06, SF x 3 06, Portland, Gorge x 2 06, MSG x 2 08, Hartford 08, Mansfield x 2 08
  • RiverrunnerRiverrunner Posts: 2,419
    edited January 2020
    Whale Song of course.   Of course, I know it will never happen. 
    Post edited by Riverrunner on
    The greatness of a nation and its moral progress can be judged by the way it treats its animals. Ghandi
  • lolobugglolobugg BLUE RDGE MTNS Posts: 8,195
    Fucking "Dirty Frank" I had the sign at Boston 2 and was so pissed when they teased it. Also need to hear "Parting ways" full band

    livefootsteps.org/user/?usr=446

    1995- New Orleans, LA  : New Orleans, LA

    1996- Charleston, SC

    1998- Atlanta, GA: Birmingham, AL: Greenville, SC: Knoxville, TN

    2000- Atlanta, GA: New Orleans, LA: Memphis, TN: Nashville, TN

    2003- Raleigh, NC: Charlotte, NC: Atlanta, GA

    2004- Asheville, NC (hometown show)

    2006- Cincinnati, OH

    2008- Columbia, SC

    2009- Chicago, IL x 2 / Ed Vedder- Atlanta, GA x 2

    2010- Bristow, VA

    2011- Alpine Valley, WI (PJ20) x 2 / Ed Vedder- Chicago, IL

    2012- Atlanta, GA

    2013- Charlotte, NC

    2014- Cincinnati, OH

    2015- New York, NY

    2016- Greenville, SC: Hampton, VA:: Columbia, SC: Raleigh, NC : Lexington, KY: Philly, PA 2: (Wrigley) Chicago, IL x 2 (holy shit): Temple of the Dog- Philly, PA

    2017- ED VED- Louisville, KY

    2018- Chicago, IL x2, Boston, MA x2

    2020- Nashville, TN 

    2022- Smashville 

    2023- Austin, TX x2

    2024- Baltimore

  • mace1229mace1229 Posts: 9,484
    edited January 2020
    Glorified G and Mankind. I love Glorified G, that and WMA are the only ones left to complete VS.
     I don't get the hate for Mankind, I like that song. Every time I see Stone step up to sing I get excited, and then it turns out to be Dont Gimme No Lip or something.
  • Man of the hour... Played that song for my dad's funeral. Lots of deep personal meaning. I apologise for the dust in the air if anyone is near me if it's played at a show I'm at this tour ;)
Sign In or Register to comment.