Options

This is not a job Israel can finish by massacring civilians.

ByrnzieByrnzie Posts: 21,037
edited July 2006 in A Moving Train
Merhi Rima: The world has to stop this slaughter if a democratic Lebanon is to have a future
Israel has led my country into destruction and my people into a humanitarian emergency

Published: 31 July 2006


Where are America and Britain now that we need them? Not that they listened to us last July, when I testified to the US Congress on the aspirations of the youth of Lebanon for national reform. I remember the moment when I cried out in sheer frustration: "Hizbollah, Hizbollah, Hizbollah - there is more to Lebanon than Hizbollah!"

Apparently not, at least not for Israel and the United States. "There is a limit to how far the Lebanese are willing to forgo their security and stability for the sake of reform," I told Congress. The tragic massacre at Qana yesterday is a clear demonstration to the US and the world of Israel's "measured response".

In complete disgust, I listened to one speaker yesterday on the BBC make the offensively racist remark that "Israelis are raised in a more human way than Arabs" while urging Lebanese mothers to not allow Hizbollah to use them as human shields. If she was a mother she would know that no mother in the world would risk her own child's life for any purpose in the world. In the name of "reform", "democracy" and "the war against terror", Israel, backed by the US, has led my country into destruction and my people into a humanitarian crisis. We are numb with despair on hearing Israel admit it is nowhere near achieving its military objectives against Hizbollah! Israel's responsibility does not begin and end with the security of its people, so long as it is party to conventions and treaties on international and humanitarian law.

No one will dispute that Israel is no more secure today than it was 19 days ago. Both Israel and Hizbollah have been accused of war crimes and must be tried by the international community at large. The whole world is outraged by Israel's disproportionate response. The attack on UN premises in Beirut yesterday morning is a desperate cry for help in a world where we feel abandoned by the international community at large, including our Arab neighbours.

With the support of my colleagues and professors, I made a speech on Lebanon at Oxford University last week. I was secretly amused to note that some colleagues may have had the illusion that Hizbollah is a terrorist dressed in black carrying a bomb and living every minute of every day with the sole intent of destroying Israel and the US.

I dread to think that many Israelis and Americans, among others, cannot see that the vast majority of Arabs simply call for respect of the Palestinian cause, while sharing the same humanity, dreams, fears and expectations for a lasting peace. I notice that the western media fails to inform the public of the underprivileged Shia living in abysmal conditions in the south of Lebanon, who are loyal to Hizbollah for no more than their bread and butter.

Last year, through democratic elections, the Lebanese government awarded 14 seats to Hizbollah in an attempt to integrate this isolated Shia community into the mainstream and build their allegiance to the Lebanese state. I reminded my colleagues that Hizbollah was established in 1982, after the Israeli invasion of Lebanon and the 18-year occupation of the south of Lebanon that granted Hizbollah the legitimacy to continue their operations against Israel on the Lebanese-Israeli border. When Israel withdrew from the south of Lebanon in 2000, conditions for a sustainable peace were not met. The Lebanese government urged the international community to no avail to empower it to disarm Hizbollah by resolving the dispute over the Sheba farms and the safe return of not two but hundreds of prisoners of war who have been thrown in Israeli prisons for more than 20 years.

As more flyers depicting Nasralah as a serpent fall on Lebanese territory together with the bombs that are wiping out whole villages, it is not surprising that Hizbollah is gaining momentum once again. The fingers that were pointing at Syria for the assassination of Hariri are now slowly shifting to assess Israel's involvement in Lebanon's turbulent domestic affairs.

The Israeli invasion of Lebanon is crippling a nascent democracy that only recently gained independence from Syria with the potential to become, in the words of President Bush only four months ago, "a beacon of democracy in the Middle East". I admit I am neither a shrewd politician nor an experienced diplomat - but I can clearly see that Israel and the US are working against their agenda for Lebanon and the "New Middle East", however they come to define it.

I would like to remind the international community that we are the same youth that put an end to the Syrian occupation of Lebanon in compliance with our Peace Accord of 1991, and in the light of yesterday's massacre we are calling for an immediate unconditional ceasefire that will pave the way for diplomatic negotiations of a lasting nature with all parties to the conflict, including Hizbollah and Iran. This may well be a long and complicated diplomatic mission that will require top-notch mediation, diplomacy and dialogue. This is not a job that Israel can finish by massacring civilians.

I want the youth back home to know that I feel their anger, pain and frustration. I want them to remember that we scored a legendary victory two months ago when the government approved the proposal for the establishment of a youth government that will give us a real voice in the country. Use this medium to make yourself heard and make yourself available in any way you can. Our country needs us now more than ever. I worry many have started to go online searching for jobs outside Lebanon, at a time when there are opportunities for social and humanitarian work back home.

Organise locally to feed the hungry, take care of the injured with the Red Cross, volunteer with non-governmental organisations and give your unconditional support to the UN, especially in the light of yesterday's attack. They are all on our side. They are condemning the attack on innocent civilians on both sides and calling for an immediate ceasefire. I swear I would rather be in Beirut right now, sweeping the rubble with my bare hands and clearing the dust than living as a refugee in a foreign land. They can destroy our homes and kill our people, but they can never take our education from us. They can never break our will, either. United, active, and ambitious we will force the US Congress and the whole world to hear our cry for peace, justice and freedom.

The writer is a youth activist in Lebanon currently studying at a summer course in Oxford
Post edited by Unknown User on

Comments

  • Options
    miller8966miller8966 Posts: 1,452
    Israel is the best thing to ever happen to the middle east
    America...the greatest Country in the world.
  • Options
    ByrnzieByrnzie Posts: 21,037
    miller8966 wrote:
    Israel is the best thing to ever happen to the middle east

    Please elaborate. I'm sure I'm not the only one who would be fascinated to hear what you mean by the above. I'm sure you will present us with your typical justifications for Israeli terrorism, but you are welcome to attempt to surprise me.
  • Options
    Puck78Puck78 Posts: 737
    yes, and overall explain to us how you relate it to the article of the topic.
    www.amnesty.org
    www.amnesty.org.uk
  • Options
    ilanailana Posts: 78
    miller8966 wrote:
    Israel is the best thing to ever happen to the middle east
    its not so much that israel is the best thing that happend in the middle east, its the only good thing that has ever happent in the middle east.
  • Options
    thankyougrandmathankyougrandma Posts: 1,182
    ilana wrote:
    its not so much that israel is the best thing that happend in the middle east, its the only good thing that has ever happent in the middle east.

    :eek:
    speechless...........
    "L'homme est né libre, et partout il est dans les fers"
    -Jean-Jacques Rousseau
  • Options
    The fact that some of you guys actually believe the crap you are spouting is the reason the world is going to hell in a handcart. The fact you won't or can't elaborate your views says so much about you.
  • Options
    jsandjsand Posts: 646
    Byrnzie wrote:
    Merhi Rima: The world has to stop this slaughter if a democratic Lebanon is to have a future
    Israel has led my country into destruction and my people into a humanitarian emergency

    Israel has led your country into destruction?! HAHAHAHAA. What a ridiculous statement. Don't blame the terrorist organization that uses you and your fellow citizens as human shields while it fires rockets at civilians in Israel. That would make way too much sense.
  • Options
    ByrnzieByrnzie Posts: 21,037
    jsand wrote:
    Israel has led your country into destruction?! HAHAHAHAA. What a ridiculous statement. Don't blame the terrorist organization that uses you and your fellow citizens as human shields while it fires rockets at civilians in Israel. That would make way too much sense.

    Try reading the article before commenting on it. I quote:

    "I dread to think that many Israelis and Americans, among others, cannot see that the vast majority of Arabs simply call for respect of the Palestinian cause, while sharing the same humanity, dreams, fears and expectations for a lasting peace."

    This began when Hizbollah decided that enough was enough with regards Israels re-occupation of Gaza and it's continuing terrorising of the Palestinian people, and so stood up in solidairity with them. This should not have been seen by Israel as a green light to destroy Lebanon and massacre hundreds of civilians. At least not if Israel has any regard whatsoever for international law, which it has shown it doesn't. Perhaps Hizbollah should have ignored the plight of the palestinians, just as we in the West have been doing for decades? Isn't it about time that someone stood up for up the Palestinians? If by doing so the country that harbours them deserves to be obliterated then what hope for Israel ever to achieve peace and security in the region? They are behaving like an out-of-control pariah. How can this benefit them in the long term?
  • Options
    jsandjsand Posts: 646
    Byrnzie wrote:
    Try reading the article before commenting on it. I quote:

    "I dread to think that many Israelis and Americans, among others, cannot see that the vast majority of Arabs simply call for respect of the Palestinian cause, while sharing the same humanity, dreams, fears and expectations for a lasting peace."

    This began when Hizbollah decided that enough was enough with regards Israels re-occupation of Gaza and it's continuing terrorising of the Palestinian people, and so stood up in solidairity with them. This should not have been seen by Israel as a green light to destroy Lebanon and massacre hundreds of civilians. At least not if Israel has any regard whatsoever for international law, which it has shown it doesn't. Perhaps Hizbollah should have ignored the plight of the palestinians, just as we in the West have been doing for decades? Isn't it about time that someone stood up for up the Palestinians? If by doing so the country that harbours them deserves to be obliterated then what hope for Israel ever to achieve peace and security in the region? They are behaving like an out-of-control pariah. How can this benefit them in the long term?

    Oh...they're standing up for the Palestinians. They're excused then. They should feel free to kill Israeli civilians and use Lebanese citizens as human shields. Sorry.
  • Options
    ByrnzieByrnzie Posts: 21,037
    jsand wrote:
    Oh...they're standing up for the Palestinians. They're excused then. They should feel free to kill Israeli civilians and use Lebanese citizens as human shields. Sorry.

    Whilst Israel muders Palestinians with impunity which is the norm. (Whoops, sorry, Palestinains don't count, right?)
    There are ways to deal with aggression. Firstly, stop particpating in it by continuing an illegal military occupation. Then if you are attacked by someone you have legitimate recourse to call on the international community to stop those responsible, put an end to hostilities, and bring those responsible to justice. This would then prevent an entire country from being devastated with masssive and disproportionate loss of life.
  • Options
    thankyougrandmathankyougrandma Posts: 1,182
    jsand wrote:
    Oh...they're standing up for the Palestinians. They're excused then. They should feel free to kill Israeli civilians and use Lebanese citizens as human shields. Sorry.

    Even the Israel govt. said it was an horrible mistake and they share the blame with Hezbollah, what is YOUR point?

    Your disc might be dirty, cause it's skipping...
    "L'homme est né libre, et partout il est dans les fers"
    -Jean-Jacques Rousseau
  • Options
    ByrnzieByrnzie Posts: 21,037
    Even the Israel govt. said it was an horrible mistake and they share the blame with Hezbollah

    Really? When? Where? My ears have pricked up!
  • Options
    thankyougrandmathankyougrandma Posts: 1,182
    Byrnzie wrote:
    Really? When? Where? My ears have pricked up!

    i think it was the Isreal UN ambassador, or the USA Israel ambassador, or i don't know, i've heard it somewhere and on multiple occasion. Just last night.
    "L'homme est né libre, et partout il est dans les fers"
    -Jean-Jacques Rousseau
  • Options
    jsandjsand Posts: 646
    Byrnzie wrote:
    Whilst Israel muders Palestinians with impunity which is the norm. (Whoops, sorry, Palestinains don't count, right?)
    There are ways to deal with aggression. Firstly, stop particpating in it by continuing an illegal military occupation. Then if you are attacked by someone you have legitimate recourse to call on the international community to stop those responsible, put an end to hostilities, and bring those responsible to justice. This would then prevent an entire country from being devastated with masssive and disproportionate loss of life.

    Oh yeah. Just like when Israel ended the "occupation" in Gaza - and hamas and other terror groups proceeded to launch rocket attacls on Israel. The international community was a big help there.

    By the way, how did you and this "youth activist" extrapolate that Hezbollah was standing up for the Palestinians? That asshole Nasrallah claims that the Hezbollah attack that started this latest round of violence was aimed at freeing Lebanese prisoners [read: terrorists] from Israeli jails.
  • Options
    jsandjsand Posts: 646
    Even the Israel govt. said it was an horrible mistake and they share the blame with Hezbollah, what is YOUR point?

    Your disc might be dirty, cause it's skipping...

    If the Israeli government did say that, which is highly unlikely, then I disagree with them too.

    Yes, my "disc is dirty"...
Sign In or Register to comment.