Options

Challenge: Create a concert from ONLY songs you've seen & in the exact place they were played!

merlin401merlin401 Posts: 216
Here’s a fun challenge for the hard core touring fan if you’re up for it. Your mission is to create your ideal Pearl Jam concert playlist from the concerts you’ve actually been to. The real hard part is you MUST use the songs in the same position they were in in those concerts. So if you only saw In Hiding once, and it was played 8th in the first set, that’s where it must be used. Since set sizes vary, set CLOSERS don’t have the follow the number location, but just have been your concert’s set closers. You can make your sets and encores as big or small as you want, but they have to follow that rule. Also two more conditions:

#1: It must have exactly 32 songs (tags don’t count)
#2: It must include at least half of the core Pearl Jam songs, which I’ll call the Dirty Dozen (I used songs that have been played at approximately 60% or more Pearl Jam concerts ever including Do The Evolution, Alive, Even Flow, Jeremy, Black, Daughter, Small Town, Corduroy, Given to Fly, Porch, Better Man and Rearviewmirror)

MAIN SET:

1. Wash ……(Mansfield II, 2008)
2. Breakerfall …… (Jones Beach II, 2000)
3. Corduroy…… (couple times here)
4. Go …… (Holmdel, 2003)
5. Animal…… (many times here)
6. Faithful…… (MSG I, 2008)
7. In Hiding…… (East Rutherford II, 2006)
8. Hold On…… (Philly III, 2009)
9. In My Tree…… (alternate version, played Holmdel 2003)
10. Unemployable…… (Camden I, 2006)
11. Deep…… (Philly III, 2009)
12. Not For You…… (Camden I, 2006)
13. Daughter/It’s OK…… (awesome version from Jones Beach II, 2000)
14. Rats…… (East Rutherford II, 2006)
15. Insignificance…… (Jones Beach II, 2000)
CLOSE: Rearviewmirror…… (Philly I, 2003)

ENCORE 1:

1. Of the Girl…… (Prague, 2012)
2. Hard to Imagine…… (East Rutherford II, 2006)
3. Lukin…… (slow version, MSG II, 2010)
4. Breath…… (Philly III, 2009)
5. Crown of Thorns…… (Gorge I, 2006)
6. Love Reign O’er Me…… (MSG I, 2010; great version!)
CLOSE: Alive…… (used a bunch of times here)

ENCORE 2:

1. Jeremy…… (MSG I, 2010)
2. Better Man/SIFL…… (MSG II, 2010 including awesome sing along/pause & cheer)
3. Leash…… (Philly II, 2016)
4. Comatose…… (Gorge II, 2006)
5. Dirty Frank…… (Gorge I, 2006)
6. Fuckin’ Up…… (Phily I, 2016)
7. Kick Out the Jams…… (MSG II, 2010)
8. Smile…… (Philly IV, 2009)
CLOSE: Yellow Ledbetter…… (many times but I’ll use Philly II, 2009 to get one from each concert)


Things that made this hard: two of my better concerts were hard to fit in. Philly II this year was awesome but with playing Ten in order, the best songs were in very weird places and/or dramatic for reasons specific to the set. Philly IV was epic but with such a ridiculously long set, it was impossible to get to things like “Out of My Mind” in there. As it was I really had to stretch my second encore to squeeze Smile in there. Also a lot of my favorite stuff ended up 3rd in first encore or 11th in the main set which was unfortunate. Lastly 5th was a dead zone… got stuck with Animal which is fine but there wasn’t much exciting to choose from.

BTW: Bonus points: I used at least 1 song from each of my 17 shows! Well that was fun, and difficult... wonder if anyone else is up for the challenge...
Jones Beach II (2000), Holmdel (2003), Camden 1, East Rutherford II, Gorge I, Gorge II (2006), MSG I, Boston II (2008), Spectrum II, Spectrum III, Spectrum IV (2009), MSG I, MSG II (2010), Prague (2012), Philly I (2013), Philly I, Philly II, Fenway I (2016), Fenway I (2018), MSG (2022)
«1

Comments

  • Options
    bootlegger10bootlegger10 Posts: 15,532
    Wow, hard work. If I can find some time I will try it.
  • Options
    jessebasijessebasi Toronto Posts: 149
    Having only seen the two 2016 Toronto shows, it's still hard, but here's my (not entirely exact) setlist:

    Go (Night 1)
    Corduroy (Night 2)
    MYM (Both nights)
    Brain of J (Night 2)
    Animal (Night 2)
    Garden (Night 2)
    Light Years (Night 1)
    Nothingman (Night 2)
    Cropduster (Night 2)
    Insignificance (Night 1)
    Of the Girl (Night 1)
    Green Disease (Night 2)
    Rival (Night 1)
    Present Tense (Night 2)
    Alone (Night 2)
    Lightning Bolt (Night 2)
    Do the Evolution (Night 2)
    Once (Night 1)
    RVM (Night 1)

    Oceans (Night 2)
    Let Me Sleep (Night 1)
    Breath (Night 2)
    Even Flow (Night 1)
    Better Man (Night 1)
    Porch (Both nights)

    Small Town (Night 1)
    Last Exit (Night 2)
    State of Love and Trust (Night 1)
    Crazy Mary (Night 2)
    Black (Both Nights)
    Alive (Both Nights)
    Yellow Ledbetter (Night 2)
    2016 - Toronto I (Binaural!), Toronto II
    2020 - Toronto, Hamilton
  • Options
    merlin401merlin401 Posts: 216
    Ha, you picked two damn good shows to start off with! Nice to have every song off Binaural at your disposal in the first set ;)
    Jones Beach II (2000), Holmdel (2003), Camden 1, East Rutherford II, Gorge I, Gorge II (2006), MSG I, Boston II (2008), Spectrum II, Spectrum III, Spectrum IV (2009), MSG I, MSG II (2010), Prague (2012), Philly I (2013), Philly I, Philly II, Fenway I (2016), Fenway I (2018), MSG (2022)
  • Options
    LiftedLifted Posts: 1,623
    I'll do my best

    1. Release (Pittsburgh '06)
    2. Go (Camden 2 '06)
    3. Save you (lollapalooza '07)
    4. Spin the black circle (philly '05)
    5. Do the evolution (pittsburgh '06)
    6. Faithful (msg 2 0'08)
    7. Alone (philly '05)
    8. Hold on (philly 3 '09)
    9. Grievance (camden 2 '06)
    10. Insignificance (bristow '10)
    11. Mfc (philly 2 '13)
    12. Long road (hampton '16)
    13. I got shit (pittsburgh '06)
    14. State of love and trust (lolla '07)
    15. Present tense (msg 2 '08)
    16. Jeremy (camden 1 '06)
    17. Why go (camden 1 '08)
    18. Rearviewmirror (hampton '16)

    Encore 1
    1. W.m.a. (bonnaroo '08)
    2. Hard to imagine (e. Rutherford 2 '06)
    3. Glorified g (hershey '03)
    4. Crown of thorns (philly '05)
    5. Breath (philly 2 '13)
    6. Alive (philly '05)
    7. Given to fly (charlottesville '13)
    8. Porch (philly 2 '13)

    Encore 2

    1. Footsteps (camden 2 '08)
    2. Crazy mary (msg2 '08)
    3. Leash (philly 2 '16)
    4. Sonic reducer (bristow '10)
    5. Little Wing (charlottesville '13)
    6. Baba o'riley (cincy '06)

    That'd be pretty epic. Not sure whether or not i was able to incorporate all 20 shows Ive attended, but i tried.
  • Options
    cutzcutz Posts: 11,422
    Man, i'm only at 5 songs and i'm stir-crazy already>LOL

    At the rate i'm going it may take me a Month to complete this, maybe longer>LOL
  • Options
    goldrushgoldrush everybody knows this is nowhere Posts: 7,274
    edited May 2016
    This is a pretty cool idea. I'll definitely give it a go later, although I can already think of some conflicts that I'll struggle to decide on (this post is just to remind me!)
    Post edited by goldrush on
    “Do not postpone happiness”
    (Jeff Tweedy, Sydney 2007)

    “Put yer good money on the sunrise”
    (Tim Rogers)
  • Options
    PapPap Aspra Spitia, Greece Posts: 28,228
    edited May 2016
    1) Go (Athens 30/09/06)
    2) Animal (Athens 30/09/06)
    3) Life Wasted (Athens 30/09/06)
    4) Hail Hail (Athens 30/09/06)
    5) Corduroy (Athens 30/09/06)
    6) Brain Of J (Milton Keynes 11/07/14)
    7) Comatose (Milton Keynes 11/07/14)
    8) Save You (Milton Keynes 11/07/14)
    9) Given To Fly (Athens 30/09/06)
    10) Marker In The Sand (Athens 30/09/06)
    11) Sad (Athens 30/09/06)
    12) Even Flow (Athens 30/09/06)
    13) Daughter (Athens 30/09/06)
    14) You Are (Athens 30/09/06)
    15) Wishlist (Athens 30/09/06)
    16) Sirens (Milton Keynes 11/07/14)
    17) Jeremy (Athens 30/09/06)
    18) Better Man (Athens 30/09/06)

    Encore Break 1

    19) Footsteps (Athens 30/09/06)
    20) I Am Mine (Athens 30/09/06)
    21) Inside Job (Athens 30/09/06)
    22) Black (Athens 30/09/06)
    23) Chloe Dancer (Milton Keynes 11/07/14)
    24) Crown Of Thorns (Milton Keynes 11/07/14)
    25) Lukin (Milton Keynes 11/07/14)
    26) Porch (Milton Keynes 11/07/14)

    Encore Break 2

    27) Smile (Athens 30/09/06)
    28) I Believe In Miracles (Athens 30/09/06)
    29) Blood (Milton Keynes 11/07/14)
    30) Alive (Milton Keynes 11/07/14)
    31) Rockin' In The Free World (Athens 30/09/06)
    32) Yellow Ledbetter (Athens 30/09/06)
    Athens 2006 / Milton Keynes 2014 / London 1&2 2022 / Seattle 1 2024 / Dublin 2024 / Manchester 2024 / London 2024
  • Options
    LCLC North Andover, MA Posts: 258
    Great topic. 7-11-03 Mansfield experiment made it a little weird. Begrudgingly, I discounted the acoustic set.

    1. Release - Montreal 9-15-05
    2. Last Exit - Boston 9-28-04
    3. Corduroy - Mansfield - 8-29-00
    4. Ghost - Montreal 6-29-03
    5. Deep - Mansfield 7-2-03
    6. Get Right - Mansfield 7-2-03
    7. Given to Fly - Boston 5-17-10
    8. Faithful - Mansfield 6-28-08
    9. Even Flow - Albany 5-12-06
    10. Present Tense - Boston 9-29-04
    11. Immortality - Mansfield 7-2-03
    12. Push Me, Pull Me - Boston 5-17-10
    13. I Got ID - Mansfield 6-28-08
    14. Green Disease - Boston 5-24-06
    15. Do the Evolution - Montreal 9-15-05
    16. Grievance - Mansfield 7-2-03
    17. Gonna See My Friend - Hartford 5-10-10
    18. Why Go - Boston 5-24-06
    --------------------------------
    19. Man of the Hour - Boston 5-25-06
    20. Masters of War - Boston 5-24-06
    21. Black - Mansfield 6-28-08
    22. Crazy Mary - Ottawa 9-16-05
    23. Rival - Boston 5-17-10
    24. Porch - New York 5-2-16
    -------------------------------
    25. Down - Montreal 9-15-05
    26. Daughter - Ottawa 9-16-05
    27. Jeremy - Mansfield 7-11-03
    28. Leash - Boston 5-25-06
    29. Alive - New York 5-2-16
    ------------------------------
    30. Crown of Thorns - Boston 5-17-10
    31. Life Wasted - Wrigley 7-19-13
    32. Rockin in the Free World - Boston 5-17-10
    8-29-00 Mansfield, 6-29-03 Montreal, 7-2-03 Mansfield, 7-3-03 Mansfield, 7-11-03, Mansfield, 9-28-04 Boston, 9-29-04 Boston, 10-8-04 Kissimmee, 9-15-05 Montreal, 9-16-05 Ottawa, 5-12-06 Albany, 5-13-06 Hartford, 5-24-06 Boston, 5-25-06 Boston, 6-28-08, Mansfield, 6-30-08 Mansfield, 5-15-10 Hartford, 5-17-10 Boston, 7-19-13 Chicago, 10-15-13 Worcester, 5-2-16 New York City, 8-5-16 Boston, 8-7-16 Boston
    EV- 2008, 2011 Boston
  • Options
    2-feign-reluctance2-feign-reluctance TigerTown, USA Posts: 23,141
    You should put this challenge to The Rob.
    www.cluthelee.com
  • Options
    merlin401merlin401 Posts: 216
    Lifted said:

    I'll do my best

    1. Release (Pittsburgh '06)
    2. Go (Camden 2 '06)
    3. Save you (lollapalooza '07)
    4. Spin the black circle (philly '05)
    5. Do the evolution (pittsburgh '06)
    6. Faithful (msg 2 0'08)
    7. Alone (philly '05)
    8. Hold on (philly 3 '09)
    9. Grievance (camden 2 '06)
    10. Insignificance (bristow '10)
    11. Mfc (philly 2 '13)
    12. Long road (hampton '16)
    13. I got shit (pittsburgh '06)
    14. State of love and trust (lolla '07)
    15. Present tense (msg 2 '08)
    16. Jeremy (camden 1 '06)
    17. Why go (camden 1 '08)
    18. Rearviewmirror (hampton '16)

    Encore 1
    1. W.m.a. (bonnaroo '08)
    2. Hard to imagine (e. Rutherford 2 '06)
    3. Glorified g (hershey '03)
    4. Crown of thorns (philly '05)
    5. Breath (philly 2 '13)
    6. Alive (philly '05)
    7. Given to fly (charlottesville '13)
    8. Porch (philly 2 '13)

    Encore 2

    1. Footsteps (camden 2 '08)
    2. Crazy mary (msg2 '08)
    3. Leash (philly 2 '16)
    4. Sonic reducer (bristow '10)
    5. Little Wing (charlottesville '13)
    6. Baba o'riley (cincy '06)

    That'd be pretty epic. Not sure whether or not i was able to incorporate all 20 shows Ive attended, but i tried.

    This is interesting in that we ended using a bunch of the same songs. We also both have CoT/Braeth at 4/5 in 1st encore but opposite order.

    Anyway kudos to your first set: I think the Alone-Hold On-Greivance-Insignificance section would make the board crash and Long Road next to I got ID is a nice touch too :)
    Jones Beach II (2000), Holmdel (2003), Camden 1, East Rutherford II, Gorge I, Gorge II (2006), MSG I, Boston II (2008), Spectrum II, Spectrum III, Spectrum IV (2009), MSG I, MSG II (2010), Prague (2012), Philly I (2013), Philly I, Philly II, Fenway I (2016), Fenway I (2018), MSG (2022)
  • Options
    hurricanezekehurricanezeke Posts: 177
    edited May 2016
    Here goes...
    This got hard at the end b/c I wanted to include a great run from Seattle 2013. That show had 36 songs, so I started running out of options..
    I have one song #33 in my history (YLB) and one song for #36 (also YLB).

    1 Love Boat Captain - Atl 2003
    2 Low Light - 2nd song at Columbia 2008 AND Charlotte 2013
    3 Present Tense - Charlotte 2013
    4 Hail, Hail - Columbia 2008
    5 Grievance - Atlanta 2003
    6 Lightning Bolt - Charlotte 2013
    7 Given to Fly - Seattle 2013
    8 Half Full - Atlanta 2003
    9 Garden - Seattle 2013 (this was incredible)
    10 Rats - Greenville 2016
    11Getaway - Charlotte 2013 (live debut)
    12 Leash - Greenville 2016
    13 In My Tree - Seattle 2013
    14 I Got Shit - Columbia 2008
    15 Unthought Known - Charlotte 2013
    16 Black - Seattle 2013
    17 Let the Records Play - Seattle 2013 AND Greenville 2016
    18 STBC - Seattle 2013 AND Greenville 2016 AGAIN
    19 DTE - Greenville 2016
    _____________
    20 Future Days - Greenville 2016
    21You've Got to Hide Your Love Away - Atlanta 2003
    22 Let Me Sleep - Seattle 2013
    23 Comfortably Numb - Greenville 2016
    24 Daughter - Seattle 2013
    25 Chloe - Seattle 2013
    26 Crown of Thorns - Seattle 2013
    27 Breath - Seattle 2013
    28 SOLAT - Seattle 2013
    29 RVM - Seattle 2013
    (This Seattle run was so INCREDIBLE I included it in full)
    30 Betterman - Greenville 2016
    -----------------------
    31 Got Some - Seattle 2013
    32 Baba - Greenville 2016
    33 YLB - Greenville 2016
    34 Kick out the Jams - Seattle 2013
    35 Eruption - Seattle 2013
    36 (!) - YLB Again - Seattle 2013
    Post edited by hurricanezeke on
    Atlanta 2003
    Columbia 2008
    Charlotte 2013
    Seattle 2013
    Greenville 2016
  • Options
    sclinvillesclinville Posts: 125

    1. Long Road cincy 06
    2. Nothingman cincy 14
    3. of the girl cincy 14
    4. last exit jax 16
    5. all night memphis 14
    6. Corduroy cincy 14
    7. wma greenville 16
    8. even flow cincy 06
    9. rival jax 16
    10. rats greenville 16
    11. love boat captain with jumping jack flash tag cincy 14
    12. not for you with modern girl tag cincy 06
    13. wishlist memphis 14
    14. in the moonlight tampa 16
    15. jeremy tampa 16
    16. spin the black circle memphis 14
    17. blood tampa 16
    18. rear view mirror memphis 14
    --------------------------------
    19. betterman with save it for later tag cincy 06
    20. inside job cincy 06
    21. crazy mary cincy 06
    22. parachutes cincy 14
    23. all those yesterdays cincy 14
    24. leash cincy 06
    -------------------------------
    25. given to fly cincy 14
    26. baba o'riley cincy 06
    27. smile lexington 16
    28. leaving here lexington 16
    29. sonic reducer tampa 16
    ------------------------------
    30. the real me cincy 14
    31. rocking in the free world jax 16
    32. little wing tampa 16
    2006 Cincinnati
    2014 Cincinnati Memphis
    2016 Tampa Jacksonville Greenville Lexington Chicago N1 Chicago N2
  • Options
    EnterThanmanEnterThanman London, ON Posts: 1,057
    I would die a very happy man if I got to see Lifted's set list. I'll totally nerd out on this when I have a minute. Cool challenge!
    The member formerly known as Scratched Vinyl
  • Options
    EP1973EP1973 Posts: 111
    1. Long Road (VA Beach 08)
    2. Corduroy (VA Beach 08)
    3. Animal (Lexington 16)
    4. Jeremy (Honolulu 92)
    5. Deep (Lexington 16)
    6. Even Flow (Honolulu 92)
    7. State of Love and Trust (Honolulu 92)
    8. Mind Your Manners (C'Ville 13)
    9. Daughter (It's OK) (Cleveland 06)
    10. Given To Fly (VA Beach 08)
    11. Immortality (Cleveland 06)
    12. Spin the Black Circle (Lexington 16)
    13. Sirens (C'Ville 13)
    14. Not For You (Charlotte 13)
    15. Wishlist (VA Beach 08)
    16. Insignificance (VA Beach 08)
    17. Unthought Known (Charlotte 13)
    18. Inside Job (Cleveland 06)
    19. Rearviewmirror (C'Ville 13)
    ______
    20. Alive (Cleveland 06)
    21. Off He Goes (Charlotte 13)
    22. Sleight of Hand (C'Ville 13)
    23. Guaranteed (VA Beach 08)
    24. Do the Evolution (Lexington 16)
    25. Sonic Reducer (Lexington 16)
    ______
    26. Small Town (Charlotte 13)
    27. Fuckin' Up (Cleveland 06)
    28. Black (Charlotte 13)
    29. Sad (C'Ville 13)
    30. Better Man (Lexington 16)
    31. Breath (C'Ville 13)
    32. Rockin' in the Free World (Honolulu 92)

    (I've only been to 6 shows...but they were 6 good ones.)
  • Options
    Micheyb21Micheyb21 UK Posts: 240
    Great challenge and wow not easy.

    1 nothing as it seems - cardiff 2000
    2 corduroy - paris 2006
    3 once - MSG2 2016
    4 hail hail - toronto 2011
    5 red mosquito - cardiff 2000
    6 sad - toronto 2011
    7 elderly woman - wrigley 2013
    8 evenflow - MSG1 2016
    9 given to fly - amsterdam 2014
    10 in hiding - MSG1 2016
    11 thumbing my way - Paris 2006
    12 garden - toronto 2011
    13 light years - cardiff 2000
    14 love boat captain - paris 2006
    15 lightning bolt - wrigley 2013
    16 leash - MSG2 2016
    17 SOLAT - toronto 2011
    18 Porch - amsterdam 2014

    19 low light - amsterdam 2014
    20 last kiss - toronto 2011
    21 present tense - MSG2 2016
    22 footsteps - amsterdam 2014
    23 go - paris 2006
    24 rvm - wrigley 2013
    25 betterman - amsterdam 2014
    26 mother - wrigley 2013

    27 alive - toronto 2011
    28 kick out the jams - toronto 2011
    29 lukin - MK 2014
    30 Baba - MSG2 2016
    31 YLB - MSG2 2016
    32 Indifference - amsterdam 2014
    2000 Cardiff/ 2006 Paris/ 2011 Toronto/ 2013 Chicago/ 2014 Amsterdam 1 & Milton Keynes, 
    2016 MSG 1 & 2/ 2017 London Ed solo/ 2018 London 1, Padua, Rome, Prague & London 2
    2019 Dusseldorf & Dublin Ed Solo  
    2022 Copenhagen, London 1&2, Budapest, Krakow, Vienna, Prague, Ams 1 & Ams 2
    2024 Manchester, London, Auckland & Sydney
  • Options
    2-feign-reluctance2-feign-reluctance TigerTown, USA Posts: 23,141
    Paging @NHiding
    www.cluthelee.com
  • Options
    ed243421ed243421 Posts: 7,631
    1. Go - red rocks 6.19.1995
    2. Last exit - red rocks 6.19.1995
    3. DTE - Boston 9.29.04
    4. All night - pj20 night 2
    5. Tremor Christ - Augusta 9.26.1996
    6. Faithfull - pj20 night 1
    7. Oceans - Philly 4.29.2016
    8. Love boat captain - Philly 4.28.2016
    9. Given to fly - Philly 4.28.2016
    10. Insignificance - Boston 5.25.2006
    11. Red mosquito - Worcester 10.15.2013
    12. Corduroy - Wrigley
    13. Present tense - Denver 10.22.2014
    14. Undone - Boston 5.17.2010
    15. In hiding - Mansfield 9.15.1998
    16. Of the earth - Denver 10.22.2014
    17. Other side - Worcester 10.16.2013
    18. Betterman - pj20 night 1

    Encore 1
    19. New song - pj20 night 2
    20. All or none - Philly 4.29.2016
    21. Blood - Augusta 9.26.1996
    22. No way - pj20 night 2
    23. Fatal - Worcester 10.15.2013
    24. Footsteps - Mansfield 6.30.2008
    25. Porch - Hartford 10.25.2013

    Encore 2
    26. Save you - Philly 4.28.2016
    27. Breath - Denver 10.22.2014
    28. Leash - Boston 5.25.2006
    29. RVM - Denver 10.22.2014
    30. Once - Denver 10.22.2014
    31. Baba o'riley - Philly 4.29.2016
    32. YL/SSB - Philly 4.29.2016
    The whole world will be different soon... - EV
    RED ROCKS 6-19-95
    AUGUSTA 9-26-96
    MANSFIELD 9-15-98
    BOSTON 9-29-04
    BOSTON 5-25-06
    MANSFIELD 6-30-08
    EV SOLO BOSTON 8-01-08
    BOSTON 5-17-10
    EV SOLO BOSTON 6-16-11
    PJ20 9-3-11
    PJ20 9-4-11
    WRIGLEY 7-19-13
    WORCESTER 10-15-13
    WORCESTER 10-16-13
    HARTFORD 10-25-13









  • Options
    goldrushgoldrush everybody knows this is nowhere Posts: 7,274
    1 - Nothing As it Seems (Cardiff 2000)
    2 - Go (Finsbury Park 1993)
    3 - Corduroy (Shepherd's Bush 2009)
    4 - All Night (MSG I 2008)
    5 - Red Mosquito (Cardiff 2000)
    6 - Jeremy (Finsbury Park 1993)
    7 - Sad (Astoria 2006)
    8 - Even Flow (Manchester I 2012)
    9 - Given To Fly (Lollapalooza 2007)
    10 - Rats/Ben (London 2009)
    11 - Hard To Imagine (The Vic 2007)
    12 - Not For You Lollapalooza 2007)
    13 - Who You Are (MSG II 2008)
    14 - Better Man (Reading 2006)
    15 - Black (London 2009)
    16 – Why Go (Manchester I 2012)

    ENCORE 1
    17 - Down (Newcastle 2006)
    18 - Footsteps (Sydney 2014)
    19 - Low Light (The Vic 2007)
    20 - Hitchhiker (Manchester II 2012)
    21 - Crown Of Thorns (Reading 2006)
    22 - Masters Of War (Newcastle 2006)
    23 - Alive (Reading 2006)

    ENCORE 2
    24 - State Of Love And Trust (Shepherd's Bush 2009)
    25 - Alone (Newcastle 2006)
    26 - Smile (Cardiff 2000)
    27 - Black Diamond (MSG II 2008)
    28 - Fuckin' Up (Newcastle 2006)
    29 - All Along The Watchtower (MSG I 2008)
    30 - Indifference (MSG I 2008)
    31 - Rockin' In The Free World (Sydney 2014)
    32 - Yellow Ledbetter (Manchester II 2012)

    That was a lot of fun, but damn it was tough! I've used at least 2 songs from each of my 15 shows except The Astoria (awesome show but too many clashes) but I haven't actually seen a 32-song show so Indifference, RITFW and YL were all set closers at different shows.

    The hardest ones for me to chose were the opener - I had to chose between NAIS, All Or None, Hard To Imagine, and Alive (at one point I was tempted to open and close Set 1 with Alive!) - and song 10 where I had Army Reserve, I Am Mine, Off He Goes, Rats and Nothingman to pick from.

    Cool challenge OP :)
    “Do not postpone happiness”
    (Jeff Tweedy, Sydney 2007)

    “Put yer good money on the sunrise”
    (Tim Rogers)
  • Options
    NHidingNHiding Posts: 1,899

    You should put this challenge to The Rob.

    will definitely try to get to this sometime soon.
  • Options
    markymark550markymark550 Columbia, SC Posts: 5,104
    My best attempt at this:

    1. Sometimes (Charlotte 2000/Charlotte 2003)
    2. Low Light (Charlotte 2013/Columbia 2016)
    3. Corduroy (Charlotte 2000)
    4. Hail Hail (Charlotte 2000/Columbia 2008)
    5. Animal (Charlotte 2000)
    6. Lightning Bolt (Charlotte 2013)
    7. In Hiding (Charlotte 2003)
    8. Given to Fly (Charlotte 2000/Columbia 2016)
    9. Immortality (Columbia 2016)
    10. Daughter (Charlotte 2013)
    11. Light Years (Columbia 2016)
    12. Even Flow (Charlotte 2000)
    13. Whipping (Columbia 2008)
    14. Not For You (Charlotte 2013)
    15. I Got Shit (Columbia 2016)
    16. Grievance (Charlotte 2003)
    17. Do the Evolution (Charlotte 2003/Columbia 2008)
    18. Spin the Black Circle (Greenville 2016)
    19. Rearviewmirror (Charlotte 2000)
    ---------------------------------------------------------------
    20. Future Days (Greenville 2016)
    21. Off He Goes (Charlotte 2013)
    22. Just Breathe (Charlotte 2013)
    23. Present Tense (Greenville 2016)
    24. Sonic Reducer (Charlotte 2003)
    25. Porch (Charlotte 2013/Columbia 2016)
    ----------------------------------------------------------------
    26. Chloe/Crown of Thorns (Columbia 2016)
    27. State of Love and Trust (Columbia 2016)
    28. Breath (Greenville 2016)
    29. Comatose (Greenville 2016)
    30. All Along the Watchtower (Charlotte 2013)
    31. Alive (Greenville 2016)
    32. Yellow Ledbetter (Greenville 2016) -- technically this came as song 33 that night, but am bumping up a slot because I'd rather end with YL than Baba


    That was tough. I like the flow of this hypothetical show, but in order to get that I had to leave out some great songs and some rarities that everyone loves to get. I also had to resist the urge to do the Greenville Vs set.

  • Options
    DW139059DW139059 Posts: 353
    CHALLENGE!! :rock_on:
    Charlotte '96
    Raleigh '03
    Charlotte '13
    Cincinnati '14
    Greenville '16, Columbia '16
    Nashville '22
  • Options
    DW139059DW139059 Posts: 353
    So heres how mine shook out...

    1 Oceans Columbia 2106
    2 Go Greenville 2016
    3 Save You Raleigh 2003
    4 Help Help Raleigh 2003
    5 Hail, Hail Charlotte 1996
    6 Dissident Greenville 2016
    7 W.M.A. Greenville 2016
    8 Severed Hand Charlotte 2013
    9 Even Flow Cincinnati 2014
    10 Rats Greenville 2016
    11 Getaway Charlotte 2013
    12 You Are Raleigh 2003
    13 Indifference Greenville 2016
    14 Insignificance Raleigh 2003
    15 Swallowed Whole Greenville 2016
    16 Jeremy Cincinnati 2014
    17 Let The Records Play Greenville 2016
    18 Rearviewmirror Charlotte 2013

    ENCORE 1
    19 Gimme Some Truth Raleigh 2003
    20 Man Of The Hour Cincinnati 2014
    21 Corduroy Columbia 2106
    22 Better Man Raleigh 2003
    23 Comfortably Numb Greenville 2016
    24 Given To Fly Cincinnati 2014
    25 Unthought Known Cincinnati 2014
    26 Porch Charlotte 2013

    ENCORE 2
    27 Fortunate Son Raleigh 2003
    28 The Real Me Charlotte 2013
    29 State Of Love And Trust Columbia 2106
    30 Alive Charlotte 2013
    31 All Along The Watchtower Charlotte 2013
    32 Yellow Ledbetter Cincinnati 2014
    A little Vs. heavy from Greenville, but I had not seen a lot of those songs. Broke it down to all 1st set songs, then all 1st encore songs, etc... (ex. Gimme Some Truth was actually 18th song played in Raleigh, but I compared it to other 1st encore openers instead.) Interested to make this a playlist and see how it flows! :triumph:
    Charlotte '96
    Raleigh '03
    Charlotte '13
    Cincinnati '14
    Greenville '16, Columbia '16
    Nashville '22
  • Options
    Merkin BallerMerkin Baller Posts: 10,475
    This is a cool idea, I'm looking forward to sitting down with this tonight & figuring it out!
  • Options
    BrainofBGABrainofBGA Australia Posts: 3,912
    This might take a little time
    Melbourne #1 '98
    Melbourne #2 '03
    Melbourne #3 '03
    Melbourne #1 '06
    Melbourne #3 '06
    Melbourne '09
    Melbourne '14
  • Options
    BrainofBGABrainofBGA Australia Posts: 3,912
    edited May 2016
    1. Long Road...Melb 98
    2. Corduroy...Melb 06
    3. Animal...Melb 09
    4. Getaway....Melb 14
    5. Dissident...Melb 98
    6. Mind Your Manners...Melb 14
    7. Low Light...Melb 14
    8. Even Flow...Melb 03
    9. Marker in the Sand...Melb 06
    10. Lightning Bolt...Melb 14
    11. Sad...Melb 06
    12. Present Tense...Melb 09
    13. Save You...Melb 06
    14. Last Exit...Melb 98
    15. I Got ID...Melb 03
    16. Given To Fly...Melb 14
    17. Once...Melb 03
    18. Do the Evolution...Melb 09

    Encore

    19. Needle and the Damage Done...Melb 09
    20. Sleight of Hand...Melb 03
    21. Red Mosquito...Melb 09
    22. Smile...Melb 98
    23. Go...Melb 14
    24. Deep...Melb 09
    25. Why Go...Melb 09
    26. Porch...Melb 09

    27. Throw Your Arms Around Me..Melb 09
    28. Black...Melb 09
    29. Spin the Black Circle...Melb 09
    30. Alive...Melb 09
    31. Baba O'Riley...Melb 09
    32. Yellow Ledbetter...Melb 09

    All 7 shows I've been too of course were in Melbourne.

    98 x 1 show
    03 x 2 shows
    06 x 2 shows
    09 x 1 show
    14 x 1 show

    On paper looks like a good show albeit a little predictable in terms of song order. 'Brother' was unlucky to miss spot 5, Dissident got the nod there.
    Post edited by BrainofBGA on
    Melbourne #1 '98
    Melbourne #2 '03
    Melbourne #3 '03
    Melbourne #1 '06
    Melbourne #3 '06
    Melbourne '09
    Melbourne '14
  • Options
    cojobocojobo Ontario Posts: 299
    1. Release (Wrigley '13)
    2. Hard to Imagine (Halifax '05) *** Drifting was the opener ;) ***
    3. Given To Fly (GCF '15) (DD#1)
    4. Hold On (Wrigley '13)
    5. Brain of J (Toronto '09)
    6. Sad (Toronto '11)
    7. Evolution (Buffalo '13) (DD#2)
    8. Immortallity (Buffalo '13)
    9. Tremor Christ (Leeds '14)
    10. Go (Halifax '05)
    11. Of the Girl (Toronto 1 '16)
    12. Ghost (Leeds '14)
    13. Once (Buffalo '13)
    14. Not for You (London '13)
    15. Present Tense(Toronto 2 '11)
    16. Parting Ways (Toronto 1 '16) ***hate the placement but has to be in...***
    17. Last Exit (London '13)
    18 SOLAT (Buffalo '13)
    19 Porch (Buffalo '13) (DD#3) *** CLOSE: END OF SET 1

    ENCORE 1:
    20 Oceans (Toronto 2 '16)
    21. Let Me Sleep (Toronto 1 '16)
    22. Breath (Toronto 2 '16)
    23. Love Reign (Ottawa '16)
    24. All or None (Leeds '14)
    25 Fatal (Leeds '14)
    26 Rearviewmirror (Buffalo '13) (DD#4) *** CLOSE: END OF ENCORE 1

    ENCORE 2:

    27. Better Man (Toronto 2 '16) (DD#5)
    28. Crown of Thorns (Wrigley '13)
    29. Alive (Ottawa '16) (DD#6)
    30. Fuckin' Up (Ottawa '16)
    31. Baba O'Riley (Detroit '14)
    32. Rockin' In the Free World (Wrigley '13) *** CLOSE: END OF ENCORE 2
    Halifax '05, Toronto '09, Toronto 2 '11, Hamilton '11, London '13, Chicago '13. Buffalo '13 , Leeds '14, Detroit '14, New York (GCF) '15, Ottawa '16, Toronto 1 '16, Toronto 2 '16
  • Options
    cojobocojobo Ontario Posts: 299
    1. Release (Wrigley '13)
    2. Hard to Imagine (Halifax '05) *** Drifting was the opener ;) ***
    3. Given To Fly (GCF '15) (DD#1)
    4. Hold On (Wrigley '13)
    5. Brain of J (Toronto '09)
    6. Sad (Toronto '11)
    7. Evolution (Buffalo '13) (DD#2)
    8. Immortallity (Buffalo '13)
    9. Tremor Christ (Leeds '14)
    10. Go (Halifax '05)
    11. Of the Girl (Toronto 1 '16)
    12. Ghost (Leeds '14)
    13. Once (Buffalo '13)
    14. Not for You (London '13)
    15. Present Tense(Toronto 2 '11)
    16. Parting Ways (Toronto 1 '16) ***hate the placement but has to be in...***
    17. Last Exit (London '13)
    18 SOLAT (Buffalo '13)
    19 Porch (Buffalo '13) (DD#3) *** CLOSE: END OF SET 1

    ENCORE 1:
    20 Oceans (Toronto 2 '16)
    21. Let Me Sleep (Toronto 1 '16)
    22. Breath (Toronto 2 '16)
    23. Love Reign (Ottawa '16)
    24. All or None (Leeds '14)
    25 Fatal (Leeds '14)
    26 Rearviewmirror (Buffalo '13) (DD#4) *** CLOSE: END OF ENCORE 1

    ENCORE 2:

    27. Better Man (Toronto 2 '16) (DD#5)
    28. Crown of Thorns (Wrigley '13)
    29. Alive (Ottawa '16) (DD#6)
    30. Fuckin' Up (Ottawa '16)
    31. Baba O'Riley (Detroit '14)
    32. Rockin' In the Free World (Wrigley '13) *** CLOSE: END OF ENCORE 2
    Halifax '05, Toronto '09, Toronto 2 '11, Hamilton '11, London '13, Chicago '13. Buffalo '13 , Leeds '14, Detroit '14, New York (GCF) '15, Ottawa '16, Toronto 1 '16, Toronto 2 '16
  • Options
    mcgruff10mcgruff10 New Jersey Posts: 27,849
    pretty easy:
    09/29/96 – Downing Stadium (Randall’s Island): New York, NY [168m]

    set: Sometimes, Go, Spin the Black Circle, Hail Hail, Animal, Tremor Christ, Who You Are, Corduroy, Lukin, Better Man, Not for You, Jeremy (new), Once, Rats, Last Exit, Habit, Rearviewmirror, Immortality, Whipping, I Got Shit, Black, Alive, Porch
    enc 1: In My Tree, Even Flow, Daughter/(The Real Me)/(ABitW)/(WMA), Mankind, Long Road, Leaving Here
    enc 2: Off He Goes, Present Tense, Yellow Ledbetter

    there's my perfect show (and my first one too).
    I'll ride the wave where it takes me......
  • Options
    pepsigatorspepsigators St. John's, NL Posts: 182
    edited May 2016
    I'm home sick today so i'll give this a try. I won't include the Pre-set from Toronto 2009 but i'm tempted too. This was very difficult. Had to leave out Let me sleep!

    Main Set:
    1. Of the Girl - (Toronto, 2009)
    2. Go - (St. John's 1, 2005)
    3. Animal - (St. John's 2, 2005)
    4. Save You - (Ottawa, 2016)
    5. Brain of J - (Toronto, 2009)
    6. Garden - (Toronto 2, 2016)
    7. Deep - (Ottawa, 2016)
    8. Nothing as it Seems - (Toronto 1, 2016)
    9. Off He Goes - (Toronto, 2009)
    10.Even Flow - (4 Times in this spot)
    11. You Are - (St. John's 2, 2005)
    12. Faithfull - (Toronto, 2009)
    13. I got Shit - (St. John's 2, 2005)
    14. Present Tense - (Toronto 2, 2016)
    15. Alone - (Toronto 2, 2016)
    16. Parting Ways - (Toronto 1, 2016)
    17. Not for You - (Toronto, 2009)
    18. Once - (Toronto 1, 2016)
    19. Rearviewmirror - (Toronto 1, 2016)

    Encore 1:
    20. Oceans - (Toronto 2, 2016)
    21. Light Years - (St. John's 2, 2005)
    22. Breath - (Toronto 2, 2016)
    23. Love Reign O'er Me - (Ottawa, 2016)
    24.Betterman - (Ottawa, 2016)
    25. Blood - (Ottawa, 2016)

    Encore 2:
    26. Last Exit - (Toronto 2, 2016)
    27. Elderly Woman - (Toronto 1, 2016)
    28. Black - (Ottawa, 2016)
    29. State of Love and Trust - (Toronto 1, 2016)
    30. Alive - (Toronto 2, 2016)
    31. Baba O'Riley - (Toronto 2, 2016)
    32. F*ckin' Up - (Ottawa, 2016)
    Post edited by pepsigators on
  • Options
    BrainofBGABrainofBGA Australia Posts: 3,912
    mcgruff10 said:

    pretty easy:
    09/29/96 – Downing Stadium (Randall’s Island): New York, NY [168m]

    set: Sometimes, Go, Spin the Black Circle, Hail Hail, Animal, Tremor Christ, Who You Are, Corduroy, Lukin, Better Man, Not for You, Jeremy (new), Once, Rats, Last Exit, Habit, Rearviewmirror, Immortality, Whipping, I Got Shit, Black, Alive, Porch
    enc 1: In My Tree, Even Flow, Daughter/(The Real Me)/(ABitW)/(WMA), Mankind, Long Road, Leaving Here
    enc 2: Off He Goes, Present Tense, Yellow Ledbetter

    there's my perfect show (and my first one too).

    Never heard this show but from the set alone this need to be a vault release!! Was hoping they'd do this one if there was a no code / yield box.
    Melbourne #1 '98
    Melbourne #2 '03
    Melbourne #3 '03
    Melbourne #1 '06
    Melbourne #3 '06
    Melbourne '09
    Melbourne '14
Sign In or Register to comment.