Options
When exactly did PJ re-record old tunes for Lost Dogs?
ForceofNature101
Posts: 1,190
Dirty Frank, Wash, Alone, Drifting, Hard To Imagine, and Hold On all seem to be at the time recent recordings but I could never pinpoint the year they were recorded
Dirty Frank, Wash, Alone, and Hold On were all recorded in various forms in the early 90's (Hold On being the acoustic recording and the instrumental demos from that time) and a version of Hard to Imagine was included to a movie soundtrack yet none of these versions are included on Lost Dogs
Dirty Frank, Wash, Alone, and Hold On were all recorded in various forms in the early 90's (Hold On being the acoustic recording and the instrumental demos from that time) and a version of Hard to Imagine was included to a movie soundtrack yet none of these versions are included on Lost Dogs
Post edited by Unknown User on
0
Comments
Alone: New vocals added to Ten era version, not the b-side for "Go"
Undone: New guitar solo
Hold On: New vocals. Note: A ten demo or rough mix exists that can be considered a completely separate version.
Hard to Imagine: Original vocals from Vs. era. The Chicago Cab version has different vocals for the verses and chorus recorded maybe around No Code. The "Things were different..." portion is identical to the original, however.
Footsteps: Added harmonica
Wash: alt. version from same time period as the original
Drifting: New vocals
Dirty Frank: Deleted some vocals from the original that Ed probably felt embarrassed of (Shut your mouth!)
Brother: New guitar, of course
I'm sure there are other things but that's all I can remember right now.
Pearl Jam bootlegs:
http://wegotshit.blogspot.com
Alone is the only track from LD that really bothers me. I really prefer the b-side version.
This was my source for HTI. Old interview with Jeff. The Chicago Cab version is still identical to the Lost Dogs except for vocals for the first half of the song. Maybe I should go back and listen to them again. I could be wrong.
Well, there are definitely a couple of "Holy Grail" Pearl Jam tracks. "Hard To Imagine" was one for awhile.
JA: We recorded it first during "Vs.," then again later on. I think it might have been "No Code." I think that's the version that ended up on [the soundtrack to the film] "Chicago Cab."
Hard to Imagine, U, Footsteps etc... love the version off the original singles.
Question... are you saying that there are THREE recorded versions of SOLAT? I.e. Singles, RVM, and Ten Re-issue? I had always assumed that the Singles and RVM versions where the same since I do not have the Singles soundtrack. Is the Singles version closer to the Ten reissue?
-Christopher Walken
you're=you are
your=showing ownership
The truth has a well known liberal bias.
-Stephen Colbert
Oh my lord!!!
So the only studio versions of SOLAT that you know are the super slow Ten reissue and the weird overproduced vocal & guitar effects version on RVM?!
You need to listen to the Singles version right now!
I mean, literally stop whatever you are doing and go online or wherever and listen to the Singles version RIGHT NOW!!
I kind of dig the vibe of the Ten reissue as it is obviously at the demo stage so that's cool but the RVM version of SOLAT is the only PJ recording of a song I know for a fact I will never ever listen to again.
You are going to be bouncing when you hear the Singles version! :thumbup:
Dave Fucking Abruzzese
-Christopher Walken
you're=you are
your=showing ownership
The truth has a well known liberal bias.
-Stephen Colbert
FYI- the vocals on Walter's Walk was done in 1983
Totally agree. Here ckravitz, here's the original versions of SOLAT and Breath from the Singles movie soundtrack. Everything stinkfoot said about SOLAT applies to Breath as well:
http://depositfiles.com/files/rf32s4knj
Pearl Jam bootlegs:
http://wegotshit.blogspot.com
Haha! Ok, I am downloading from Ledbetterman10's link right now. Thanks!
Thank you! Just downloaded.... going to unpack and listen now! Thanks again!
The soundtrack CD has the same recording as remixed by Brendan O'Brien.
You're welcome. Enjoy, they're certainly the best versions of those two songs.
Pearl Jam bootlegs:
http://wegotshit.blogspot.com
Alone - it sounds indeed like someone here said that they took the instrumental performance from the first take (the non-Go single studio version) and added new vocals and were able to remix the tune so it sounded modern. The guitar parts and drum fills are exactly the same
Dirty Frank sounds like the instrumental is the same take but the mix was heavily altered so it sounds more modern for 2003 standards and heavier like Alone and again with more 'recent' vocals
Now I am curious as to when those vocals were recorded? I am guessing 2003 or near the release of the album although I do like these vocals more than the takes on the songs on Riot Act
the mix is different, and that little toy-piano-sounding part (for lack of a better description) is audible in the chorus, but i'm pretty sure it's the same recording with new vox from eddie.
i know the liner notes say matt played drums on it, but i swear that's a mistake. that is jack, and i'm almost positive that it's the same drum track as the original.
http://www.theskyiscrape.com/2009/04/ob ... trust.html
I need to read the book again from Singles soundtrack and the rvm compilation. I read somewhere that the rvm version is the version they used to the film, when Linda goes to the club with her friend and they dance SOLAT.
Seeya!
spived
I got some if you need it
Say it aint so!
I think Alone suffered the most on Lost Dogs from the original.
Hey thanks for sharing. Pretty cool. I didn't realize the Krusen version is on the reissue. Have to respectfully disagree with Jeff though, the Dave A version destroys the original.
As a drummer and a fan of Jack, the drums in the Lost Dogs version of U are not Jack! Close but no sitar.
Liner notes state Matt. It is Matt. Compare the two versions.
The LD version of Brother is OK, I like the Ten reissue better because of the lyrics, but the fade out is a buzz killer... is there any other version? can I get the demo version from gremmie?
Which version is the one where he says "40 shades of gray" instead of "only gray" ?
If I opened it now would you not understand?