MLB 2025 Season

Enkidu

I'm a dumb girl right now, but how does the protest thing work?

perfectlefts14

Bronx Bombers wrote:

perfectlefts14 wrote:

So if Atlanta wins the protest, do they come back tomorrow and play from that point in the game with 1 out and bases loaded?

Yes it would be like the pine tar game with the yanks

So I would imagine game 1 1/2 should be tomorrow.

Ledbetterman10

Get a hit here, Chipper

Love,

A Phillies fan

(well not "love" but you get it)

perfectlefts14

Enkidu wrote:

I'm a dumb girl right now, but how does the protest thing work?

MLB has 24 hours to make a ruling. If they rule in favor of the Braves, they have to replay the game from that point with the bases loaded and 1 out in the 8th inning.

norm

classy way the braves fans sent chipper out

Ledbetterman10

norm wrote:

classy way the braves fans sent chipper out

classy move by the ump to not call him out too because I thought the 1st baseman got his foot back on the bag. But you're not getting out of there alive if you call him out on a bang-bang play there.

Bronx Bombers

perfectlefts14 wrote:

Enkidu wrote:

I'm a dumb girl right now, but how does the protest thing work?

MLB has 24 hours to make a ruling. If they rule in favor of the Braves, they have to replay the game from that point with the bases loaded and 1 out in the 8th inning.

This is going to be a longshot, dont think the cardinals are going to stick around tonight and I doubt MLB will overturn this and make them fly back from Washington and play the same day.

Wobbie

at least we don't have to endure any more tomahawk chop chant.

he.who.forgets

what a bizarre game. Seriously terrible call. Freddy is soft though...Bobby would have gotten tossed in under 10 seconds. Another heartbreaking season from the Bravos

he.who.forgets

And this one-game wild card thing sucks.

DewieCox

Horrible call, but there has surely been worse. Maybe it's a makeup call for the Denkinger call in the 85 series.

That place was loud as shit and either a dipshit fan or the ump's call pulled Kozma off that ball. He had it, but no way was it "ordinary effort".

Real classy of Atlanta fans. They should've been begging for a curtain call from Chipper after that last out, instead they shower the field with trash.

And speaking as a Cards fan, yes, the one game wild card stinks.

Gary Carter

perfectlefts14 wrote:

So if Atlanta wins the protest, do they come back tomorrow and play from that point in the game with 1 out and bases loaded?

probably finish it tonight if the call is reversed and it should be. im a die hard braves hater, obviously, but the braves got really royally screwed on that call. how the fuck is that an infield fly rule when both the holiday and the ss abandoned the ball? seriously that LF umpire should be done for umping the rest of the postseason.

Newch91

Gary Carter wrote:

perfectlefts14 wrote:

So if Atlanta wins the protest, do they come back tomorrow and play from that point in the game with 1 out and bases loaded?

probably finish it tonight if the call is reversed and it should be. im a die hard braves hater, obviously, but the braves got really royally screwed on that call. how the fuck is that an infield fly rule when both the holiday and the ss abandoned the ball? seriously that LF umpire should be done for umping the rest of the postseason.

It was probably one of the replacement refs.

Bronx Bombers

Gary Carter wrote:

perfectlefts14 wrote:

So if Atlanta wins the protest, do they come back tomorrow and play from that point in the game with 1 out and bases loaded?

probably finish it tonight if the call is reversed and it should be. im a die hard braves hater, obviously, but the braves got really royally screwed on that call. how the fuck is that an infield fly rule when both the holiday and the ss abandoned the ball? seriously that LF umpire should be done for umping the rest of the postseason.

This call is not going to be overturned but if it was there's no way they would play tonight, the Cards are boozing it up right now

Gary Carter

Newch91 wrote:

Gary Carter wrote:

perfectlefts14 wrote:

So if Atlanta wins the protest, do they come back tomorrow and play from that point in the game with 1 out and bases loaded?

probably finish it tonight if the call is reversed and it should be. im a die hard braves hater, obviously, but the braves got really royally screwed on that call. how the fuck is that an infield fly rule when both the holiday and the ss abandoned the ball? seriously that LF umpire should be done for umping the rest of the postseason.

It was probably one of the replacement refs.

Gary Carter

Bronx Bombers wrote:

Gary Carter wrote:

perfectlefts14 wrote:

So if Atlanta wins the protest, do they come back tomorrow and play from that point in the game with 1 out and bases loaded?

probably finish it tonight if the call is reversed and it should be. im a die hard braves hater, obviously, but the braves got really royally screwed on that call. how the fuck is that an infield fly rule when both the holiday and the ss abandoned the ball? seriously that LF umpire should be done for umping the rest of the postseason.

This call is not going to be overturned but if it was there's no way they would play tonight, the Cards are boozing it up right now

oh shit totally forgot bout that part, lol . hope they don't go to any clubs in ATL or else it could get ugly.

Indifference71

Protest has been denied.

The Juggler

162 game season decided by that.

cutz

he.who.forgets wrote:

And this one-game wild card thing sucks.

Yea, but now it's more important to win the Division(i like that part).

cutz

Indifference71 wrote:

Protest has been denied.

Are we really surprised?

I didn't think you could protest a judgement call?

I think it was a BAD call, but the Braves played like crap(3 E's).