FINAL WC! Part 4! definitive "Best Song in the PJ Catalog"

24567…15

Comments

  • LoveBoatAdmiral
    LoveBoatAdmiral Posts: 1,191
    All Those Yesterdays wrote:
    Johnny Abruzzo wrote:
    This sounds like fun.

    My complaint: Garden is in the Wild Card round???

    1- Oceans
    2- Wash
    3- Garden
    4- Brother
    5- Let Me Sleep
    6- W.M.A.


    I think I'd personally take out all improvs too.

    There aren't any improvs, covers, or EV solo songs in the tournament, I only included Out of My Mind because they did play it again in Philly, and I needed 1 more song to make an even number.
    2006- Boston I
    2008- Boston I+II
    2009- Toronto, Philly III+IV
    2010- Bristow, Hartford, Boston, Newark
  • RhinoJam
    RhinoJam Raleighwood Posts: 596
    1. Oceans
    2. Deep
    3. Garden
    4. Dirty Frank
    5. ...Let Me Sleep
    6. W.M.A.
    Charlotte 10/4/96 Raleigh 8/31/98 Charlotte 8/4/00 Raleigh 4/15/03 Asheville 10/6/04
    Bonnaroo 6/14/08 Spectrum 10/30/09 Spectrum 10/31/09 Atlanta 9/22/12 Wrigley 7/19/13
    Baltimore 10/27/13 Charlottesville 10/29/13 Charlotte 10/30/13 OKC 11/16/13
    St. Louis 10/03/14 Greenville 4/16/16 Hampton 4/18/16
    Columbia 4/21/16 Wrigley 8/18/18
  • corduroykelly
    corduroykelly Posts: 668
    Oceans
    Deep
    Garden
    Dirty Frank
    Out on my mind
    W.M.A
  • yooperpj
    yooperpj Posts: 316
    1. Oceans vs. Just A Girl
    The currents shift back in forth in a close battle, but in the end, Just A Girl is, well, only a girl.
    Winner: Oceans

    2. Wash vs. Deep
    Deep thought this was going to be a Wash of a game but really just couldnt reach the bottom.
    Winner: Wash

    3. Garden vs. Alone
    Even with Hands Bound, Face Blood, and Shadow Flag, Garden don't share, and Alone Tries to forget, but he can't... he can't....
    Winner: Garden

    4. Brother vs. Dirty Frank
    Brother should have been happy with what he got cuz now hes Food!
    Winner: Dirty Frank

    5. Out of My Mind vs. Let Me Sleep
    Let Me Sleep finally falls asleep and dreams of winning at Christmas time but wakes up and realized he's out of his mind.
    Winner: Out of My Mind

    6. Bee Girl vs. W.M.A.
    W.M.A. Wins the lottery and Bee Girl is, well, being a girl.
    Winner: W.M.A.
  • Bump30
    Bump30 Burlington Ontario Posts: 446
    1. Oceans
    2. Wash
    3. Alone
    4. Brother
    5. Out of My Mind
    6. W.M.A.
    Toronto - 2009
    Hartford - 2010
    Ed Solo - Hartford - 2011
    Toronto X 2, Ottawa & Hamilton - 2011
    Ed Solo - Jacksonville - 2012
    London, Pittsburgh & Buffalo - 2013
    No shows in 2014 :-(
  • Got Guts
    Got Guts Posts: 40
    Simple fun, love it

    1. Oceans
    2. Deep
    3. Garden
    4. Dirty Frank
    5. Out of my Mind
    6. W.M.A.
  • KB262864
    KB262864 Posts: 67
    Oceans
    Wash
    Garden
    Dirty Frank
    Let Me Sleep
    W.M.A.
  • Gmoney
    Gmoney Posts: 1,618
    1. Oceans
    2. Wash
    3. Garden
    4. Dirty Frank
    5. Out of My Mind
    6. W.M.A.
    Further back and forth a wave will break on me, today...
  • marcos
    marcos Posts: 2,112
    1. Oceans
    2. Wash
    3. Garden
    4. Dirty Frank
    5. Let Me Sleep
    6. W.M.A
  • Yellow Ledbelly
    Yellow Ledbelly Posts: 3,749
    1. Oceans
    2. Deep
    3. Alone
    4. Dirty Frank
    5. Out of My Mind
    6. W.M.A.
    All I have to do is revel in the everyday....then do it again tomorrow

    They say every sin is deadly but I believe they may be wrong...I'm guilty of all seven and I don't feel too bad at all
  • FrankieG
    FrankieG Abingdon MD Posts: 9,100
    edited December 2009
    1. Oceans
    2. Deep
    3. Garden
    4. Brother
    5. Out of My Mind
    6. Bee Girl


    GREAT IDEA!!! :D
    Just wondering... how did you choose which song got matched up with who?

    [Edit]: nevermind, read page 2 haha
    Post edited by FrankieG on
    2003: 7/14 NJ ... 2006: 6/1 NJ, 6/3 NJ ... 2007: 8/5 IL ... 2008: 6/24 NY, 6/25 NY, 8/7 EV NJ ... 2009: 10/27 PA, 10/28 PA, 10/30 PA, 10/31 PA
    2010: 5/20 NY, 5/21 NY ... 2011: 6/21 EV NY, 9/3 WI, 9/4 WI ... 2012: 9/2 PA, 9/22 GA ... 2013: 10/18 NY, 10/19 NY, 10/21 PA, 10/22 PA, 10/27 MD
    2015: 9/23 NY, 9/26 NY ... 2016: 4/28 PA, 4/29 PA, 5/1 NY, 5/2 NY, 6/11 TN, 8/7 MA, 11/4 TOTD PA, 11/5 TOTD PA ... 2018: 8/10 WA
    2022: 9/14 NJ ... 2024: 5/28 WA, 9/7 PA, 9/9 PA ---- http://imgur.com/a/nk0s7
  • chattapeejay
    chattapeejay Posts: 12
    1. Oceans
    2. Wash
    3. Garden
    4. Dirty Frank
    5. Out of my Mind
    6. W.M.A.
    6/14/08, 6/23/09
  • veddertown
    veddertown Scotland Posts: 5,260
    Come Back in Black wrote:
    1. Oceans
    2. Deep
    3. Garden
    4. Dirty Frank
    5. Out of My Mind
    6. W.M.A.

    Really great idea. This is going to be great..... but why exactly would 3 ten songs be "wild card" songs? That parts a bit weird. Don't like that album much?

    Same for me :D
    Like a book among the many on a shelf...

    Dublin 02 Arena - 22/6/10. Belfast Odyssey Arena - 23/6/10. London Hyde Park - 25/6/10. Berlin Wuhlheide - 30/6/10.
    Manchester MEN - 20/06/12. Manchester MEN - 21/06/12
  • sstuart42
    sstuart42 Posts: 21
    ** GREAT IDEA***** Maybe you can do a small bracket for albums...


    1. Oceans
    2. Wash
    3. Garden
    4. Brother
    5. Out of my mind
    6. WMA
    09/28/96 Randalls Island,NY 1 09/29/96 Randalls Island 2, 09/10/98 Madison Square Garden,NY 1, 09/11/98 MSG 2, 08/23/00 Jones Beach,NY 1, 08/24/00 Jones Beach 2, 08/25/00 Jones Beach 3, 07/08/03 MSG 1, 07/09/03 MSG 2, 07/12/03 Hershey Park,PA, 06/25/05 MSG, 09/30/05 Borgata Hotel,NJ, 06/03/06 Contintental Arena,NJ, 06/25/08 MSG, 10/31/09 Wachovia Center,Phil , UPCOMING FOR 2010-MSG 2 05/21/2010~~~Continental Arena,NJ 05/18/2010
  • sstuart42
    sstuart42 Posts: 21
    I agree , I already don't agree with the wild cards
    09/28/96 Randalls Island,NY 1 09/29/96 Randalls Island 2, 09/10/98 Madison Square Garden,NY 1, 09/11/98 MSG 2, 08/23/00 Jones Beach,NY 1, 08/24/00 Jones Beach 2, 08/25/00 Jones Beach 3, 07/08/03 MSG 1, 07/09/03 MSG 2, 07/12/03 Hershey Park,PA, 06/25/05 MSG, 09/30/05 Borgata Hotel,NJ, 06/03/06 Contintental Arena,NJ, 06/25/08 MSG, 10/31/09 Wachovia Center,Phil , UPCOMING FOR 2010-MSG 2 05/21/2010~~~Continental Arena,NJ 05/18/2010
  • Johnny Abruzzo
    Johnny Abruzzo Philly Posts: 12,441
    Is Garden vs. Alone kind of an 8 vs. 9 matchup? Those are two really good songs!
    Spectrum 10/27/09; New Orleans JazzFest 5/1/10; Made in America 9/2/12; Phila, PA 10/21/13; Phila,  PA 10/22/13; Baltimore Arena 10/27/13; Phila, PA 4/28/16; Phila, PA 4/29/16; Fenway Park 8/7/16; Fenway Park 9/2/18; Asbury Park 9/18/21; Camden 9/14/22; Las Vegas 5/16/24; Las Vegas 5/18/24; Phila, PA 9/7/24; Phila, PA 9/9/24; Baltimore Arena 9/12/24; Pittsburgh 5/16/25; Pittsburgh 5/18/25

    Tres Mtns - TLA 3/23/11; EV - Tower Theatre 6/25/11; Temple of the Dog - Tower Theatre 11/5/16
  • Niko80
    Niko80 Posts: 1,613
    1. Oceans
    2. Deep
    3. Garden
    4. Brother
    5. Let Me Sleep
    6. W.M.A.
    I will swallow poison
  • rival.
    rival. Chicago Posts: 7,775
    1. Oceans
    2. Wash
    3. Alone
    4. Dirty Frank
    5. Out of My Mind
    6. W.M.A.
  • LoveBoatAdmiral
    LoveBoatAdmiral Posts: 1,191
    sstuart42 wrote:
    I agree , I already don't agree with the wild cards

    I'll admit, it was difficult to seed the songs, especially the songs on Ten. The wild card songs become more like throw away songs later on (there's a Whale Song vs. Santa Cruz matchup on the horizon), but I had to make some tough calls early on. 100 different people could organize this and we'd have 100 different brackets, but since there's no AP poll on this particular subject, I had to make some judicious calls. Just know that what you see now is just a fraction of the whole thing, and as long as you keep voting for your favorites, the best songs will rise to the top.
    2006- Boston I
    2008- Boston I+II
    2009- Toronto, Philly III+IV
    2010- Bristow, Hartford, Boston, Newark
  • nevmiles
    nevmiles Ottawa, ON Posts: 1,363
    1. Oceans
    2. Deep
    3. Garden
    4. Brother
    5. Let Me Sleep
    6. W.M.A.
    Barrie 08/22/98
    Montreal 10/04/00
    Toronto 10/05/00
    Toronto 06/28/03
    Kitchener 09/11/05
    Ottawa 09/16/05
    Toronto 08/21/09
    Toronto 09/11/11
    Ottawa 09/14/11
    Buffalo 10/12/13
    Ottawa 05/08/16
    Chicago 08/20/18
    Ottawa 09/03/22
    Nashville 09/16/22

Categories