Something about teacher's pay...
Comments
-
PJ_Soul said:brianlux said:tempo_n_groove said:mcgruff10 said:mace1229 said:If you're curious how much teachers make in my area this is a good example. The local paper reported this district as the highest paying in the county.
If you're not familiar with this scale, the #1-26 on the left represent years of experience, and the top represents education. So yes a teacher can make close to 80k here, if they have a Masters AND a something close to a PHD equivalent (72 graduate level units) and 26 years of teaching experience. How many people with a PHD do you know that work in the same place for 26 years and only make 80k? I don't know any.
A teacher with a masters starts out at 42,900, a masters and 10 years experience makes 49,900. If all you ever get is a BA, then your max pay is 46k. You have to spend more time and a lot of money to earn additional, graduate level credits to increase pay. This is expensive and slow. Earn a Masters after your BA and you get a whopping 5k added to your pay.
Not to mention about $1000 a month will be taken out of this pay for benefits. Then deductions for taxes, medicare, retirement etc is another $700 or $800 a month
And that retirement the article bragged about so much, well that is self-funded. Money is taken out of your paycheck and placed into a fund. No retirement is given to teachers in this state, it is basically a stock market that is managed for you with your own money. The only problem is if you die 2 years after you retire your wife or kids never see that money that you put into for 30 years, it goes back into the pension fund (yes there is that potential to live to 100 and get more back than you put in). Stock market managed by me and not on my behalf actually sounds like a better deal.
So you still think they are overpaid?
Teachers?
I've been out of teaching for several years so I don't know for fact how competitive teaching positions are in most places (U.S., that is) but I'm guessing that with as low as the pay is, as high the stress is, as unappreciated as the career is, and as the value of being well educated seems to be going down here, not up, there probably isn't all that much competition here anymore. I rarely meet college age kids anymore who talk about wanting to go into teaching.
"It's a sad and beautiful world"-Roberto Benigni0 -
PJ_Soul said:brianlux said:tempo_n_groove said:mcgruff10 said:mace1229 said:If you're curious how much teachers make in my area this is a good example. The local paper reported this district as the highest paying in the county.
If you're not familiar with this scale, the #1-26 on the left represent years of experience, and the top represents education. So yes a teacher can make close to 80k here, if they have a Masters AND a something close to a PHD equivalent (72 graduate level units) and 26 years of teaching experience. How many people with a PHD do you know that work in the same place for 26 years and only make 80k? I don't know any.
A teacher with a masters starts out at 42,900, a masters and 10 years experience makes 49,900. If all you ever get is a BA, then your max pay is 46k. You have to spend more time and a lot of money to earn additional, graduate level credits to increase pay. This is expensive and slow. Earn a Masters after your BA and you get a whopping 5k added to your pay.
Not to mention about $1000 a month will be taken out of this pay for benefits. Then deductions for taxes, medicare, retirement etc is another $700 or $800 a month
And that retirement the article bragged about so much, well that is self-funded. Money is taken out of your paycheck and placed into a fund. No retirement is given to teachers in this state, it is basically a stock market that is managed for you with your own money. The only problem is if you die 2 years after you retire your wife or kids never see that money that you put into for 30 years, it goes back into the pension fund (yes there is that potential to live to 100 and get more back than you put in). Stock market managed by me and not on my behalf actually sounds like a better deal.
So you still think they are overpaid?
Teachers?
Not all schools and areas do that, some states are funded very well and prefer more education. But I have heard more than one administrator say that.0 -
mace1229 said:PJ_Soul said:brianlux said:tempo_n_groove said:mcgruff10 said:mace1229 said:If you're curious how much teachers make in my area this is a good example. The local paper reported this district as the highest paying in the county.
If you're not familiar with this scale, the #1-26 on the left represent years of experience, and the top represents education. So yes a teacher can make close to 80k here, if they have a Masters AND a something close to a PHD equivalent (72 graduate level units) and 26 years of teaching experience. How many people with a PHD do you know that work in the same place for 26 years and only make 80k? I don't know any.
A teacher with a masters starts out at 42,900, a masters and 10 years experience makes 49,900. If all you ever get is a BA, then your max pay is 46k. You have to spend more time and a lot of money to earn additional, graduate level credits to increase pay. This is expensive and slow. Earn a Masters after your BA and you get a whopping 5k added to your pay.
Not to mention about $1000 a month will be taken out of this pay for benefits. Then deductions for taxes, medicare, retirement etc is another $700 or $800 a month
And that retirement the article bragged about so much, well that is self-funded. Money is taken out of your paycheck and placed into a fund. No retirement is given to teachers in this state, it is basically a stock market that is managed for you with your own money. The only problem is if you die 2 years after you retire your wife or kids never see that money that you put into for 30 years, it goes back into the pension fund (yes there is that potential to live to 100 and get more back than you put in). Stock market managed by me and not on my behalf actually sounds like a better deal.
So you still think they are overpaid?
Teachers?
Not all schools and areas do that, some states are funded very well and prefer more education. But I have heard more than one administrator say that.
"It's a sad and beautiful world"-Roberto Benigni0 -
tempo_n_groove said:mcgruff10 said:mace1229 said:If you're curious how much teachers make in my area this is a good example. The local paper reported this district as the highest paying in the county.
If you're not familiar with this scale, the #1-26 on the left represent years of experience, and the top represents education. So yes a teacher can make close to 80k here, if they have a Masters AND a something close to a PHD equivalent (72 graduate level units) and 26 years of teaching experience. How many people with a PHD do you know that work in the same place for 26 years and only make 80k? I don't know any.
A teacher with a masters starts out at 42,900, a masters and 10 years experience makes 49,900. If all you ever get is a BA, then your max pay is 46k. You have to spend more time and a lot of money to earn additional, graduate level credits to increase pay. This is expensive and slow. Earn a Masters after your BA and you get a whopping 5k added to your pay.
Not to mention about $1000 a month will be taken out of this pay for benefits. Then deductions for taxes, medicare, retirement etc is another $700 or $800 a month
And that retirement the article bragged about so much, well that is self-funded. Money is taken out of your paycheck and placed into a fund. No retirement is given to teachers in this state, it is basically a stock market that is managed for you with your own money. The only problem is if you die 2 years after you retire your wife or kids never see that money that you put into for 30 years, it goes back into the pension fund (yes there is that potential to live to 100 and get more back than you put in). Stock market managed by me and not on my behalf actually sounds like a better deal.
So you still think they are overpaid?
Teachers?I'll ride the wave where it takes me......0 -
mcgruff10 said:tempo_n_groove said:mcgruff10 said:mace1229 said:If you're curious how much teachers make in my area this is a good example. The local paper reported this district as the highest paying in the county.
If you're not familiar with this scale, the #1-26 on the left represent years of experience, and the top represents education. So yes a teacher can make close to 80k here, if they have a Masters AND a something close to a PHD equivalent (72 graduate level units) and 26 years of teaching experience. How many people with a PHD do you know that work in the same place for 26 years and only make 80k? I don't know any.
A teacher with a masters starts out at 42,900, a masters and 10 years experience makes 49,900. If all you ever get is a BA, then your max pay is 46k. You have to spend more time and a lot of money to earn additional, graduate level credits to increase pay. This is expensive and slow. Earn a Masters after your BA and you get a whopping 5k added to your pay.
Not to mention about $1000 a month will be taken out of this pay for benefits. Then deductions for taxes, medicare, retirement etc is another $700 or $800 a month
And that retirement the article bragged about so much, well that is self-funded. Money is taken out of your paycheck and placed into a fund. No retirement is given to teachers in this state, it is basically a stock market that is managed for you with your own money. The only problem is if you die 2 years after you retire your wife or kids never see that money that you put into for 30 years, it goes back into the pension fund (yes there is that potential to live to 100 and get more back than you put in). Stock market managed by me and not on my behalf actually sounds like a better deal.
So you still think they are overpaid?
Teachers?0 -
tempo_n_groove said:mcgruff10 said:tempo_n_groove said:mcgruff10 said:mace1229 said:If you're curious how much teachers make in my area this is a good example. The local paper reported this district as the highest paying in the county.
If you're not familiar with this scale, the #1-26 on the left represent years of experience, and the top represents education. So yes a teacher can make close to 80k here, if they have a Masters AND a something close to a PHD equivalent (72 graduate level units) and 26 years of teaching experience. How many people with a PHD do you know that work in the same place for 26 years and only make 80k? I don't know any.
A teacher with a masters starts out at 42,900, a masters and 10 years experience makes 49,900. If all you ever get is a BA, then your max pay is 46k. You have to spend more time and a lot of money to earn additional, graduate level credits to increase pay. This is expensive and slow. Earn a Masters after your BA and you get a whopping 5k added to your pay.
Not to mention about $1000 a month will be taken out of this pay for benefits. Then deductions for taxes, medicare, retirement etc is another $700 or $800 a month
And that retirement the article bragged about so much, well that is self-funded. Money is taken out of your paycheck and placed into a fund. No retirement is given to teachers in this state, it is basically a stock market that is managed for you with your own money. The only problem is if you die 2 years after you retire your wife or kids never see that money that you put into for 30 years, it goes back into the pension fund (yes there is that potential to live to 100 and get more back than you put in). Stock market managed by me and not on my behalf actually sounds like a better deal.
So you still think they are overpaid?
Teachers?
I lived in western NY state for two separate years ('75 and '77) and that first year I could not find work and hadn't yet completed my BA in California. I was almost on the verge of starving so I finally applied for financial assistance and was told I could receive food stamps and a bit of welfare money and I said, "Fine, but I need to work for it." That rural county was in desperate need of teaching assistants so they created a class for me in which they dumped all the drop outs, flunkies and fuck ups. That was cool because I could understand their rebellion. On Fridays, I checked out a record player from the AV room and we spun records. We had a good time and one Friday, one of those kids brought in a record he had just bought. It was the Neil Young & Crazy Horse album, Zuma which I had never hear until that day. Good times!
"It's a sad and beautiful world"-Roberto Benigni0 -
tempo_n_groove said:mcgruff10 said:tempo_n_groove said:mcgruff10 said:mace1229 said:If you're curious how much teachers make in my area this is a good example. The local paper reported this district as the highest paying in the county.
If you're not familiar with this scale, the #1-26 on the left represent years of experience, and the top represents education. So yes a teacher can make close to 80k here, if they have a Masters AND a something close to a PHD equivalent (72 graduate level units) and 26 years of teaching experience. How many people with a PHD do you know that work in the same place for 26 years and only make 80k? I don't know any.
A teacher with a masters starts out at 42,900, a masters and 10 years experience makes 49,900. If all you ever get is a BA, then your max pay is 46k. You have to spend more time and a lot of money to earn additional, graduate level credits to increase pay. This is expensive and slow. Earn a Masters after your BA and you get a whopping 5k added to your pay.
Not to mention about $1000 a month will be taken out of this pay for benefits. Then deductions for taxes, medicare, retirement etc is another $700 or $800 a month
And that retirement the article bragged about so much, well that is self-funded. Money is taken out of your paycheck and placed into a fund. No retirement is given to teachers in this state, it is basically a stock market that is managed for you with your own money. The only problem is if you die 2 years after you retire your wife or kids never see that money that you put into for 30 years, it goes back into the pension fund (yes there is that potential to live to 100 and get more back than you put in). Stock market managed by me and not on my behalf actually sounds like a better deal.
So you still think they are overpaid?
Teachers?I'll ride the wave where it takes me......0 -
In Kentucky ALL teachers are required to have their masters within 10 years but most teacher prep programs are set up to give you a masters as your initial certification credentials.. The only teachers that have generally needed to go back were older teachers who started before this was required (before 1995 or so).
I'd like to add a big thank you to those who have offered your support. Its disheartening to go to work every day and know that so many blame you for the ills of society and offer little to no support. I actively discourage anyone from entering this profession and that includes my own child who would be an outstanding teacher. But this country will have to learn the hard way. In KY we just staged several days of 'sickouts' to fight to fully fund our pension (a pension that I've paid 13% of EVERY paycheck into for the last 16 years - people seem to think pensions are "free" money!) and fully fund our schools. We've gotten a lot of support and we managed to roll back some of the worst issues the legislature and our dumbass governor were pushing but the amount of people that don't support us (and really, that means they don't support kids) is disgusting. I read through this thread yesterday and I'd like to say I'm surprised with the things some people said but really, it's just more of the same. I've worked a regular 9-5 job for a "full" year like some of you here and I can tell you from firsthand experience that teaching is way harder, physically, mentally, and emotionally. I'd like to address some of the misconceptions that some of you have and maybe I'll have time later but I encourage (and really I think it should be required) each of you to go work in a school with a teacher so you can get a sense of what really happens in a classroom. Trust me it is nothing like you think that it is.Are we getting something out of this all-encompassing trip?
Seems my preconceptions are what should have been burned...
I AM MINE0 -
I was studying to be a teacher, did about 2 weeks of placement at a high school. I got scared away. Not for me.
I hate how parents don't read to their kids, don't help them with their homework and then blame teachers.
I hate how stupid people are, they think having kids is just breeding them and that is it.Adelaide 17/11/2009, Melbourne 20/11/2009, Sydney 22/11/2009, Melbourne (Big Day Out Festival) 24/01/20140 -
For those regions requiring their teachers to earn a masters degree... do the districts pay for the demand or is that left to the individual?"My brain's a good brain!"0
-
Thoughts_Arrive said:I was studying to be a teacher, did about 2 weeks of placement at a high school. I got scared away. Not for me.
I hate how parents don't read to their kids, don't help them with their homework and then blame teachers.
I hate how stupid people are, they think having kids is just breeding them and that is it.
You don’t need a masters to teach in Ontario ...
You did a placement at a high school ... those kids should be able to read to themselves. Not sure how many parents can help kids with much of their homework at the high school level. As far as homework ... it should be banned.Give Peas A Chance…0 -
Meltdown99 said:Thoughts_Arrive said:I was studying to be a teacher, did about 2 weeks of placement at a high school. I got scared away. Not for me.
I hate how parents don't read to their kids, don't help them with their homework and then blame teachers.
I hate how stupid people are, they think having kids is just breeding them and that is it.
You don’t need a masters to teach in Ontario ...
You did a placement at a high school ... those kids should be able to read to themselves. Not sure how many parents can help kids with much of their homework at the high school level. As far as homework ... it should be banned.I'll ride the wave where it takes me......0 -
riotgrl said:In Kentucky ALL teachers are required to have their masters within 10 years but most teacher prep programs are set up to give you a masters as your initial certification credentials.. The only teachers that have generally needed to go back were older teachers who started before this was required (before 1995 or so).
I'd like to add a big thank you to those who have offered your support. Its disheartening to go to work every day and know that so many blame you for the ills of society and offer little to no support. I actively discourage anyone from entering this profession and that includes my own child who would be an outstanding teacher. But this country will have to learn the hard way. In KY we just staged several days of 'sickouts' to fight to fully fund our pension (a pension that I've paid 13% of EVERY paycheck into for the last 16 years - people seem to think pensions are "free" money!) and fully fund our schools. We've gotten a lot of support and we managed to roll back some of the worst issues the legislature and our dumbass governor were pushing but the amount of people that don't support us (and really, that means they don't support kids) is disgusting. I read through this thread yesterday and I'd like to say I'm surprised with the things some people said but really, it's just more of the same. I've worked a regular 9-5 job for a "full" year like some of you here and I can tell you from firsthand experience that teaching is way harder, physically, mentally, and emotionally. I'd like to address some of the misconceptions that some of you have and maybe I'll have time later but I encourage (and really I think it should be required) each of you to go work in a school with a teacher so you can get a sense of what really happens in a classroom. Trust me it is nothing like you think that it is.
I took a year off from teaching at one point and that is 100% true. No stress, well rested, etc. Went back to teaching after moving thinking it was going to be different. And it was for a while, until the lack of pay increases combined with the huge spike in insurance and other cost of living has forced me to find other work part time, now I'm just exhausted all day again. Some years we make less than the year before with higher deductions from my paycheck.
I don't get the argument that the public thinks the pension is such a perk either. Its very puzzling. We all pay a good amount of our paycheck into it, and for anyone hired within the last 15 years we don't get back what we've put it. We seriously would be better off putting that 13% into a private fund. But we are paying (literally) for the mistakes the previous generation made. If you started right out of college many teachers retiring now can retire at 52 with almost a full paycheck and live another 40 years, so they have to raise what newer teachers put into the retirement plan and we get less back to compensate for it. End result, I wont be allowed to retire until 64 and only get about 65% of my paycheck when I do, while I've put in more of my check each month than previous generations did who retired a lot earlier with a lot better benefits.Post edited by mace1229 on0 -
Thirty Bills Unpaid said:For those regions requiring their teachers to earn a masters degree... do the districts pay for the demand or is that left to the individual?Are we getting something out of this all-encompassing trip?
Seems my preconceptions are what should have been burned...
I AM MINE0 -
riotgrl said:Thirty Bills Unpaid said:For those regions requiring their teachers to earn a masters degree... do the districts pay for the demand or is that left to the individual?my small self... like a book amongst the many on a shelf0
-
riotgrl said:Thirty Bills Unpaid said:For those regions requiring their teachers to earn a masters degree... do the districts pay for the demand or is that left to the individual?I'll ride the wave where it takes me......0
-
mcgruff10 said:riotgrl said:Thirty Bills Unpaid said:For those regions requiring their teachers to earn a masters degree... do the districts pay for the demand or is that left to the individual?Are we getting something out of this all-encompassing trip?
Seems my preconceptions are what should have been burned...
I AM MINE0 -
Meltdown99 said:Thoughts_Arrive said:I was studying to be a teacher, did about 2 weeks of placement at a high school. I got scared away. Not for me.
I hate how parents don't read to their kids, don't help them with their homework and then blame teachers.
I hate how stupid people are, they think having kids is just breeding them and that is it.
You don’t need a masters to teach in Ontario ...
You did a placement at a high school ... those kids should be able to read to themselves. Not sure how many parents can help kids with much of their homework at the high school level. As far as homework ... it should be banned.
Some universities offer it some don't.
When I was doing my placement I had other student teachers from other universities doing their masters.Adelaide 17/11/2009, Melbourne 20/11/2009, Sydney 22/11/2009, Melbourne (Big Day Out Festival) 24/01/20140 -
Thoughts_Arrive said:Meltdown99 said:Thoughts_Arrive said:I was studying to be a teacher, did about 2 weeks of placement at a high school. I got scared away. Not for me.
I hate how parents don't read to their kids, don't help them with their homework and then blame teachers.
I hate how stupid people are, they think having kids is just breeding them and that is it.
You don’t need a masters to teach in Ontario ...
You did a placement at a high school ... those kids should be able to read to themselves. Not sure how many parents can help kids with much of their homework at the high school level. As far as homework ... it should be banned.
Some universities offer it some don't.
When I was doing my placement I had other student teachers from other universities doing their masters.Thoughts_Arrive said:Meltdown99 said:Thoughts_Arrive said:I was studying to be a teacher, did about 2 weeks of placement at a high school. I got scared away. Not for me.
I hate how parents don't read to their kids, don't help them with their homework and then blame teachers.
I hate how stupid people are, they think having kids is just breeding them and that is it.
You don’t need a masters to teach in Ontario ...
You did a placement at a high school ... those kids should be able to read to themselves. Not sure how many parents can help kids with much of their homework at the high school level. As far as homework ... it should be banned.
Some universities offer it some don't.
When I was doing my placement I had other student teachers from other universities doing their masters.
when i was studying, if youd obtained an undergrad degree, you had to satisfy the dept of education guidelines to do a masters in secondary education, dependant on what that degree was. i did my bachelors degree majoring in english and history/philosophy/politics. when it came time for my masters i had to be in possession of a quota of whatever my KLA was going to be. mine was english and history. if you didnt have that quota you had to study them concourrently with your masters.
hear my name
take a good look
this could be the day
hold my hand
lie beside me
i just need to say0 -
catefrances said:Thoughts_Arrive said:Meltdown99 said:Thoughts_Arrive said:I was studying to be a teacher, did about 2 weeks of placement at a high school. I got scared away. Not for me.
I hate how parents don't read to their kids, don't help them with their homework and then blame teachers.
I hate how stupid people are, they think having kids is just breeding them and that is it.
You don’t need a masters to teach in Ontario ...
You did a placement at a high school ... those kids should be able to read to themselves. Not sure how many parents can help kids with much of their homework at the high school level. As far as homework ... it should be banned.
Some universities offer it some don't.
When I was doing my placement I had other student teachers from other universities doing their masters.Thoughts_Arrive said:Meltdown99 said:Thoughts_Arrive said:I was studying to be a teacher, did about 2 weeks of placement at a high school. I got scared away. Not for me.
I hate how parents don't read to their kids, don't help them with their homework and then blame teachers.
I hate how stupid people are, they think having kids is just breeding them and that is it.
You don’t need a masters to teach in Ontario ...
You did a placement at a high school ... those kids should be able to read to themselves. Not sure how many parents can help kids with much of their homework at the high school level. As far as homework ... it should be banned.
Some universities offer it some don't.
When I was doing my placement I had other student teachers from other universities doing their masters.
when i was studying, if youd obtained an undergrad degree, you had to satisfy the dept of education guidelines to do a masters in secondary education, dependant on what that degree was. i did my bachelors degree majoring in english and history/philosophy/politics. when it came time for my masters i had to be in possession of a quota of whatever my KLA was going to be. mine was english and history. if you didnt have that quota you had to study them concourrently with your masters.
When I was doing my BA (Humanities) I was doing both concurrently.Adelaide 17/11/2009, Melbourne 20/11/2009, Sydney 22/11/2009, Melbourne (Big Day Out Festival) 24/01/20140
Categories
- All Categories
- 148.8K Pearl Jam's Music and Activism
- 110K The Porch
- 274 Vitalogy
- 35K Given To Fly (live)
- 3.5K Words and Music...Communication
- 39.1K Flea Market
- 39.1K Lost Dogs
- 58.7K Not Pearl Jam's Music
- 10.6K Musicians and Gearheads
- 29.1K Other Music
- 17.8K Poetry, Prose, Music & Art
- 1.1K The Art Wall
- 56.7K Non-Pearl Jam Discussion
- 22.2K A Moving Train
- 31.7K All Encompassing Trip
- 2.9K Technical Stuff and Help