***PJ20 Alpine Valley Setlist Thread 9/3/11***

RiotZact

LukinFan wrote:

Ed, Glenn, and now Liam all backing Chris - standing towards the back of the stage

still for reach down??

Byrnzie

This may be a silly question, but will they be releasing this on c.d, or even dvd?

rival.

small town beck wrote:

So watching PJ dvds and drinking beer is in fact NOT the same thing as being there. :(

i am doing the same my friend. but i keep telling myself it is the same experience

TheMurph

Clearly a great Andrew Wood tribute section. Well deserved!!

over bends

Sometimes I get mopey and really jealous at insane shows such as this... but this is just too fucking cool.

stateoflove79

I will laugh my ass off if they play just the hits tomorrow.

ryanevolution

Those harmonies on Reach Down chorus must be insane Eddie Glen Liam and Chris :shock: My god

"I wanna reaach DOWN AND PICK THE CROWD UP!!!!!"


Takin us to the promised land!!!!!!!!!!

small town beck

pjhawk wrote:

small town beck wrote:

So watching PJ dvds and drinking beer is in fact NOT the same thing as being there. :(

This, unfortunately, is TRUTH!

Yep! I thought I could have my own version of PJ 20. I can't complain I have four shows here but MAN!!!!

InHidingInOttawa wrote:

small town beck wrote:

So watching PJ dvds and drinking beer is in fact NOT the same thing as being there. :(

Hey! Montreal on Wednesday?

OF COURSE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! I can't wait!!!! Leaving here around 1 I think!

small town beck

rival. wrote:

small town beck wrote:

So watching PJ dvds and drinking beer is in fact NOT the same thing as being there. :(

i am doing the same my friend. but i keep telling myself it is the same experience

At least there is no line up for the loo.

PJ5a1

These shows need to be a box set collectors item... DVD and CDs... has to happen....

I been to 30+ shows and I always say the MSG-NY shows and Boston were always the best...even better than Gorge(I wasn't there) but this one show TOP anything show they've done...

This is why PJ is great.... there's countless shows that can be debated but THIS is a celebration of them and their peers right now (rightfully so)

Footage from this show NEEDS to rest in the rock n roll Hall of Fame

joely_91

Byrnzie wrote:

This may be a silly question, but will they be releasing this on c.d, or even dvd?

I'd hope that they release a dvd eventually if its being filmed but as for audio they'd be smart to include it in a boxset with the doco dvd... maybe 4-6 cds for the two shows and then the dvd.... just what i think they should do.... not like the whole philly fiasco of waiting a year to get that shit out

Pry To

stateoflove79 wrote:

I will laugh my ass off if they play just the hits tomorrow.

Don't see that happening with a hardcore crowd like this. That said, tonight seemed like a great mix of ultra ultra rare material mixed with some fairly well-known songs. If you think that's a criticism, it's most certainly not. This is definitely one of the all time great setlists ever.

Left Porch

I'm in awe of this setlist. PJ always shows up in the clutch, batting .400 with runners in scoring position. The David Ortiz circa 2004 of rock bands.

LukinFan

25. Hunger Strike

HailHailOZ

Puddles of wee on the ground

JoelInNoCal

small town beck wrote:

So watching PJ dvds and drinking beer is in fact NOT the same thing as being there. :(

And when PJ25 or PJ30 rolls around and we are not at the concert, we will put in our "old trusty" DVD of PJ20 @ Alpine 2011 and try to convince ourselves that watching that concert is the same as being there.

stateoflove79

Passim wrote:

stateoflove79 wrote:

I will laugh my ass off if they play just the hits tomorrow.

Don't see that happening with a hardcore crowd like this. That said, tonight seemed like a great mix of ultra ultra rare material mixed with some fairly well-known songs. If you think that's a criticism, it's most certainly not. This is definitely one of the all time great setlists ever.

Oh i know it won't happen...haha.

Pry To

stateoflove79 wrote:

Passim wrote:

stateoflove79 wrote:

I will laugh my ass off if they play just the hits tomorrow.

Don't see that happening with a hardcore crowd like this. That said, tonight seemed like a great mix of ultra ultra rare material mixed with some fairly well-known songs. If you think that's a criticism, it's most certainly not. This is definitely one of the all time great setlists ever.

Oh i know it won't happen...haha.

hinsey21

guess that rumoured curfew isn't sticking

PJ5a1

AFTER THIS WEEKEND, PJ SHOULD BE CONVINCED THAT THE FESTIVAL NEEDS TO HAPPEN EVERY YEAR...SAME PLACE AND SAME WEEKEND....

The bands along (strokes/queens of stone age) make for a great festival within itself...

Not for nothing look how many bands over the year PJ helped by having them open for them...

:idea: