Something about teacher's pay...
Comments
-
Hmmm...
Most of all?
1. Teaching is immeasurable. You can't quantify when good teaching has occurred... you can only tell when it has or hasn't happened.
2. The public needs to embrace its teaching force. It needs to be prepared to not only compensate teachers for their efforts, but also respect the same efforts. It needs to encourage people to enter the profession and succeed- both professionally and personally- within it.
3. Teachers unions need to be prepared to negotiate a model of accountability into contracts. Exactly how 'accountability' might be measured... I'm not entirely sure (although I do have ideas I won't go into at this moment).
The public would likely go along with item 2 if they knew there were legitimate steps employers could take to support and/or relieve poor performers."My brain's a good brain!"0 -
Thirty Bills Unpaid said:
Hmmm...
Most of all?
1. Teaching is immeasurable. You can't quantify when good teaching has occurred... you can only tell when it has or hasn't happened.
2. The public needs to embrace its teaching force. It needs to be prepared to not only compensate teachers for their efforts, but also respect the same efforts. It needs to encourage people to enter the profession and succeed- both professionally and personally- within it.
3. Teachers unions need to be prepared to negotiate a model of accountability into contracts. Exactly how 'accountability' might be measured... I'm not entirely sure (although I do have ideas I won't go into at this moment).
The public would likely go along with item 2 if they knew there were legitimate steps employers could take to support and/or relieve poor performers."It's a sad and beautiful world"-Roberto Benigni0 -
-
Thirty,
#2 - I just made a joke about not being a parent, but I do know that it is important for the public to respect/embrace educators, regardless of whether one has children or not. Glad you phrased it that way.
Excellent answers from you both!0 -
Oh brother. This is ridiculous. Union members have *individual* negotiating power? Huh?
I have never said I get paid close to 100 grand. I'm not sure where you read that, but it wasn't me.Free said:Post edited by what dreams on0 -
OffSheGoes, I feel a major concern right now for the growing amount of mental health issues I see cropping up in students. I have had more students institutionalized in the past three years than I have in the previous 20. I have had multiple students in the past few years with diagnosed anxiety disorders at age 13 and 14. Many, many more go undiagnosed with major depressive symptoms. I'm just terribly concerned that most parents are either not paying any attention at all to their kids or they're paying the wrong kind of attention and making their children anxious and depressed with really dysfunctional parenting. I see very few healthy relationships between parents and their children, and that bleeds over into my job. I can't educate an unwell brain.OffSheGoes35 said:Ok...here is what I would like to know, and I understand if certain people/posters are through with this thread...
1. Free, I would like to know more about the 2 problems you mentioned earlier in the thread. I don't think you ever got a chance to elaborate on those 2 issues you spoke of...
2. Whatdreams, I would like to know more about how changes in parenting have impacted the way you feel about teaching.
3. Thirty and brianlux, what would you like most of all for the average lay person to understand about teaching?0 -
I think we can agree that teacher pay, quality of schooling including the human interaction aspect, resources and infrastructure varies around this country (let alone the world) like crazy. I've seen them all, rat infested leaky roofed American Indian school and schools for children of Hispanic farm workers/ field hands. an institution for mostly inner city black kids living in large dorms and getting their last shot at job training before very likely ending up in jail (that job was intense, almost got killed on that one). Schools for children of wealthy professionals. Alternative schools. I've worked in all of these. It's different all over.
But the bottom line is, the article talked about averages. Statistics, ho hum.
(Random thought)
Oh, and Free, you asked me if I taught. Yes.
-One year in an eastern New York State high school with black listed unruly delinquents who could not be maintained/controlled in a regular class. I learned more from these kids than in any other teaching experience.
-One year in a Job Corps Training site.
-Two full years with a fifth/sixth grade combo.
-One year homeschooling a fourth grade student.
-Five years subbing (mostly grades 6-12 but did 'em all from K up).
-One year at a county job training site.
-Two years tutoring adults.
-Two years in a Health Library (I consider this a teaching position)
-Two years program assistant at our local college.
I think that's all of them but it's hard to remember. I've had a little over thirty different types of jobs.
Post edited by brianlux on"It's a sad and beautiful world"-Roberto Benigni0 -
what dreams said:
Is it any wonder? From their perspective, I can only imagine how crazy this world seems to them. I'm not surprised kids are mentally ill. I'm not surprised most people are mentally ill (yes, I believe that). R. D. Lang. The Politics of Experience. It's pretty well summed up there.
And add to that environmental poisoning and slow poisoning from our food. Major factor in body, mental health, mind/body health."It's a sad and beautiful world"-Roberto Benigni0 -
Again, no union in my state . . . And we have accountability measures in place to support and relieve poor performers.brianlux said:
Thirty Bills, I think you would agree that what makes this conversation so difficult is that the nation is all over the map regarding contracts, salaries, etc. Articles about national salary averages mask gross disparities between rural/urban and suburban districts. The averages are skewed because teachers are getting younger and they get paid less. There are union states with labor protections and then there is the rest of us. Some localities fund through property taxes, others through a school tax. Each state funds its schools at a different percentage of its revenues, which affects how much a locality has available for salaries. It's a mess. It's why I can't stand getting into conversations with people about it, because the public has no idea what the problem is. They think it's about summer vacation. It's just not.
Thank you for finally sharing with me (us?) that you are a teacher. It helps to know who we are talking to. I didn't know. Sorry.0 -
^^^ Yeah, I don't know where this summer vacation thing comes from though I'm sure some teachers, in some districts actually take the summer and go play tennis and loll on some Caribbean Island. Good for them, I guess. But what do I know? The idea of summer vacation is but a faded memory of long ago."It's a sad and beautiful world"-Roberto Benigni0
-
are you trying to deny that schools are closed in the summers?brianlux said:^^^ Yeah, I don't know where this summer vacation thing comes from though I'm sure some teachers, in some districts actually take the summer and go play tennis and loll on some Caribbean Island. Good for them, I guess. But what do I know? The idea of summer vacation is but a faded memory of long ago.
0 -
To cut costs, my school district eliminated summer pay three years ago, leaving it to us to manage our own savings from our salary divided by 10 instead of 12. Our last paycheck is June 30 and then we don't see another one until September 30. I have $175 dollars left to get me through the end of September. I blame it on Pearl Jam.brianlux said:^^^ Yeah, I don't know where this summer vacation thing comes from though I'm sure some teachers, in some districts actually take the summer and go play tennis and loll on some Caribbean Island. Good for them, I guess. But what do I know? The idea of summer vacation is but a faded memory of long ago.
0 -
Not sure about where you live but here in Colorado a lot of schools are open for summer programs, summer school, administration issues, etc.pjhawks said:
Every teacher I know works during the summer.....
Summer school
Summer camps
Private tutoring
Etc0 -
they don't have to work those and get paid extra for those things. it is not part of their regular pay, at least in my area and for every teacher i know that is the case.Bentleyspop said:
Every teacher I know works during the summer.....
Summer school
Summer camps
Private tutoring
Etc0 -
It seems many are stuck on my saying leave at 2:40. They missed the words "on most days" in patentheses.
This summer, I worked five paid days at school at a significantly reduced hourly wage (not my per diem) helping administrators plan our teacher leadership training. I'm in charge of the training on grading, after spending last year as the school rep on the division's policy revision committee, which I only did because 1) my principal appointed me because she said I would bring a common sense perspective, and 2) they paid me extra -- but not much -- to sit through those deadly meetings listening to teachers argue about all the wrong things. Common sense (mostly) prevailed.
I worked four July days planning my department-wide calendar for the year and one August afternoon meeting with another department chair about various school programs.
I had my 8th grade teachers over for dinner at the beginning of August. We had a four hour meeting to plan our first unit. I have three young teachers in the 8th grade, all three at three years of experience. (Imagine the year they were all brand new.) They are putting in many more hours than I will because they just don't know their stuff yet. Give it a few more. One is already talking about quitting (and then we'll waste money training another one instead of changing things to retain this one). Another wants to have a baby and when her baby is born, those students will be stranded with an unqualified sub for a while, if she even comes back. Many don't, so we recruit and train again.
I will get a $500 stipend next June for being department chair. It will work out to about .000000075 an hour. Since it's technically not free labor, I don't mind, and I enjoy helping new teachers become really great ones.
It is absolutely essential that we solve our human resource problem in education, and I really, really, really wish the public would argue about the right things as well so that common sense prevails.0 -
You mean Common Core, a program that every state and DC has implemented but 4.OffSheGoes35 said:Ok...here is what I would like to know, and I understand if certain people/posters are through with this thread...
1. Free, I would like to know more about the 2 problems you mentioned earlier in the thread. I don't think you ever got a chance to elaborate on those 2 issues you spoke of
"The Common Core is a set of high-quality academic standards in mathematics and English language arts/literacy (ELA). These learning goals outline what a student should know and be able to do at the end of each grade."
Common core is single handedly dismantling education in the states, after GWB instituted No Child Left Behind and then Obama kept it. Common core has teachers hands tied of real teaching kids, enforces teachers to teach to the test all year, and in my state, dictates teachers performance (which is unfair).
But I am the only one talking about this.Post edited by Free on0 -
PJHawks...
Earlier, I went through the task of making the following comparison for you. Did you note anything? You should have noted days worked compared to pay. Do you remember when you kept insisting all other professions work a minimum of 50 days more and therefore get paid more?
Province of BC:
Nurse entry wage (excluding OT) $63,000
Teacher entry wage $44,000
Nurse max wage (excluding OT) $99,000
Teacher max wage $83,000
Nurse days of work 3-4 days per week... opportunities for OT... plus holidays (52 weeks X 3.5 days= 183 days)
Teachers days of work as per collective agreement 187 per year
* I'm thankful our nurses get what they do. They offer a wonderful service to us and I appreciate them and the stresses and challenges they face on a daily basis. I'm not offering this comparison for any other reason than to model for PJHawks a useful comparison for discussion's sake.
** Information taken from government PDF files.
"My brain's a good brain!"0 -
Pjhawks, I just have to get it out there on the table. Whenever I hear people stuck on the summer issue, it always seems to me to come from a place of bitter jealousy.pjhawks said:
Same thing with the pension. I just got back from a visit to a cousin who retired in June from the NYC school system, riddled with stress-related health problems. She recounted several bitter conversations she had with near strangers about her pension. This is a woman who at retirement, was honored by the local NAACP chapter as Music Educator of the Year because of how she helped her poor community. Thousands if her students were invited regularly to sing the Star Spangled Banner at Yankee games. She got instruments into the hands of thousands of kids who would never touch one if it hadn't been for her. They were all bawling their eyes out when they sang at her retirement party. She served our nation for so many years, sacrificed her health along the way, and she will not be floating on a yacht with her retirement pension. She'll be holed up in a small house in western PA getting her health back that teaching took from her.
Here's the thing . .if anybody wants our salary, our benefits, our vacation plan, our pension . . . They are welcome to join the service. If people are not willing to join the service, then at least appreciate those who do. We make the sacrifice because we love kids and we love our country.
Notice I never once in this thread have complained about my salary. I've simply stated facts about my choices. I will continue to make choices. I will get by on my last 175 dollars until Sept 30. My complaint is with the seemingly bitter people who dismiss the difficult choice we make, based on narrow reporting about problems in the profession. It just doesn't help solve the problem by dismissing it.0 -
Are you kidding, rather than admit Summer's off are a perk, you're going to twist it to make Hawks look jealous... for stating the obvious!!!what dreams said:
Same thing with the pension. I just got back from a visit to a cousin who retired in June from the NYC school system, riddled with stress-related health problems. She recounted several bitter conversations she had with near strangers about her pension. This is a woman who at retirement, was honored by the local NAACP chapter as Music Educator of the Year because of how she helped her poor community. Thousands if her students were invited regularly to sing the Star Spangled Banner at Yankee games. She got instruments into the hands of thousands of kids who would never touch one if it hadn't been for her. They were all bawling their eyes out when they sang at her retirement party. She served our nation for so many years, sacrificed her health along the way, and she will not be floating on a yacht with her retirement pension. She'll be holed up in a small house in western PA getting her health back that teaching took from her.
Here's the thing . .if anybody wants our salary, our benefits, our vacation plan, our pension . . . They are welcome to join the service. If people are not willing to join the service, then at least appreciate those who do. We make the sacrifice because we love kids and we love our country.
Notice I never once in this thread have complained about my salary. I've simply stated facts about my choices. I will continue to make choices. I will get by on my last 175 dollars until Sept 30. My complaint is with the seemingly bitter people who dismiss the difficult choice we make, based on narrow reporting about problems in the profession. It just doesn't help solve the problem by dismissing it.
Teachers here, for every extracurricular after school coaching or enrichment or anything, they get paid extra. They go on a field trip that takes longer than the school day? Extra pay.
Your friend retiring from NYC? W/ a pension? Big bucks right there. Sorry about the health issues but those are facts. Who gets pensions any more? She is very lucky. That's teachers unions. And you did say you made close to 100k, while specifying your contract allows you to leave at 2:40 most days.0 -
A+what dreams said:
Same thing with the pension. I just got back from a visit to a cousin who retired in June from the NYC school system, riddled with stress-related health problems. She recounted several bitter conversations she had with near strangers about her pension. This is a woman who at retirement, was honored by the local NAACP chapter as Music Educator of the Year because of how she helped her poor community. Thousands if her students were invited regularly to sing the Star Spangled Banner at Yankee games. She got instruments into the hands of thousands of kids who would never touch one if it hadn't been for her. They were all bawling their eyes out when they sang at her retirement party. She served our nation for so many years, sacrificed her health along the way, and she will not be floating on a yacht with her retirement pension. She'll be holed up in a small house in western PA getting her health back that teaching took from her.
Here's the thing . .if anybody wants our salary, our benefits, our vacation plan, our pension . . . They are welcome to join the service. If people are not willing to join the service, then at least appreciate those who do. We make the sacrifice because we love kids and we love our country.
Notice I never once in this thread have complained about my salary. I've simply stated facts about my choices. I will continue to make choices. I will get by on my last 175 dollars until Sept 30. My complaint is with the seemingly bitter people who dismiss the difficult choice we make, based on narrow reporting about problems in the profession. It just doesn't help solve the problem by dismissing it.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 148.8K Pearl Jam's Music and Activism
- 110K The Porch
- 274 Vitalogy
- 35K Given To Fly (live)
- 3.5K Words and Music...Communication
- 39.1K Flea Market
- 39.1K Lost Dogs
- 58.7K Not Pearl Jam's Music
- 10.6K Musicians and Gearheads
- 29.1K Other Music
- 17.8K Poetry, Prose, Music & Art
- 1.1K The Art Wall
- 56.7K Non-Pearl Jam Discussion
- 22.2K A Moving Train
- 31.7K All Encompassing Trip
- 2.9K Technical Stuff and Help