A GAME OF THRONES - Discussion Thread

JK_Livin · June 2013

pjsteelerfan wrote:

no way. but roslin knew. and as catelyn thought.. it was a most joyless wedding... for good reason as it turned out.

Who is roslin?[/quote]

Walter Freys daughter that married Edmure[/quote]

Thanks. I don't recall hearing her name. How do you know she knew? Maybe I shouldn't be asking that.

Better Dan · June 2013

JK_Livin wrote:

pjsteelerfan wrote:

no way. but roslin knew. and as catelyn thought.. it was a most joyless wedding... for good reason as it turned out.

Who is roslin?

Walter Freys daughter that married Edmure[/quote]

Thanks. I don't recall hearing her name. How do you know she knew? Maybe I shouldn't be asking that.[/quote]

Hope this isn't a spoiler, but wasn't she crying/sad in the book throughout the wedding? Haven't read it, but I think I read something like that in a forum.

Don't think it's really that major of a plot point so hopefully no one gets upset that I posted it, especially since we're past that moment in the show.

pjsteelerfan · June 2013

Better Dan wrote:

JK_Livin wrote:

pjsteelerfan wrote:

no way. but roslin knew. and as catelyn thought.. it was a most joyless wedding... for good reason as it turned out.

Who is roslin?

Walter Freys daughter that married Edmure

Thanks. I don't recall hearing her name. How do you know she knew? Maybe I shouldn't be asking that.[/quote]

Hope this isn't a spoiler, but wasn't she crying/sad in the book throughout the wedding? Haven't read it, but I think I read something like that in a forum.

Don't think it's really that major of a plot point so hopefully no one gets upset that I posted it, especially since we're past that moment in the show.[/quote]

I don't think it is a spoiler now that it has happened. I would think people assumed all of house Frey was in on it. My guess is more of what transpired behind the wedding will be explained in the season finale to answer non book readers questions.

ldent42 · June 2013

http://www.happyplace.com/24297/game-of-thrones-facebook-recap-season-3-episode-9

intodeep · June 2013

duska3419 wrote:

http://www.happyplace.com/24297/game-of-thrones-facebook-recap-season-3-episode-9

i read these almost every week they are alwasy great! i had not seen this weeks yet though and it was awesome

ldent42 · June 2013

intodeep wrote:

duska3419 wrote:

http://www.happyplace.com/24297/game-of-thrones-facebook-recap-season-3-episode-9

i read these almost every week they are alwasy great! i had not seen this weeks yet though and it was awesome

just found this on facebook now i'm reading all the old ones lol I'm dying laughing

Hugh Freaking Dillon · June 2013

catefrances wrote:

Hugh Freaking Dillon wrote:

rearviewross wrote:

Do you think the wolf was going crazy because it knew Rob was in trouble or because it could smell Arya. I thought it was because of Arya.

I think it was because it knew Rob was in trouble. I doubt it smelled Arya....unless she had just started her "bleeding".

uncalled for.

I got it from the show!

catefrances · June 2013

Hugh Freaking Dillon wrote:

catefrances wrote:

Hugh Freaking Dillon wrote:

I think it was because it knew Rob was in trouble. I doubt it smelled Arya....unless she had just started her "bleeding".

uncalled for.

I got it from the show!

still uncalled for... by whoever said it.. and im guessing its a man. :P

pjradio · June 2013

catefrances wrote:

Hugh Freaking Dillon wrote:

rearviewross wrote:

Do you think the wolf was going crazy because it knew Rob was in trouble or because it could smell Arya. I thought it was because of Arya.

I think it was because it knew Rob was in trouble. I doubt it smelled Arya....unless she had just started her "bleeding".

uncalled for.

ridiculous reaction....Like Hugh mentioned, they talked about it on the show!.....you're taking these made up, fantasy stories WAYYYY to seriously

catefrances · June 2013

pjradio wrote:

catefrances wrote:

Hugh Freaking Dillon wrote:

I think it was because it knew Rob was in trouble. I doubt it smelled Arya....unless she had just started her "bleeding".

uncalled for.

ridiculous reaction....Like Hugh mentioned, they talked about it on the show!.....you're taking these made up, fantasy stories WAYYYY to seriously

no its not a ridiculous reaction... im just tired of 'joking' comments about 'women being on the rag'. that's all. its like drunken idiots saying "whats the matter you a lesbian?' or being called a dyke when you decline their oh so polite offer of hooking up. I do however understand the context in which it was said.. doesn't mean I have to llke it tho. boorish men are a bore.

ldent42 · June 2013

pjradio wrote:

catefrances wrote:

Hugh Freaking Dillon wrote:

I think it was because it knew Rob was in trouble. I doubt it smelled Arya....unless she had just started her "bleeding".

uncalled for.

ridiculous reaction....Like Hugh mentioned, they talked about it on the show!.....you're taking these made up, fantasy stories WAYYYY to seriously

i'm no expert but im pretty sure mocking a child over a likely future life-changing biological event is in fact, uncalled for. particularly in the context of being smelled by a wolf.
The joking in the show not so much.

catefrances · June 2013

I don't want this thread to be derailed by something I find boorish. it was said, I didn't like it, i said so... lets move on. this really isn't the thread to hash out mens attitudes towards women.

rearviewross · June 2013

Very curious to see what John Snow will do next. The whole scene with Dani and the siege was very anticlimactic. I was really thinking there would be a big battle.

catefrances · June 2013

rearviewross wrote:

Very curious to see what John Snow will do next. The whole scene with Dani and the siege was very anticlimactic. I was really thinking there would be a big battle.

want me to tell you?

shep · June 2013

holy fucking crap.

just got to watch the episode tonight.

I knew the scene was coming the whole episode, and was on the edge of my seat...

even though it wasn't anywhere near as gruesome as the book, that was still something to see... definitely going to have to watch it again...

time for bed now... we'll talk more tomorrow.

PearlJamaholic · June 2013

Get over yourselves with the bleeding joke. Some people are too touchy. Youre watching a show that has murder, torture, and rape, and you wanna cause a stink about reference joke based on that show, in a thread discussing yet again that same show.

The reaction to the 'bleeding' joke is even funnier. You just look like a spoiled hypocritical brat....'oh that offends me what you said but every week i watch a show where babies could get killed and i find that entertaining.'

intodeep · June 2013

http://teamcoco.com/video/conan-highlight-red-wedding-reactions

GRRM watches the youtube video with Conan with fans reacting to the red wedding :corn:

I know Neil Gaimen told us long ago GRRM is not our bitch, but i can't help it everytime i see him out on the publicity circuit i want to ask him why are you not writing winds of winter

catefrances · June 2013

PearlJamaholic wrote:

Get over yourselves with the bleeding joke. Some people are too touchy. Youre watching a show that has murder, torture, and rape, and you wanna cause a stink about reference joke based on that show, in a thread discussing yet again that same show.

The reaction to the 'bleeding' joke is even funnier. You just look like a spoiled hypocritical brat....'oh that offends me what you said but every week i watch a show where babies could get killed and i find that entertaining.'

on what show do babies get killed every week? cause whatever that show is, if it indeed exists... and the news does not count.

...i am unaware of it. as for being a spoiled hypocritical brat.... all I can say is come sit by my side and you will soon discover how flimsy that perception is.

the fact that you called it 'the bleeding joke' tells me you are unaware of the insidiousness of pejorative language directed towards women and excused as humour.

catefrances · June 2013

intodeep wrote:

http://teamcoco.com/video/conan-highlight-red-wedding-reactions

GRRM watches the youtube video with Conan with fans reacting to the red wedding :corn:

I know Neil Gaimen told us long ago GRRM is not our bitch, but i can't help it everytime.....i see him out on the publicity circuit i want to ask him why are you not writing winds of winter

yes.. why isn't he writing. I don't want to rush him and risk the next book being a pile of shit but im sitting idle in the world of westeros waiting... waiting for the continuance of a story im deeply engrossed in. all I n say is thank goodness for my imagination and my faith in jon snow.

F Me In The Brain · June 2013

intodeep wrote:

http://teamcoco.com/video/conan-highlight-red-wedding-reactions

GRRM watches the youtube video with Conan with fans reacting to the red wedding :corn:

I know Neil Gaimen told us long ago GRRM is not our bitch, but i can't help it everytime i see him out on the publicity circuit i want to ask him why are you not writing winds of winter

I used to laugh when he would occasionally post his updates on Dances, basically telling people he was working as quickly as he could and to please stop asking. Now he is so busy I dont know how the poor guy will find the time to sleep with all of the editing, writing, traveling, signing, interviewing, etc.
Good for him; just hope everyone keeps watching and he can write ahead of the show so that we can see all of what he wants to play out in the books also play out on the screen.

A GAME OF THRONES - Discussion Thread

Comments

Categories