Black - most depressing, yet most beautiful song

62strat · September 2003

ever.

MeddleDeal · September 2003

YES it is.

I mean, I love it how mike changes his solos EVERY TIME, it is not the same and that is what I like about this song and Eddie, OMG, how he puts his own emotions into that song like 'we belong together' oh MAN, it doesn't get any heavier than that.:)

Pearl_Ju · September 2003

I think Nothingman is as much depressing as Black... Both are equally sad... and I love both of them!

pears · September 2003

black makes me cry. i love the unplugged version. i could listen to it for hours.

5horizons · September 2003

Originally posted by pears
black makes me cry. i love the unplugged version. i could listen to it for hours.

the Unplugged version is also my fav.

We belong.. we belong together...

{[Pearl_Jam}] · September 2003

for me... i love depressing songs... i think most beautiful than a love song...

monster · September 2003

I STILL can't listen to that song.

I remember going to the Buffalo show, and I was having a great time, and then all off of the sudden I hear the opening notes for Black and it was like being hit by a truck. I just kinda sat down and held my head in my hands for a few minutes.

fucking suck I am

Arcticangel · September 2003

I'll agree with you there strat...it's an amazing song. There is so much emotion behind the song that I don't think I'll ever figure out. But even though it's such a deep, personal song, everyone connects to it in some way. Every fan. Now that, that is an epic.

Lauri · September 2003

and there isn't anyone alive who can't relate to it somehow..."i know you'll be a star in somebody else's sky..."

intodeep · September 2003

I've been skipping this song lately brings too many sad emotions for me right now.

IT is a great song though just hard to listen to right now in my life

TABBYCAT · September 2003

black reminds me of someone i loved a lot and for a lot of reasons i cant be with anymore...someone i had to give up (distance reasons..) oh well ,black is a beautiful song !

StonesDirtyUndies · September 2003

This song is worthy of a salute.........

i forget · September 2003

I heard this tune live, and it was such
a rollercoaster of emotions! I almost cried,
but they played some cool little laughing raindrop
type notes that made me have to smile.
I get shivers all through me listening to the
boot. Thanks PJ!!

PhillyPJ · September 2003

I agree

rybes · September 2003

such a beautiful beautiful song, brings me to tears quite often

Cornflakegrl98 · September 2003

Black definitely can bring me to tears but lately Nothingman has really been getting to me, especially the Touring Band version. But when black is live and mixed with just the right amount of sorrow, it's amazing. A lot of my own memories are mixed up in Black.

amicitia · September 2003

Black is really an emotional song and I guess most of the people were going, are going or will be going through the stage in their life when they can somehow relate to it...

dgenerate1857 · September 2003

black is the single most amazing song ever written for me in terms of emotion. that song is 100% pure heartache. I can relate to it on so many levels, and its the only song that has ever made me cry............i have a hard time imagining my life without that song.

Thank you PJ!!!! Thank you so much!

Versus13 · December 2013

My FAVOURITE song of all time! Full of huge emotion and is just brilliant musically and lyrically! They played it in Pittsburgh this year and it was awesome!

MTV '92 is my favourite version

Malroth · January 2014

WWWHHHYYYYYYYY, WWWWWHHHHYYYYYYY CAN'T IT BE MEEEEEEEEEEEE.

it just can't. I've sang this song at the top of my lungs many times, often scaring those around me.

dimitrispearljam · January 2014

best song in the history of music

Black - most depressing, yet most beautiful song

Comments

Categories