ESPN Ultimate Home Run Derby

Newch91

Who do you have to win it all?

http://espn.go.com/sportsnation/feature ... merunderby

SPEEDY MCCREADY

Ruth or Mantle.......

Gary Carter

how in the hell can they leave off Ralph Kiner?

dude only lead MLB in homers for 6 consecutive seasons

81

With or without roids

Newch91

The 81 wrote:

With or without roids

Players like A-Rod and Bonds, I'm going before steroids but I don't know when Bonds first did it.

RW81233

that's ridiculous Pujols than man with more HRs before 30 than anyone is a 4 seed? Braun the man who at one point was hot on Pujols heels isn't even in it? AND the younger guys had to do it against players of all races and not with fences that were 296 feet to right field. That said, the best sluggers probably came out of the 50-70s when they had to do it in cookie cutter parks and against all races (that was for you Juggler).

DewieCox

Musial should be on there somewhere.

Jim Thome? Only top 20 all time missing outside of presumed roid user in Palmeiro

Get rid of Bo, Rob Deer, Jose Bautista(he's only had 1 great hr season), Hamilton(100 career homers), one of the Fielders(prolly Cecil),Sosa

Newch91

I don't get how Hank Aaron is a 2 seed when he should be a 1.

eeriepadave

Newch91 wrote:

The 81 wrote:

With or without roids

Players like A-Rod and Bonds, I'm going before steroids but I don't know when Bonds first did it.

that was my first reaction


I Would say ruth vs Gerhig or Williams in the finals.

Newch91

eeriepadave wrote:

Newch91 wrote:

The 81 wrote:

With or without roids

Players like A-Rod and Bonds, I'm going before steroids but I don't know when Bonds first did it.

that was my first reaction


I Would say ruth vs Gerhig or Williams in the finals.

Can't forget Mantle. He had crazy power. He was a foot and a half away from hitting it out of Yankee Stadium batting lefty.