Man Trilogy?

hinsey21

blueandwhite wrote:

KH85051 wrote:

I saw them do it in Toronto Oct 2000

They didn't play Nothingman during the 2000 show. In Ontario the trilogy was only played in Barrie 98 and Toronto 2011. Kitchener had all three songs, but does it count as a trilogy if they aren't played back-to-back?

nothingman forsure was not played in kitchener...i was there and it's my buddies fav song and we didn't hear it till chicago 09

hinsey21

also may not be the place...but what is rarer the lukin/not for you combo, or the man trilogy?

blueandwhite

hinsey21 wrote:

blueandwhite wrote:

KH85051 wrote:

I saw them do it in Toronto Oct 2000

They didn't play Nothingman during the 2000 show. In Ontario the trilogy was only played in Barrie 98 and Toronto 2011. Kitchener had all three songs, but does it count as a trilogy if they aren't played back-to-back?

nothingman forsure was not played in kitchener...i was there and it's my buddies fav song and we didn't hear it till chicago 09

Indeed. The sad thing was I was at that show too . I really have no memory for setlists.

Eraserhead

Played all three (although not together) in Manchester, UK in 2000. Ed makes reference to the fact they've already played the other two that night before starting Leatherman.

titchinello

nothing_man_92 wrote:

hinsey21 wrote:

nothing_man_92 wrote:

Have they ever played the mamasan trilogy and the man trilogy in the sane show?

thats a great question

i would bet on no?

Yeah id assume it would be no.... It would be an incredible 2nd encore though!!!

when i used to make my own setlists for fun, i'd quite often have that as a six song encore, and it would be awsome if they ever did it for real

SVRDhand13

Nice work phungi!

Pap

Grandmas Jam said:

bignumpty wrote:

Prague 2006 they played Dead Man, Man of the Hour, Nothingman, Leatherman and then Better Man.
A Quintet no less!

sick!

Even though I won't be there, I'd love to experience the Pentalogy (including PJ's Holy Trinity) through the boot! Here's my recommendation for Seattle 2018:

1) Leatherman

2) Better Man

3) Nothingman

4) Dead Man

5) Man of the Hour

Peasant Tents

Pap said:

Grandmas Jam said:

bignumpty wrote:

Prague 2006 they played Dead Man, Man of the Hour, Nothingman, Leatherman and then Better Man.
A Quintet no less!

sick!

Even though I won't be there, I'd love to experience the Pentalogy (including PJ's Holy Trinity) through the boot! Here's my recommendation for Seattle 2018:

1) Leatherman

2) Better Man

3) Nothingman

4) Dead Man

5) Man of the Hour

In Prague 06 , Ed introduced the first 4 as a song about a man in Czech and then Betterman as a song about a woman in Czech... As far as I remember anyway...!
I was also lucky enough to see the trio at MSG 2 in 2016! Love Leatherman....

Pap

Peasant Tents said: Love Leatherman....

Me too!

pjhawks

phungi said:

not sure why i was motivated to do this (but I do then to gravitate towards Pearl Jam Statistics; see: Philly F*ck Count thread)

(edited as per comments later in thread)

Leatherman/Betterman/Nothingman played as trilogy: 3-songs in a row: 17 times
(SD 98, ONT98, NJ98, SW00, GA00, FL00, NY00, IL00, CA00, WA00, JAP03, NC03, MI03, MA03, PA05, CZ06, ONT11)

Leatherman/Betterman/Nothingman played as 3-songs in a show (not together): 9 times
(AU98, WI98, NV98, NY98, OH00, MA00, OR00, ONT05, NS05)

What follows may be irrelevant, but of interest to fans of Leatherman:

Leatherman played with only Betterman: back-to-back: 10 times
MN98, OR98, MD98, FL98, ENG00, WALES00, GER00, NC00, IN00, PA00

Leatherman played with Betterman: in show not back-to-back: 11 times
(AZ98, WA98(x2), OH98, AL98, VA98, TN00, ONT00, BRA05, AU06(x2))

Leatherman played with Nothingman: back-to-back: 0 times

Leatherman played with Nothingman: in show not back-to-back: 3 times
(NJ05, POL07, WI11)

Leatherman played by itself: 8 times
(WA98(x2), POL00, AT00, AU03, MI06, NJ06, NJ10)

because of this I just bumped your philly f... thread.  it needs to be updated

smarshall76

Any chance we might see a collab with Richard Ashcroft doing Lucky Man, where he is support on this Dark Matter Tour? 

Pap

smarshall76 said:

Any chance we might see a collab with Richard Ashcroft doing Lucky Man, where he is support on this Dark Matter Tour?