Home› The Porch
Options

Create your all time rock band lineup

TunnelThroughDenialTunnelThroughDenial Posts: 767
edited February 2008 in The Porch
OK guys - I am bored tonight and this is a discussion I have with friends to inspire plenty of debate and argument.

** If you could hand pick the all time lineup of a new band made up of the best musicians, artists, and songwriters of all time who would you pick? **

Here are some ground rules I would like to follow:

1) Your band may be comprised of anyone alive or dead, male or female, etc.

2) You are limited to 5 band members

3) Your band should probably contain a drummer, bass player, a guitarist or two (or keys), and a singer so they can put on a legitimate performance - in other words, you can't pick all guitar players because those are your favorites of all time

4) Band members may be a double or triple threat so if everyone sings and plays their instruments that is fine. So if Eric Clapton, John Lennon, and Ed were in your dream band they could take turns singing but all can play their guitars

5) You should consider band chemistry as well as songwriting. Someone needs to come up with material and they need to get along in theory at some level. Imagine they are required to at least write and record one album of new material and pull off one tour (and dead people are considered resurrected as though they were never dead)....

6) Be creative

Hope this is fun and interesting.........If it's been done already here sorry - I searched and didn't see anything...
|9.5.93Gorge|2.6.95Moore|5.7.98AROSpace|7.21.98Seattle|7.22.98Seattle|10.21.00PHX|11.5.00Seattle
|11.6.00Seattle|6.6.03Vegas|6.7.03PHX|5.25.06Boston|7.22.06Gorge|7.23.06Gorge|9.21.09Seattle|9.22.09Seattle |10.6.09LA|11.19.13PHX|11.29.13Portland|12.6.13Seattle |10.22.14Denver| 8.8.18 Seattle | 8.10.18 Seattle

EV Solo |7.15.11 Benaroya|7.16.11 Benaroya|4.13.12PHX|10.30.14Redmond|
TOTD 11.11.16 San Fran
Post edited by Unknown User on
«13

Comments

  • Options
    nicksmith33nicksmith33 Posts: 38
    Hmmm, interesting thought. Just off the top of my head I'm going to say Ed, Jimmy Hendrix, John Lennon, Flea, and the drummer from Velvet Revolver/G n R (can't remember his name, Matt something). Not that I have a real strong opinion about most of these, just seems pretty cool off the top of my head.
  • Options
    Kevin DavisKevin Davis Posts: 70
    My dream band already exists:

    Ed Vedder: vocals and guitar
    Jeff Ament: bass
    Stone Gossard: guitar
    Mike McCready: guitar
    Matt Cameron: drums

    Those supergroups never work out, anyway. Too many egos.
  • Options
    stylo17stylo17 Posts: 1,001
    John Entwistle
    Eddie Vedder
    Neil Young
    Keith Moon
    John Frusciante

    in no particular order

    but i definitely like those all those guys in that group, Pearl Jam, they're alright.
    6/11/08 WPB


    ♬♪♫ and I will not, grow tired of crayon stars and fire

    ♬♪♫ cause a soldier's death is so much better than defeat just hanging around
  • Options
    PJammer4lifePJammer4life Los Angeles Posts: 2,591
    Eddie Vedder (Vocals and Guitar)
    Dave Grohl(Guitar and Drums)
    Billy Corgan (Rhythm Guitar)
    The Edge (Lead Guitar)
    Jeff Ament (Bass Guitar)
    Bridge Benefit 1994, San Francisco 1995, San Diego 1995 1 & 2, Missoula 1998, Los Angeles 2000, San Diego 2000, Eddie Vedder/Beck 2/26/2002, Santa Barbara 2003, Irvine 2003, San Diego 2003, Vancouver 2005, Gorge 2005, San Diego 2006, Los Angeles 2006 1 & 2, Santa Barbara 2006, Eddie Vedder 4/10/08, Eddie Vedder 4/12/08, Eddie Vedder 4/15/08, 7/12/2008, SF 8/28/09, LA 9/30/09, LA 10/1/09, LA 10/06/09, LA 10/07/09, San Diego 10/09/09, Eddie Vedder 7/6/2011, Eddie Vedder 7/8/2011, PJ20 9/3/2011, PJ20 9/4/2011, Vancouver 9/25/2011, San Diego 11/21/13, LA 11/24/13, Ohana 9/25/21, Ohana 9/26/21, Ohana 10/1/21, EV 2/17/22, LA Forum 5/6/22, LA Forum 5/7/22, EV 10/1/22, EV 9/30/23
  • Options
    jsnleejsnlee Posts: 11
    I'll just take Zeppelin in their prime
  • Options
    MrStyles420MrStyles420 Posts: 272
    Ed Vedder- Vocals/Guitar
    Kirk Hammet- Lead Guitar
    George Harrison-Guitar/ Background Vocal (occasionally lead vocals)
    John Paul Jones- Bass/Keys
    Max Weinberg- Drums
    '06- Irving Plaza (What a way to see my first PJ concert), Albany, Hartford, Camden I & II, East Rutherford I & II, Pittsburgh

    '07- THE VIC!!!, Lollapalooza (Chicago)

    '08- Virginia Beach, Camden I & II, Washington D.C., MSG I & II, Hartford, Mansfield I & II,
    EV NY I & II, Newark, DC I & II
  • Options
    walkunafraidwalkunafraid Posts: 2,557
    Jeff Buckley (vocals) -- sorry Ed
    Nels Cline (guitar)
    Prince (guitar)
    Jimi Hendrix (guitar)
    Glen Kotche (drums)

    I win.
    Everything has chains...Absolutely nothing's changed. - PJ

    “The only way to deal with an unfree world is to become so absolutely free that your very existence is an act of rebellion.” - Albert Camus
  • Options
    Them-BonesThem-Bones Posts: 518
    Layne Staley-Vocals
    Mike McCready-Guitar
    Jerry Cantrell-Guitar/Vocals
    Les Claypool-Bass/Vocals
    Dave Grohl-Drums
    "If my thoughts, dreams, could be seen, they'd probably put my head, in a guillotine, but it's alright ma, it's life and life only."
  • Options
    ChadsStillAliveChadsStillAlive Indianapolis Posts: 450
    Props. I enjoy this concept immensely.

    My band:

    John Lennon: Vocals/Guitars/Keyboard
    Eddie Vedder: Vocals/Guitars
    Jimmy Page: Lead Guitar
    Roger Waters: Vocals/Bass/Keyboard
    Keith Moon: Drums

    A piece of The Beatles, Pearl Jam, Led Zeppelin, Pink Floyd, and The Who all in the same band?? Pssshhhhhh.... Ridiculous.

    My second team:

    Bob Dylan: Vocals/Guitars/Harmonica
    Paul McCartney: Vocals/Bass/Guitars/Piano
    Jimi Hendrix: Vocals/Lead Guitar
    Stone Gossard: Guitars
    Danny Carey: Drums
    I am lost, I'm no guide, but I'm by your side.
    I am right by your side.
  • Options
    Oz JammerOz Jammer Posts: 9,858
    Eddie Vedder (Lead Vocals & Guitar)
    Pete Townshend (Lead Guitar & Backing Vocals)
    John Bonham (Drums/Percussion)
    Flea (Bass & Backing Vocals)
    Ray Manzarek (Keyboard)

    Now THAT'S a band!!!
  • Options
    randaldoesjerseyrandaldoesjersey Posts: 151
    PJammer4life wrote:
    Eddie Vedder (Vocals and Guitar)
    Dave Grohl(Guitar and Drums)
    Billy Corgan (Rhythm Guitar)
    The Edge (Lead Guitar)
    Jeff Ament (Bass Guitar)

    lol
  • Options
    South of SeattleSouth of Seattle West Seattle Posts: 10,708
    Drums - ?uestlove
    Drums # 2 - Stephen Perkins
    Bass - Mike Watt
    Lead Guitar - John Frusciante
    Rhythm Guitar/Vocals - Ben Harper
    NERDS!
  • Options
    hiding103006hiding103006 Posts: 452
    steve winwood (vocal; traffic)
    jimi hendrix (lead guitar)
    brad whitford (rhythym guitar; aerosmith)
    les claypool (bass; primus)
    keith moon (drums; the who)
    Camden 7-5-2003, Camden 7-6-2003, Hershey 7-12-2003, Camden 5-27-2006, Camden 5-28-2006, Lollapalooza 8-5-2007, Camden 6-19-2008, Camden 6-20-2008, New York 6-24-2008, New York 6-25-2008, Mansfield 6-28-2008, Mansfield 6-30-2008
  • Options
    restlesssoulrestlesssoul Posts: 6,939
    keith moon
    jimmy page
    flea
    robertplant
    stone
    Van '98, Sea I+II '00, Sea '01, Sea II '02, Van '03, Gorge, Van, Cal, Edm '05, Bos I+II, Phi I+II, DC, SF II+III, Port, Gorge I+II '06, DC, NY I+II '08, Sea I+II, Van, Ridge , LA III+IV' 09, Indy '10, Cal, Van '11, Lond, Van, Sea '13, Memphis '14, RRHOF '17, Sea I+II '18
  • Options
    hiding103006hiding103006 Posts: 452
    walkunafraid wrote:
    Jeff Buckley (vocals) -- sorry Ed
    Nels Cline (guitar)
    Prince (guitar)
    Jimi Hendrix (guitar)
    Glen Kotche (drums)

    I win.
    this is awesome - jeff buckley is such an unsung hero - i wish he had/got more pub...
    Camden 7-5-2003, Camden 7-6-2003, Hershey 7-12-2003, Camden 5-27-2006, Camden 5-28-2006, Lollapalooza 8-5-2007, Camden 6-19-2008, Camden 6-20-2008, New York 6-24-2008, New York 6-25-2008, Mansfield 6-28-2008, Mansfield 6-30-2008
  • Options
    jamhotgammonjamhotgammon Posts: 39
    i know i'm not being very inventive here, but i have to say Zep in their prime also :D
    http://www.myspace.com/heavyloadrocks
  • Options
    dunkmandunkman Posts: 19,646
    Vocals & Guitar.......Ed Vedder
    Rhythm & Vocals.....John Lennon
    Lead & Vocals.........Jack White
    Drums...................John Bonham
    Bass & Vocals.........Paul McCartney
    oh scary... 40000 morbidly obese christians wearing fanny packs invading europe is probably the least scariest thing since I watched an edited version of The Care Bears movie in an extremely brightly lit cinema.
  • Options
    JulienJulien Posts: 2,457
    Kevin Davis wrote:
    My dream band already exists:

    Ed Vedder: vocals and guitar
    Jeff Ament: bass
    Stone Gossard: guitar
    Mike McCready: guitar
    Matt Cameron: drums

    Those supergroups never work out, anyway. Too many egos.
    my vote goes forthe same band
    2006: Antwerp, Paris
    2007: Copenhagen, Werchter
    2009: Rotterdam, London
    2010: MSG, Arras, Werchter
    2012: Amsterdam, Prague, Berlin
    2014: Amsterdam, Stockholm
  • Options
    jamie ukjamie uk Posts: 3,812
    Robert Plant. vocals, harmonica, and pelvic thrusts.
    Malcolm Young. rythm guitar.
    Niel Young. Lead guitar.
    Shane Fitzsimons. Bass.
    Clive Dreamer. Drums, percussion.
    I came, I saw, I concurred.....
  • Options
    jamie ukjamie uk Posts: 3,812
    Julien wrote:
    my vote goes forthe same band

    Come on lads, that's lame. Why don't you play?
    I came, I saw, I concurred.....
  • Options
    PearlerPearler Posts: 191
    vocals - Bon Scott.
    lead guitar - Carlos Santana.
    rythmn guitar - Mike McCready.
    bass - Geezer Butler.
    drums - Mick Fleetwood.
  • Options
    Beck..Beck.. Posts: 535
    Ed vedder. Vocal/guitar
    Jimmy page. Lead guitar
    Mike mccready. Guitar/vocals
    Flea.bass Guitar
    John bonham. Drums
  • Options
    i like matt.ci like matt.c Posts: 1,121
    My band:
    Vocals: PJ Harvey
    Bass: Josh Homme
    Guitar: Chris Shiflett
    Drums: Matt Cameron

    I have other dream bands but this is near the top!
  • Options
    dunkmandunkman Posts: 19,646
    i like matt.c wrote:
    My band:
    Vocals: PJ Harvey
    Bass: Josh Homme
    Guitar: Chris Shiflett
    Drums: Matt Cameron

    I have other dream bands but this is near the top!


    wow!!!! Josh Homme on bass... :confused:
    oh scary... 40000 morbidly obese christians wearing fanny packs invading europe is probably the least scariest thing since I watched an edited version of The Care Bears movie in an extremely brightly lit cinema.
  • Options
    i like matt.ci like matt.c Posts: 1,121
    dunkman wrote:
    wow!!!! Josh Homme on bass... :confused:
    But of course, he played bass in Wellwater Conspiracy;)
  • Options
    alexross42alexross42 Posts: 364
    Jeff Buckley - Vocals/Guitar
    Danny Whitten - Lead Guitar/Vocals
    Stone Gossard - Rhythm Guitar/Vocals
    Rick Danko - Bass/Vocals
    John Bonham - Drums/Gurning

    Think of the harmonies you could have!
    My Music, 'Crowd of Oaks' - Spotify | Bandcamp

    Manchester 2000 :: Cardiff 2000 :: Prague 2006 :: London 2007 :: Manchester 2009 :: London 2009 :: Manchester I 2012 :: Manchester II 2012 :: Milton Keynes 2014 :: London I 2018 :: London II 2018

    *BRAD* Birmingham 2013 :: London 2013
  • Options
    JulienJulien Posts: 2,457
    jamie uk wrote:
    Come on lads, that's lame. Why don't you play?
    ok, let's play:

    vocals - Ed Vedder
    lead guitar - Neil Young
    rythmn guitar - Ben Harper
    bass - Flea (?) or the guy from Stone temple pilots
    drums - the guy from Incubus (don't know his name)
    2006: Antwerp, Paris
    2007: Copenhagen, Werchter
    2009: Rotterdam, London
    2010: MSG, Arras, Werchter
    2012: Amsterdam, Prague, Berlin
    2014: Amsterdam, Stockholm
  • Options
    Army & NavyArmy & Navy Posts: 120
    Dee Snider - Vocals
    Eddie Hazel - Lead Guitar
    Stone Gossard - Rhythm Guitar
    Gene Simmons - Bass Guitar
    Keith Moon - Drums
  • Options
    PJGARDENPJGARDEN Posts: 1,484
    Ed.....Vocals
    Keith Moon....drums
    Flea.......Bass
    Jimi Hendrix.....lead guitar
    Stone.....rthymn
  • Options
    EJE201EJE201 Mason, MI Posts: 319
    ED
    Tom Petty
    Prince
    Roger waters
    Dave Grohl
    Let's say knowledge is a tree,
    It's growing up just like me
Sign In or Register to comment.