Thank You PJ and all 10Cers for making Come Back true.(LONG)
I am proof that this band listens to their fans and no song dedication campaign is too big or small for them not to see it.
I just made it back to my home in Fort Wayne, Indiana. What an absolutely epic, surreal, entertaining, bittersweet journey to Chicago. I have to detail it so I always have it in writing.
Of course, most probably know about my wife passing away back on May 6th. I am a pretty emotionally strong guy, but that broke me down. Nothing in life prepares you for that and the only thing harder than losing a spouse has to be losing a child. It took five days to turn a TV on after she died. I didn't answer my phone for even longer. I am always on top of my job, but I didn't even care if I ever went in to work again. Nothing in my life mattered anymore. All I wanted was to speak to my wife one more time. Get that chance to tell her goodbye. I turned to music. Certain songs just totally changed meaning to me. I have seen/heard people tell me Pearl Jam just speaks to them. I used to roll my eyes and think "Eddie wrote it in his mind, how can it now be YOUR song?"
I now see why. When something emotionally overcomes you, something so big there is nothing in writing on how to deal with it, you have to battle it head-on on your own. Pearl Jam helped me deal with it.
I used to tell my wife that Pearl Jam is only one of the few things I loved way before I met her that I loved still to this day. How many people my age can say they loved something or someone authentically for 2/3 of their life? Pearl Jam is what got me into music, and they are still my band to this day. I got her into the band as well. But the songs that spoke to her weren't the ones that were speaking to me. From day one "Release" was her song. She fell in love with Eddie's voice. She loved "Off He Goes" and "Thumbing My Way" for a long time. When she heard "Come Back" she thought it was the most emotional song the band wrote. She said it could be about anyone who lost a loved one. How right she was.
So after Eddie dedicated that song to my wife and I (even with saying "Andy" instead of "Adam," which is no big deal to me), this band officially became to me "Before and After Sarah PJ." Before Sarah died, PJ songs just sounded awesome to me, after she died, some speak to me in a different way, some have a whole new meaning, and some will always be the ones that got me through the grieving process of losing my best friend. This band will never do wrong in my eyes from this moment on. They genuinely care for their fans. What I asked for would have been easy. Just play Come Back is all I wanted. Just a simple add to the setlist. What they did was not only play the song, but also shared the story of my wife, said her name, said we lost one of the good ones...all of that at one of the biggest/most-anticipated concert of their careers. SERIOUSLY? Think about that.
When I won the lottery to get seats at Wrigley. My wife and I planned our trip to Chicago around the concert. We booked a hotel from Tuesday-Saturday. We were going to enjoy Chicago and make the show the last thing we did before heading home. She loved the city and we made it a mini vacation. And even when she got sick a few months before she died, it was still the highlight of our summer break (I teach high school) and what we kept on anticipating over anything else.
After she died, my whole summer changed. I wanted to fulfill her final wishes (ash spreading in the Atlantic Ocean and Yellowstone National Park) sooner rather than putting it off for a year. This summer officially became the Summer Of Sarah for me. I would do everything for her and with her memory on my mind. That is why I made the request for them to play the song. Because even if they didn't, I would hope for it and Sarah's memory would always be on my mind.
I did my Florida and Colorado/Wyoming/South Dakota trips from June 10th-22nd (Sarah's bday was June 22). I got to see parts of our country she loved the most all the while making peace with her being gone forever. Of course, PJ was a long for the ride too!
I asked my best friend from Cleveland to join me to Chicago, which he accepted. We went up on Thursday and met two of my other friends and lot of fans at Sluggers. Got to hear some of the soundcheck. But we focused on just having a blast that night. I hadn't really had a night like that since my wife passed away. It was great to be surrounded by friends, and of course, Pearl Jam music and Pearl Jam fans.
Friday was nuts. I stood in line for four hours to make sure I got a couple posters. I figured if they played the song, this will be a show like no other and I better get some mementos to have forever. We all hit up another pre-PJ party at Mullen's prior to the show and the next thing I knew we were heading over to Wrigley around 6:30.
Once at my seats (Section 109 row 2) I began meeting a ton of other fans. Guys from Philly, some locals, a guy from Cleveland, a few from Colorado. WOW! This show was such a huge show, bigger than even I thought. I began thinking, there is no way PJ will play this song for me, this is no ordinary show. They have bigger things on their mind than worrying about one fan.
Boy, was I wrong.
I never thought Come Back would be on the setlist so soon. When Eddie was talking and eventually went in to "this next song" speech, my buddy grabbed me and said "this is it." I said, "no way, not this soon." Sure enough he said it all. All of my emotions came rushing back to me. I thought "my god, Sarah is still finding ways of making me happy." But then I went numb. I am not a dancer but I am in to every song, singing a long, maybe a little air guitar or head bopping. But for Come Back, I just stood still looking to the sky. My buddy was hugging me, but I couldn't shake this feeling. Even the people around me were asking if I was ok. I didn't full out breakdown, but I definitely had tears running down by the end of the song. The guy next to me grabbed me and said something I couldn't recall and all I told him was "that song, that was for me and my wife who died in May." He didn't believe me at first, but I told him again. He said "are you serious?" Told him I was, then he got emotional and hugged me. A couple behind me overheard us and during the delay a song later he told me about his wife's brother who passed away from health issues at the age of 34. He told me how much PJ helped that man (who was waiting for a heart transplant) cope with everything. And of course how PJ helped them as well.
Of course, every single person said "no other band would do that for their random fans." And "that's what makes Pearl Jam the best band ever."
I don't disagree.
They are for me and will be forever. I will never get that chance to talk to my wife again, but because of Eddie Vedder, Stone Gossard, Mike McCready, Jeff Ament, and Matt Cameron, Sarah will live on forever in a bigger way than she could have ever imagined.
Thank you to all who kept that thread going to make this come true. It was a magical moment for me and only happened because of you and the world's greatest rock band.
I have met a few people through here. All are cooler than hell. I have private messaged a ton more. All are great people. This band should be so proud of their fans.
By the way, the band stayed at The Four Season's on the Mag Mile. I stayed in the Whitehall across the street. When I left Saturday (to drive to the burbs and stay with family), Boom is just chilling in front of the hotel like it's nothing. A few fans were talking to him and he was cool as hell. I did the "Booooooom" from my car and he smiled and waved. Just thought that was cool and worthy of a mention here.
I just made it back to my home in Fort Wayne, Indiana. What an absolutely epic, surreal, entertaining, bittersweet journey to Chicago. I have to detail it so I always have it in writing.
Of course, most probably know about my wife passing away back on May 6th. I am a pretty emotionally strong guy, but that broke me down. Nothing in life prepares you for that and the only thing harder than losing a spouse has to be losing a child. It took five days to turn a TV on after she died. I didn't answer my phone for even longer. I am always on top of my job, but I didn't even care if I ever went in to work again. Nothing in my life mattered anymore. All I wanted was to speak to my wife one more time. Get that chance to tell her goodbye. I turned to music. Certain songs just totally changed meaning to me. I have seen/heard people tell me Pearl Jam just speaks to them. I used to roll my eyes and think "Eddie wrote it in his mind, how can it now be YOUR song?"
I now see why. When something emotionally overcomes you, something so big there is nothing in writing on how to deal with it, you have to battle it head-on on your own. Pearl Jam helped me deal with it.
I used to tell my wife that Pearl Jam is only one of the few things I loved way before I met her that I loved still to this day. How many people my age can say they loved something or someone authentically for 2/3 of their life? Pearl Jam is what got me into music, and they are still my band to this day. I got her into the band as well. But the songs that spoke to her weren't the ones that were speaking to me. From day one "Release" was her song. She fell in love with Eddie's voice. She loved "Off He Goes" and "Thumbing My Way" for a long time. When she heard "Come Back" she thought it was the most emotional song the band wrote. She said it could be about anyone who lost a loved one. How right she was.
So after Eddie dedicated that song to my wife and I (even with saying "Andy" instead of "Adam," which is no big deal to me), this band officially became to me "Before and After Sarah PJ." Before Sarah died, PJ songs just sounded awesome to me, after she died, some speak to me in a different way, some have a whole new meaning, and some will always be the ones that got me through the grieving process of losing my best friend. This band will never do wrong in my eyes from this moment on. They genuinely care for their fans. What I asked for would have been easy. Just play Come Back is all I wanted. Just a simple add to the setlist. What they did was not only play the song, but also shared the story of my wife, said her name, said we lost one of the good ones...all of that at one of the biggest/most-anticipated concert of their careers. SERIOUSLY? Think about that.
When I won the lottery to get seats at Wrigley. My wife and I planned our trip to Chicago around the concert. We booked a hotel from Tuesday-Saturday. We were going to enjoy Chicago and make the show the last thing we did before heading home. She loved the city and we made it a mini vacation. And even when she got sick a few months before she died, it was still the highlight of our summer break (I teach high school) and what we kept on anticipating over anything else.
After she died, my whole summer changed. I wanted to fulfill her final wishes (ash spreading in the Atlantic Ocean and Yellowstone National Park) sooner rather than putting it off for a year. This summer officially became the Summer Of Sarah for me. I would do everything for her and with her memory on my mind. That is why I made the request for them to play the song. Because even if they didn't, I would hope for it and Sarah's memory would always be on my mind.
I did my Florida and Colorado/Wyoming/South Dakota trips from June 10th-22nd (Sarah's bday was June 22). I got to see parts of our country she loved the most all the while making peace with her being gone forever. Of course, PJ was a long for the ride too!
I asked my best friend from Cleveland to join me to Chicago, which he accepted. We went up on Thursday and met two of my other friends and lot of fans at Sluggers. Got to hear some of the soundcheck. But we focused on just having a blast that night. I hadn't really had a night like that since my wife passed away. It was great to be surrounded by friends, and of course, Pearl Jam music and Pearl Jam fans.
Friday was nuts. I stood in line for four hours to make sure I got a couple posters. I figured if they played the song, this will be a show like no other and I better get some mementos to have forever. We all hit up another pre-PJ party at Mullen's prior to the show and the next thing I knew we were heading over to Wrigley around 6:30.
Once at my seats (Section 109 row 2) I began meeting a ton of other fans. Guys from Philly, some locals, a guy from Cleveland, a few from Colorado. WOW! This show was such a huge show, bigger than even I thought. I began thinking, there is no way PJ will play this song for me, this is no ordinary show. They have bigger things on their mind than worrying about one fan.
Boy, was I wrong.
I never thought Come Back would be on the setlist so soon. When Eddie was talking and eventually went in to "this next song" speech, my buddy grabbed me and said "this is it." I said, "no way, not this soon." Sure enough he said it all. All of my emotions came rushing back to me. I thought "my god, Sarah is still finding ways of making me happy." But then I went numb. I am not a dancer but I am in to every song, singing a long, maybe a little air guitar or head bopping. But for Come Back, I just stood still looking to the sky. My buddy was hugging me, but I couldn't shake this feeling. Even the people around me were asking if I was ok. I didn't full out breakdown, but I definitely had tears running down by the end of the song. The guy next to me grabbed me and said something I couldn't recall and all I told him was "that song, that was for me and my wife who died in May." He didn't believe me at first, but I told him again. He said "are you serious?" Told him I was, then he got emotional and hugged me. A couple behind me overheard us and during the delay a song later he told me about his wife's brother who passed away from health issues at the age of 34. He told me how much PJ helped that man (who was waiting for a heart transplant) cope with everything. And of course how PJ helped them as well.
Of course, every single person said "no other band would do that for their random fans." And "that's what makes Pearl Jam the best band ever."
I don't disagree.
They are for me and will be forever. I will never get that chance to talk to my wife again, but because of Eddie Vedder, Stone Gossard, Mike McCready, Jeff Ament, and Matt Cameron, Sarah will live on forever in a bigger way than she could have ever imagined.
Thank you to all who kept that thread going to make this come true. It was a magical moment for me and only happened because of you and the world's greatest rock band.
I have met a few people through here. All are cooler than hell. I have private messaged a ton more. All are great people. This band should be so proud of their fans.
By the way, the band stayed at The Four Season's on the Mag Mile. I stayed in the Whitehall across the street. When I left Saturday (to drive to the burbs and stay with family), Boom is just chilling in front of the hotel like it's nothing. A few fans were talking to him and he was cool as hell. I did the "Booooooom" from my car and he smiled and waved. Just thought that was cool and worthy of a mention here.
___________________________________________________________
"A whisper in the dark...is that you, or just my thoughts?"
-EV
"A whisper in the dark...is that you, or just my thoughts?"
-EV
Post edited by Unknown User on
0
Comments
-
Nice......amazing story that will live on.Montreal 2003. Halifax 2005. EV Montreal 2008. Toronto 2009
Toronto 2011 1 & 2 London 2013. Quebec City 2016. Ottawa 2016
Fenway 2016 1 & 20 -
Wow Hoosiers. Tears in my eyes as I read your message. it's so great they played the song for you & I absolutely wish you love & healing as you move on with your life. R.I.P. Sarah & long & happy life Hoosiers.<hr>
PJ - Auckland 2009; Alpine Valley1&2 2011; Man1, Am'dam1&2, Berlin1&2, Stockholm, Oslo & Copenhagen 2012; LA, Oakland, Portland, Spokane, Calgary, Vancouver, Seattle 2013; Auckland 2014, Auckland1&2 2024
EV - Canberra, Newcastle & Sydney 1&2 20110 -
In a world full of superlatives (of more and less or better and worst), that version of Come Back was one of the most emotionally charged renditions of any song that I've ever heard, and sent me (and a number of other people around me) to tears.
Hoosiers, I can't even imagine how this has (and continues to be) the most absolute difficult thing in the world. On behalf of so many people who have read your posts, our thoughts and prayers. Please stay strong.0 -
I thought my respect for the band couldn't get any higher but this raised it to a whole new level. After reading your original thread on here I'm really happy they played the song for you. Sorry again for your loss Hoosier.0
-
This is amazing. I am so happy for you. It was amazing to hear your story and watch the video of Sarah, watch the thread grow and then hear eddie speak about it at freaken wrigley field!! So awesome. I had a feeling they would play it for you, but i didnt expect the dedication. They have hearts of gold as do you and Sarah. It was all around amazing. I stood there and just wondered where you were sitting and what you could be feeling... I can't imagine what you have endured in these past few months. I admire your strength and courage. Your story and Sarah have now touched the lives of thousands. I hope that this can serve as a seed of happiness that grows in your life from here on out. Pearl Jam foreverFurther back and forth a wave will break on me, today...0
-
It was an amazing moment, I'm glad it happened for you! I told my wife about it before the show, and as soon as Eddie started talking I knew it was happening. Best wishes.1998-06-30 Mpls | 2006-07-06 Las Vegas
2010-05-03 Kansas City | 2011-07-01 St. Louis EV
2011-07-02 Mpls EV | 2011-09-03 PJ20
2011-09-04 PJ20 | 2011-09-17 Winnipeg
2012-09-30 Missoula | 2012-11-18 Tulsa EV
2013-07-19 Chicago | 2013-11-15 Dallas
2013-11-16 OKC | 2014-10-09 Lincoln
2014-10-17 Moline | 2014-10-19 St. Paul
2014-10-20 Milwaukee | 2016-08-20 Chicago
2016-08-22 Chicago | 2018-08-18 Chicago
2018-08-20 Chicago | 2022-05-09 Phoenix
2022-05-20 Las Vegas | 2022-09-18 St. Louis
2022-09-20 OKC | 2023-08-31 St. Paul
2023-09-02 St. Paul | 2024-05-16 Las Vegas
2024-05-18 Las Vegas | 2024-08-31 Chicago0 -
my best thoughts to you....so sorry for your lossRemember the Thomas Nine !! (10/02/2018)
The Golden Age is 2 months away. And guess what….. you’re gonna love it! (teskeinc 11.19.24)
1998: Noblesville; 2003: Noblesville; 2009: EV Nashville, Chicago, Chicago
2010: St Louis, Columbus, Noblesville; 2011: EV Chicago, East Troy, East Troy
2013: London ON, Wrigley; 2014: Cincy, St Louis, Moline (NO CODE)
2016: Lexington, Wrigley #1; 2018: Wrigley, Wrigley, Boston, Boston
2020: Oakland, Oakland: 2021: EV Ohana, Ohana, Ohana, Ohana
2022: Oakland, Oakland, Nashville, Louisville; 2023: Chicago, Chicago, Noblesville
2024: Noblesville, Wrigley, Wrigley, Ohana, Ohana; 2025: Pitt1, Pitt20 -
I was sitting in section 109 row 1 , seats 7 and 8. Were you the two guys sitting behind me. Either way God bless you and your wife.....0
-
So happy for you (and Sarah) that it got played.0
-
Sorry for your loss but so happy they did this for you. Thank you for sharing with us all. Thanks to 10C for passing on this message to them. Good luck to you!0
-
Yeah man, that was great.
I had tears in my eyes just from knowing about your story.Hey, hey. My, my. Rock and roll can never die.
"Why go home? I am home! And I gotta tell you, it feels FUCKIN GREAT to be here. You may experience this yourself but, if you were born in Chicago, you're always from Chicago. And even if you don't live in Chicago, Chicago will always live in you."-Ed0 -
Man that put tears in my eyes. Unreal. Sarah was my mothers name. This story is an amazing testament to this band and their fans. It should be published somewhere. Truly amazing. God bless you.0
-
I got extremely emotional hearing this song dedicated to your Sarah.
It just goes to show that this band listens to their fans. They care about their fans.
I'm very, very touched by your experience and as a fellow PJ fan, I hug you from afar.2003 Dallas
2013 Wrigley
2013 Dallas
2013 Oklahoma City
2013 Seattle
How I choose to feel is how I am.
There's just one word I still believe...and it's LOVE.
"Take care of one another..." -EV0 -
Ecolella9 wrote:I was sitting in section 109 row 1 , seats 7 and 8. Were you the two guys sitting behind me. Either way God bless you and your wife.....
We were 5 and 6. Are you from Philly? Wearing the banana shirt? If so, I talked to you all night, man!___________________________________________________________
"A whisper in the dark...is that you, or just my thoughts?"
-EV0 -
Very happy that you got to hear this!!! As they played it I thought about how moving it must be for you. I've had two loved one's pass away over the years to which I played Immortality on a loops for weeks on end...so I can relate & the band has done so much for us in that manner that collectively we would never be able to repay them.RC:SD 06241998//ET:WI 06271998//MP:MN 06301998//AH:MI 10072000//ET:WI 10082000 (ICEBOWL)//CB:IA 06132003//SL:MO 10052004//CHI:IL 05162006//SP:MN 06262006//SP:MN 06272006//CHI:IL 082120080
-
Kimmiebyrom wrote:I got extremely emotional hearing this song dedicated to your Sarah.
It just goes to show that this band listens to their fans. They care about their fans.
I'm very, very touched by your experience and as a fellow PJ fan, I hug you from afar.
Same here. I took a friend to his first PJ show and explained to him what's going on. It was already an amazing experience (just a few songs in) for him, but he walked away with a greater admiration for the band because of the dedication.
Very cool on their part. Glad you followed up after the concert for us to hear your story.0 -
Hell yea that was me , I sent you my info to your email . Thanks. EC0
-
Come back was just amazing; I was in tears at the show and I'm in tears again reading your post. I'm so sorry for your loss. Best thoughts to you! *hug*0
-
My husband and I watched the set list from Wyoming.... of course I had tears in my eyes when I saw that they played your song.
I hope that this will help as you continue your healing. Just to have that deep emotional connection to the song with your wife is such a blessing.
The songs of Pearl Jam are the backdrop to many of our lives and just hearing a certain note or lyric from a song brings back a memory of how that song helped shape us into who we are.
My husband had asked the band to play Of The Girl at the Salt Lake show in 09. This song was our daughters "walk up song" in little league baseball where she had to complete against the boys. When they opened the show with that song everyone in the crowd around us was just ecstatic. An excited fan next to my daughter almost knocked her over with a bear hug.
I know that Pearl Jam has that emotional connection to their fans and appreciates the deep connection and how the lyrics bring all of us together. Someone on the forum yesterday compared a Pearl Jam concert to a religious experience and I think that is exactly what it is for many of us.
Whenever I hear Come Back I will be sending good thoughts your way.....can not find the candle of thought to light your name0 -
Beautiful0
Categories
- All Categories
- 148.9K Pearl Jam's Music and Activism
- 110.1K The Porch
- 274 Vitalogy
- 35K Given To Fly (live)
- 3.5K Words and Music...Communication
- 39.2K Flea Market
- 39.2K Lost Dogs
- 58.7K Not Pearl Jam's Music
- 10.6K Musicians and Gearheads
- 29.1K Other Music
- 17.8K Poetry, Prose, Music & Art
- 1.1K The Art Wall
- 56.8K Non-Pearl Jam Discussion
- 22.2K A Moving Train
- 31.7K All Encompassing Trip
- 2.9K Technical Stuff and Help