Anyone ever had this reaction regarding PJ?

Fitz
Fitz Posts: 169
edited December 2007 in The Porch
I recently made a CD for a mate thinking he would like PJ and put some real corkers on it to. When I said a while later 'what do you think?' His reaction was: 'The music arangement is fantastic, some of it very much like the Who but I don't like Vedder's voice'

Now I can honestly say thats the first person I have ever heard say that, normally non fans from my experience seem to find it PJ's strongest point. Anyone else had that?
"First of all, there’s the palpable camaraderie and good feeling you get from the entire band as they smile and nod at each other, and huddle together in various formations throughout the show --- They look like they really like each other. They look stoked!"
Post edited by Unknown User on
«1

Comments

  • Hebejebe
    Hebejebe Posts: 108
    Fitz wrote:
    I recently made a CD for a mate thinking he would like PJ and put some real corkers on it to. When I said a while later 'what do you think?' His reaction was: 'The music arangement is fantastic, some of it very much like the Who but I don't like Vedder's voice'

    Now I can honestly say thats the first person I have ever heard say that, normally non fans from my experience seem to find it PJ's strongest point. Anyone else had that?
    I think you'll find that a great number of people find Ed's voice an acquired taste.
  • Kilgore_Trout
    Kilgore_Trout Posts: 7,334
    all my PJ hating friends say the same thing... its got a deep throaty vibrato to it that just bugs some people... to each their own
    "Senza speme vivemo in disio"

    http://seanbriceart.com/
  • gozzo5058
    gozzo5058 Posts: 611
    Hebejebe wrote:
    I think you'll find that a great number of people find Ed's voice an acquired taste.

    ...and the odd whoesque guitar chords once and awhile. All rock n roll is derivitive/an acquired taste to some extent, so the comment isn't so out of place. Hey, to each their own.
    s

    Montreal/98, Toronto/00'03'05'06x2, Brad Toronto/02, Buffalo/03, Kitchener/05, London/05, Hamilton/05, Late Show Taping/06, Cleveland/06, Pittsburgh/06, Bridge School Benefit Concert/06, Hartford/08, Mansfield 1/08, EV Montreal/08x2, EV Toronto/08x2...
  • pjfan31
    pjfan31 Posts: 7,335
    Hebejebe wrote:
    I think you'll find that a great number of people find Ed's voice an acquired taste.

    Just like olives. And i like olives too
    Sydney 11/02/2003
    Sydney 14/02/2003
    Sydney 07/11/2006
    Sydney 18/11/2006
    Sydney 22/11/2009
    EV Sydney 18/03/2011
    EV Sydney 19/03/2011
    EV Sydney 20/03/2011
    Melbourne 24/01/2014
    Sydney 26/01/2014
    EV Sydney 13/02/2014
  • glasshouse
    glasshouse Posts: 1,762
    from my experience the biggest detractors find ed's "singing" very annoying.
    Athens, Greece: 2006/09/30

    "Call me Ishmael. Some years ago- never mind how long precisely- having little or no money in my purse, and nothing particular to interest me on shore, I thought I would sail about a little and see the watery part of the world." Herman Melville : Moby Dick
  • Brisk.
    Brisk. Posts: 11,581
    no i havent
  • soulsinging
    soulsinging Posts: 13,202
    Fitz wrote:
    I recently made a CD for a mate thinking he would like PJ and put some real corkers on it to. When I said a while later 'what do you think?' His reaction was: 'The music arangement is fantastic, some of it very much like the Who but I don't like Vedder's voice'

    Now I can honestly say thats the first person I have ever heard say that, normally non fans from my experience seem to find it PJ's strongest point. Anyone else had that?

    most people i know that don't like pearl jam don't like them becos of ed's voice.
  • Pegasus
    Pegasus Posts: 3,754
    soulsinging wrote:
    most people i know that don't like pearl jam don't like them becos of ed's voice.
    same here.. either they don't know them, or they don't like Ed. his voice is very distinctive, unlike many bands.

    the voice is the most obvious, and so potentially annoying thing in a band, and whislt you can change a guitar, put effects on it, etc... the voice doesn't change that much from one song to the next, it's a constant.
  • Bangers_n_mash
    Bangers_n_mash Posts: 1,241
    soulsinging wrote:
    most people i know that don't like pearl jam don't like them becos of ed's voice.
    Yeah but I think blaming Ed's voice is just these people's lame excuse to not bother listening.
    uʍop ǝpısdn ǝɹ,ǝʍ 'punoɹ ʎɐʍ ɹǝɥʇo ǝɥʇ ןןɐ s,ʇı
  • jwillmo
    jwillmo Posts: 471
    Seriously? His voice has always seemed to me to be the most divisive part of the group. Most every casual fan I know likes PJ because of his voice, and most every hater I know hates them for his voice. I can't believe you've never run into this before.
  • Julien
    Julien Posts: 2,457
    People hating PJ are crazy !
    People hating Ed's voice ar crazy !
    Come on, hwo can one don't like that voice ! i don't get it...
    2006: Antwerp, Paris
    2007: Copenhagen, Werchter
    2009: Rotterdam, London
    2010: MSG, Arras, Werchter
    2012: Amsterdam, Prague, Berlin
    2014: Amsterdam, Stockholm
  • MakingWaves
    MakingWaves Posts: 1,294
    My wife likes the music but says she can't stand Eddies voice. Of course I tell her she is crazy and turn it up louder.
    But I have heard a few people say they don't like his voice.
    Seeing visions of falling up somehow.

    Pensacola '94
    New Orleans '95
    Birmingham '98
    New Orleans '00
    New Orleans '03
    Tampa '08
    New Orleans '10 - Jazzfest
    New Orleans '16 - Jazzfest
    Fenway Park '18
    St. Louis '22
  • Hitch-Hiker
    Hitch-Hiker Posts: 2,873
    That's the most common reaction to Pearl Jam for people who don't like them. Not odd in the slightest.
    I'll Ride The Wave Where It Takes Me
  • rearviewmiror
    rearviewmiror Posts: 894
    That's what I hear from everyone. "I just can't stand his voice"

    I felt the same, it was the only reason i didn't get on board till the summer before vs. came out. I love it now, but I get what people are saying.
    9/7/98, 8/3/00, 9/4/00, 4/15/03, 7/1/03, 9/28/04, 9/29/04, 5/24/06, 5/25/06, 6/17/08, 6/22/08, 6/28/08, 6/30/08, 5/17/10, 10/15/13, 10/16/13.
  • Strangest Tribe
    Strangest Tribe Posts: 2,502
    People used to and still say the same about Robert Plant.

    So it really doesn't mean anything... And it shouldn't matter to the real fans.
    the Minions
  • brainofme
    brainofme Posts: 231
    of course i can't understand why people don't like ed's voice, but i totally understand why the voice is the aspect that makes them not like pj. whether i like or not like a band has a lot to do with the singers voice, and i guess that's the case with most people. if you find the voice annoying you probably don't like the band.
    Vienna, Austria 2006
    Munich, Germany 2007
  • LikeAnOcean
    LikeAnOcean Posts: 7,718
    When I first heard Pearl Jam back in 1992, early '93, I didn't like Pearl Jam because of Ed's voice. During the summer of '93 my best friend forced Pearl Jam on me all summer and I eventually grew into it.

    Look at me now.
  • One Song Glory
    One Song Glory Posts: 710
    None of my housemates like Pearl Jam very much...and they've heard quite a lot of it in the past year and a half. :D One of them sort of likes them but would never listen to them of her own accord and one knows a lot of the hits through her older brother but still doesn't care either way. The others can't stand them and don't understand why I don't like "good music like Nickelback or Rihanna!" :confused: From what I've gathered, it IS his voice they don't like. I listen to more live stuff than studio, and they can never figure out what he's saying. I think that's a biggie -- we know the lyrics so well we don't have any problems and I know I personally love the way he lets the lyrics run together, but the average joe can hardly string together a few words listening to a live song they've never heard from this band. I'm sure it can be annoying and just sound like mumbled nonsense. Although I don't know if it's even just Ed that they don't like -- they just aren't fans of real rock music to begin with...they find guitar solos or extended jams boring. :( But I DO see where they're coming from with his voice. Unless you've really been exposed to it long enough to appreciate his vocal ability or loved it right from the beginning, it probably doesn't sound like anything special.
    2003: Toronto
    2005: Kitchener/Hamilton/Toronto
    2006: Toronto 1 & 2
    2008: Hartford/EV Toronto 1 & 2
    2009: Toronto/Philadelphia 3 & 4
    2010: Buffalo
    2011: Montreal/Toronto 1 & 2/Hamilton
    2013: London/Buffalo/Vancouver/Seattle
    2016: Toronto 1 & 2
    2022: Hamilton/Toronto
    2023: EV Seattle 1&2
  • dane
    dane Posts: 1,062
    An Ed basher is no friend of mine! ;)
    Roskilde 30-06-00
    Berlin 23-09-06
    Copenhagen 26-06-07
    :-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-
    "This is not wine that I'm drinking tonight. This is Gatorade!" EV-Copenhagen 26-06-07
  • chiquimonkey
    chiquimonkey Posts: 9,337
    i've heard that too, how people don't like ed's voice. i remember one time i was driving my parents around and i had benaroya on (i figured it's mellow, good tuneage), and my dad says the music's nice but why does that guy sound like a sheep bleating :confused: lol

    i guess ed's voice is an acquired taste, but i love it so that's all that matters to me :)

Categories